My Teen Wants to Major in Medicine: What I Wish I’d Asked First
Last month, I was folding soccer laundry at the kitchen table while my 17-year-old Lila picked at a leftover pepperoni slice and flipped through a stack of college viewbooks. One glossy page had a group of grinning students in oversized white coats, and she pushed it across the table toward me. “I think I want to major in pre-med,” she said. I fumbled a pair of her cleat socks, and the first thing out of my mouth was, “Do you know how much school that is? And the debt? The MCAT is one of the hardest exams out there.” She closed the viewbook, said “never mind” and took her laptop up to her room, and we didn’t talk about it for three days.
I ran into our high school guidance counselor, Mrs. Henderson, at the grocery store a couple days later, and mentioned the exchange. She didn’t tell me I was wrong to worry, just noted that most parents jump to the risks first, before they even find out why their kid wants to pursue medicine in the first place. That hit me. I’d reacted out of my own secondhand fear of burnout and student debt, not out of curiosity about what Lila actually wanted. I decided to back up and try again.
I texted Lila that night, asked if she wanted to get mint chocolate chip after school the next day, no college talk unless she initiated it. She said yes. We sat on a splintered park bench overlooking the soccer fields, and she brought it up first. I started with the first question I should have asked from the start: “What made you think of medicine, anyway?”
She picked at her ice cream cone and said it was when I had that bad stomach flu last winter, and she came with me to the doctor because her dad was out of town. I was dizzy and could barely stand, and Dr. Rao, our family physician, didn’t just write me a prescription. She sat with Lila for five minutes after the appointment, asked how she was holding up taking care of me and her 10-year-old brother, and gave her a free granola bar from the front desk. No one had ever done that for her when we were going through a stressful time, she said. That’s the kind of person she wanted to be: someone who shows up for people when they’re scared.
That answer told me more than any “are you sure you’re smart enough” question ever could. Next I asked, “Have you seen what a full day of that actually looks like? Not just the 15-minute office visit we go to?” Lila admitted she hadn’t. I called Dr. Rao a few days later, asked if Lila could shadow her for a Saturday clinic, and she said yes. Most doctors are happy to let a local high schooler shadow for a day, it turns out; you just have to ask.
Lila came home that night exhausted, her feet sore from standing for 10 hours. She told me she had no idea Dr. Rao spent two full hours after the last patient doing insurance paperwork and returning patient messages. One patient yelled at her because they waited 20 minutes past their appointment time, and Lila had to step out of the room to give them privacy. But when I asked her what she thought, she just shrugged and said, “I still liked it. The paperwork isn’t fun, but talking to people was worth it.” That was more honest than any hypothetical conversation we could have had at the kitchen table.
After that, we talked about the next thing I never would have thought to frame nicely: alternatives. Instead of saying “what if you don’t get into med school,” which sounds like I don’t believe in her, I asked, “What parts of this interest you that you could do even if you end up not going to med school?” She thought about it for a minute and said she likes working with people, she likes science, and she cares a lot about kids having access to good healthcare. That opened the door to talking about flexible tracks: we looked up three in-state schools that let you complete pre-med requirements for the first two years, and switch seamlessly to a physician assistant program, nursing degree, or public health major without losing credits if you change your mind. Lila liked that option a lot; it took the pressure off feeling like one wrong choice on application day would ruin everything.
We also sat down for 15 minutes one night and looked up actual numbers, not just my vague fear of massive debt. We checked in-state medical school tuition, average starting salaries for family medicine (what Lila thinks she wants to do), and what kind of loan forgiveness programs are available for primary care doctors in rural or low-income areas. I didn’t throw the numbers at her to scare her; I just put them out there, so she was working with real information instead of the idealized version in the viewbook. She said she’s fine with taking 10 years to pay off loans, because she doesn’t care about having a big salary or a fancy house. That’s her call to make, not mine.
It’s been a month now. Lila volunteers four hours a week at the free clinic downtown, checking in patients and helping with intake. Last week she mentioned she thought pediatric public health sounded really interesting, and I didn’t panic. I just asked what part of it sounded good. We still don’t know if she’ll end up a doctor, or even in healthcare at all. She might change her mind three more times before she sends in her college applications. But now we’re talking about it, instead of her shutting down and me stressing. That’s enough for right now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » My Teen Wants to Major in Medicine: What I Wish I’d Asked First