My son came home from his third week at the new school with a crumpled blue form at the bottom of his backpack. The top read “Student Council Nomination — Grades 4 and 5.” It was due the next morning.
He hadn’t mentioned it. When I asked, he shrugged. “I thought maybe I would,” he said, not looking up from his snack. We’d moved over the summer, and he was still in that phase where every conversation about school came out as a monotone. I knew better than to push. So I just said, “Okay. Let me know if you need anything,” and left the form on the counter.
That was the moment I started quietly dreading the whole thing. Not because I didn’t want him to run, but because I knew exactly how hard it is to put yourself out there in a room full of strangers. I’d been the new kid once. I still remembered the particular loneliness of lunch tables and the way you have to learn the hidden rules of a place nobody bothers to explain. The last thing I wanted was for him to get up in front of those kids and be met with blank stares.
But he brought it up again at dinner. “Do you think I could actually win?” he asked. I gave my standard “If you try your best, that’s what matters,” which he ignored. He wanted logistics. How many kids were in the grade? What kind of speech did people usually give? Did he have to make posters? He was already thinking like a campaign manager, which surprised me.
The next morning, we showed up to school a little early. The principal, who was at the front gate, told us the nominations were due at the office before first bell. My son handed in his form, and that was that. He was officially running.
What followed was a week I hadn’t anticipated. I assumed student council in elementary school was mostly about a nice speech and maybe some posters. But the school had a whole process. A teacher announced the candidates over the intercom. There was a designated week where posters could go up, but only on specific bulletin boards in the hallway. Speeches were to be delivered in the gym in front of the entire junior grade, during an assembly. There was even a “question period” the day before, where candidates could be asked things by other students.
My son was not prepared for the question period. He told me about it later, a bit rattled. A girl from his class had asked, “What will you do about the water fountain by the playground?” And he had no answer. He’d been thinking about bigger things, like school spirit and library books. But that was the thing about this new school—the students had specific, local concerns. I helped him think through a few responses that night, framing them around listening and figuring things out, but honestly, the best lesson was him realizing that you can’t have an answer for everything.
We made posters on a Tuesday night. He printed his name in big letters with markers, and I helped cut out cardboard. We kept it simple: “Vote for Sam” and “A voice for new ideas.” He debated whether to write “new ideas” or “fresh ideas” and settled on “fresh” because it sounded more like something the principal would say. That small detail struck me as a good sign—he was paying attention to the culture of the place, the language people used. That’s something you can’t teach.
The speech itself was a struggle. He wanted me to write it for him. I said no, but I’d help him practice. We sat at the kitchen table and I asked him, “What do you actually want to say?” He said he wanted to tell them that he was new, and that being new meant he saw things differently. He wanted to say that he’d notice the trash on the playground and the fact that there weren’t enough soccer balls at recess. He wanted to start a recycling club. I told him that was enough. He didn’t need to be funny or clever. He just needed to sound like himself.
The morning of the assembly, he was quiet at breakfast. He had a white button-up shirt on, which was his version of dressing up. I walked him to school and said, “Whatever happens, you’re already doing the hard part.” He rolled his eyes, but I saw him straighten his shoulders before he went in.
I didn’t hear anything until the afternoon pickup. He came out looking a little flushed but not upset. I asked how it went. He said, “I didn’t win.” I could tell he was trying to be casual about it. Then, after a pause, “I got three votes.” Three votes out of maybe fifty. It was a tough loss. But then he told me about the speech—how he had been nervous, but he’d kept the buttons on his shirt and one of them had come undone halfway through, and a kid in the front row had laughed, but not meanly. And he had kept going. That, to me, was the real result.
When we got home, he wanted to tell me about the winners. A boy and a girl from the same class had won, the kind of kids who were already well-known. “They were good,” my son said. He didn’t sound bitter, just realistic. “I think a lot of people voted for them because they knew their names.” That observation felt surprisingly mature for a ten-year-old.
In the weeks that followed, I saw something shift. He started coming home with small pieces of knowledge about how the school worked. He knew which teachers coached soccer. He knew the names of the secretaries in the office. He knew that the water fountain by the playground really did get fixed—the girl who asked that question had been right to bring it up. He still wasn’t part of the social inner circle, but he wasn’t on the edge anymore either. He’d made himself visible.
That’s what I’ve come to understand about helping a child through something like this. The election part was secondary. What mattered was that he had an excuse to talk to classmates, to learn the rhythms of the school, to put his face on a piece of paper and say, “Here I am.” For a new kid, that’s a huge step. It doesn’t require being the best speaker or having the best ideas. It just requires showing up.
If your child is going through something similar, I’d offer two things. First, don’t help with the content. Help with the logistics. Sit with them while they make posters, help them practice out loud, but let the words be theirs. When adults take over, kids can sense it, and worse, so can the other students. The speech doesn’t have to be polished. It just has to be authentic. Second, be prepared for the loss. Most kids won’t win, especially in a new setting. But losing a school election in front of peers is a safe way to learn resilience. It stings, but it doesn’t actually hurt. And the experience gives them material—they start to understand how groups work, what people respond to, how to handle disappointment.
We still talk about that day sometimes. Last week, my son mentioned that he might run again next year. “I’ll know more people by then,” he said. I nodded. That’s probably true. But I also think that even if he never runs again, he already got what he needed from it. He found a place for himself, not by winning, but by offering something to a community that wasn’t yet his. There’s no rulebook for that kind of thing. You just have to let them try.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » My son came home from his third week at the new school with a crumpled blue form at the bottom of his backpack