My Kid Says Their Classmates Hate Them: How to Help, Tips From a Fourth Grade Teacher
The final bell had just rung, the last of the parent pick-up cars were pulling out of the parking lot, and Mia was still huddled by my desk, scuffed pink sneakers twisting into the edge of my reading rug, half a sheet of crumpled cat drawing tucked behind her back. Most days she’s the first one out the door, chasing her older brother to the playground after school, so I knew something was off before she said anything. When I asked what she was still doing here, she mumbled so quiet I had to lean in: “All the girls at my table hate me.”
I’ve been teaching fourth grade for 12 years, and this isn’t the first time I’ve had this conversation. Three weeks earlier it was Javi, who leaned against the same spot after school and said no one on the soccer field would pass him the ball, so “everyone hates me.” It never sounds like “a few people are being mean” when you’re 9. One small rejection from the group you want to impress feels like the whole world is against you, so I don’t bother arguing with the wording. That’s the first thing most people get wrong, anyway.
That night I got the call from Mia’s mom, Sarah, who was already halfway to panicking. She’d seen the photos of the craft day on a class mom’s Instagram, the four girls from Mia’s table all covered in glitter, no Mia. She wanted to know if she should email all the moms, pull Mia out of the after-school art club, even ask me to move her to a different table right away. I told her to hold off for a week, and we’d take it step by step.
First, don’t start by fixing the problem. Start by just letting the kid say how bad it feels. When Mia told me they all moved their trays away from her at lunch on Wednesday, I didn’t say “they probably just wanted more room” or “you’re exaggerating, they don’t hate you.” I just said, “That would make me feel really invisible too. Tell me what they said that made you feel that way.” People think they have to cheer the kid up right away, but minimizing how they feel just makes them stop talking to you about it. If you jump to fix it before they’ve gotten all the hurt out, they leave the conversation thinking you don’t get how bad it is.
Second, don’t call out the other kids or make a big deal out of it in front of the whole class. I’ve seen new teachers do a whole lesson on “being kind to everyone” right after a kid says they’re left out, and all that does is make the other kids resent the kid who got them in trouble, and makes your kid feel like a target who needs special saving. Instead, I make one small, low-key change. I already rotate table groups every two weeks to keep dynamics from getting stuck, so I moved Mia to a spot next to Lila, who I’d seen drawing little comics in her notebook during silent reading. I didn’t say “you two need to be friends” I just said “Lila draws too, I thought you two might like seeing each other’s work.”
At home, I told Sarah to stop asking “did you make any friends today?” or “were the girls nice to you?” That question puts so much pressure on a kid, it makes them feel like something’s wrong with them if it didn’t go well. Instead, I told her to ask one small, low-stakes question every day: “What’s the silliest thing that happened today?” If Mia wanted to talk about the mean girls, she could, but if she didn’t, she could just talk about the time Mr. Todd slipped on a crayon at PE. I also told her not to badmouth the other girls in front of Mia, even if she was furious. It just makes the problem feel bigger than it is, and if they end up playing together later, it puts Mia in an awkward spot. Sarah did that, she told me later; she bit her tongue when Mia brought up the craft day, and just sat on the couch with her while she ranted.
A week after that after-school chat, I put a small wooden bin on the back shelf labeled “Class Comics.” I told anyone who wanted to leave their drawings or short comics for other kids to read could put them there. Mia left her half-crumpled cat drawing in there the same day. Two days later, Lila left a note in the bin asking Mia if she could help her draw a cat for her little sister’s birthday card. By the end of the week, three other kids were leaving comics in the bin, and they started sitting together on the bench during recess to draw.
Last week, Mia came in after the weekend and told me one of the girls from the old table asked her if she could have a copy of her latest cat comic. It’s not perfect. Sometimes those girls still roll their eyes when Mia raises her hand to ask too many questions during reading. Sarah still texts me once a week to check in, and I still pull Mia aside for a 30 second chat after morning attendance to make sure she’s okay. She doesn’t hide by my desk after school anymore, though. She’s out by the bench with the other comic kids, trading pages.
The thing no one tells you when your kid says their classmates hate them is that it doesn’t need a big, perfect fix. You don’t need to force everyone to be friends, or get an apology from the other kids, or make everything go back to the way it was. Mostly, you just don’t panic. You let the kid feel their hurt, you give them a small space to find people who like the same things they do, and you wait. Some days that’s all you can do, and that’s enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » My Kid Says Their Classmates Hate Them: How to Help, Tips From a Fourth Grade Teacher