My Kid Is Choosing Between a Master’s in Mass Communication vs Social Media Marketing: What I Learned
Last Sunday, my 22-year-old daughter Lila pushed her laptop across our chipped oak kitchen table, a half-eaten peanut butter toast oozing onto a napkin beside it, and blinked at me. She’s a senior communications undergrad, and she’d just gotten acceptances to two graduate programs: a two-year on-campus Master of Arts in Mass Communication at our state university, and a 12-month online Master of Science in Social Media Marketing from a smaller private program that costs half as much. “All the TikTok creators say social media marketing is the only degree that gets you a real job right now,” she said, twisting a strand of hair around her finger. “But my undergrad advisor says mass comm is more useful long-term. I don’t know who to believe.”
I work as an administrative assistant at our local public high school, so parents stop me in the hall all the time to ask for advice about college and grad programs. But this was different—this was my kid, and I realized I had no off-the-cuff answer for her. I was folding laundry while we talked, the dryer buzzing in the background as my 16-year-old yelled about a bad Fortnite match down the hall. I told her we wouldn’t figure this out in 10 minutes, so I jotted down names of people I knew who’d taken both paths and said I’d reach out.
First I texted my cousin Mia, who got her master’s in mass communication 12 years ago and now works in corporate communications for a regional healthcare system. She called me back that night, straight from her commute. She started out right after grad school running the social media accounts for a non-profit, she said, but when the organization had layoffs three years later, she was able to pivot to a role in crisis communications because her degree had taught her how to write for any audience, analyze messaging, and coordinate communications across multiple channels. “I use stuff I learned in my media law and audience analysis classes every single day,” she said. “Even for social media. The niche tactics you can learn on the job, but the big picture thinking? Most places don’t have time to teach you that.” A mass comm degree, she said, doesn’t lock you into one role—it works for PR, internal comms, politics, marketing, even content strategy. If you don’t know exactly what you want to do long-term, it’s a safe bet.
Next I talked to Javi, our 28-year-old neighbor who got his master’s in social media marketing three years ago and works from home as a senior social media manager for a small sustainable clothing brand. He came over for a beer after mowing his lawn last Tuesday and told me straight up that his degree got him his first job faster than any traditional degree would have. “I learned how to set up a TikTok ad campaign, negotiate influencer contracts, read Google Analytics, and grow an Instagram following in my first semester,” he said. “I had a job offer two weeks before I graduated, starting at $72,000. I didn’t have any student debt because I did it online in a year while I worked part-time.” The downside, he said, is that about half the specific tactics he learned in classes are already outdated, because algorithms change every six months. If he ever wanted to leave social media to do something else, like PR or corporate comms, he’d have to go back and take extra classes to fill in the gaps.
Then I met Sarah, the hiring manager at the local environmental non-profit Lila wants to work for, for coffee at Starbucks downtown. Sarah and I did PTA together 10 years ago when our kids were in elementary school, so she was honest with me. She said when she looks at grad degree applications, the name on the degree doesn’t sway her nearly as much as two things: what the candidate did while they were getting the degree, and how clear they are about their goals. “If your kid knows they want to do social media for the next 5 years, and they can get the degree faster, cheaper, and get an internship while they do it? That’s way more attractive than a two-year degree that leaves them with $40k in debt and no on-the-job experience,” she said. “If they’re not sure what they want, or they want to work in a more traditional field like government or corporate comms long-term, the mass comm degree makes more sense.”
That Wednesday after dinner, Lila and I sat back down at the kitchen table and went through the points we’d gathered. She wrote down her answers to three simple questions we’d put together: Do I know what role I want right after graduation? Yes, social media manager for a climate non-profit. If I switch roles in 10 years, can I learn the extra stuff I need along the way instead of paying for it now? Yes, I’d rather work and pay for a few classes than take on debt now. Am I okay with the fact that the niche stuff I learn will be outdated in a few years? Yes, that’s just how social media works, and I’m used to learning new things all the time.
She ended up picking the social media marketing program. I still have moments where I wonder if we made the right call—old habits die hard, and I grew up thinking traditional degrees are always the more solid choice. She starts in the fall, and she’s already lined up her internship for credit with the non-profit she volunteers with on weekends. We don’t know what will happen in 5 or 10 years. There’s no way to know if social media will even look the same as it does now.
But what I can tell other parents who are in this same spot is this: don’t default to the traditional degree just because it feels more familiar to you. Pull up the program curricula side by side, talk to at least two people who graduated from each program in the last 5 years, and walk through those three concrete questions with your kid. Let their goals and their financial situation lead the choice, not what you think a “real” grad degree should look like. Right now, this fits her, and that’s enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » My Kid Is Choosing Between a Master’s in Mass Communication vs Social Media Marketing: What I Learned