My Kid Hates Their Math Teacher: What I Learned When They Called Her A Bitch
The kitchen counter was still sticky with popsicle juice from after lunch when my 13-year-old son slammed the front door open, backpack thudding against the wall, and yelled, “My math teacher is a bitch.” I was mid-sip of iced coffee, and I almost choked. I’d heard him swear before, usually when he died in Minecraft, but never about an adult, never with that much raw, shaking anger. I wiped coffee off my sleeve, leaned against the counter, and waited. He kicked off his sneakers, one of them missing a lace, and stomped over to the table, dropping a crumpled D-minus quiz face up in front of me. All the answers were correct. Half the points were gone, scrawled in red pen: No work shown.
He told me she’d announced the new no-work-no-points rule the day before, when he was home sick with a cold. No one texted him the update, she didn’t post it to the class Google Classroom until after the quiz. When he raised his hand to ask about it after, she told him “irresponsible students don’t get exceptions” in front of the whole class. He ranted that she does this all the time: calls on kids who don’t raise their hands just to watch them fumble, gives detention for being one minute late when the hallway was crowded after PE, moved his seat to the front alone because he whispered to ask for a pencil once.
My first instinct was two things, both wrong. First, I wanted to jump in and scold him for using that word. Second, I wanted to grab my phone and fire off a furious email to the principal and the teacher, demanding an apology. But I remembered last fall, when he came home upset about his science teacher embarrassing him for forgetting his lab report, and I’d told him “teachers work hard, you need to respect them” and he’d nodded, gone up to his room, and didn’t tell me about any school stress for almost two months. So I didn’t do either. I pulled out a chair, sat down across from him, and said, “That sounds so humiliating. I’d be furious too. For the record, that word isn’t okay to use at school or around me, but I get why you’re this mad. Tell me everything.”
He talked for 25 minutes, twisting the hem of his stained band hoodie the whole time. By the end, he was leaning back in the chair, less tense, just tired. I didn’t say anything for a minute, then I asked him, “What do you want me to do here? Do you want me to email her, or email the principal, or do you just want to complain about it after school every day, or what?” He thought for a minute, then said he didn’t want me to go in and make a big deal. He just didn’t want to fail math because she was unfair.
That’s when I realized something I hadn’t thought through before. When a kid says something that harsh about a teacher, it’s not just them being rude or disrespectful. It’s them feeling totally powerless. Middle schoolers have almost no control over their day: someone tells them when to eat, when to move, what to do, and their grade is entirely in one person’s hands. If that person feels unfair, the only way they can process that rage is to say the worst thing they can think of. Jumping in to either scold the kid or attack the teacher robs them of the chance to learn how to handle hard people, which is something they’re going to need for the rest of their lives.
We came up with a small plan that night, nothing big. First, we made a quick checklist for every math assignment and quiz: 1) Write every step, even if it’s just adding two numbers, 2) Box the final answer, 3) Write your name at the top. We taped it to the front cover of his math notebook with a piece of washi tape he picked out. It takes him 30 extra seconds a problem, but it means he doesn’t lose points over the silly little rules she enforces. Second, we agreed that he can complain as much as he wants after school, no interrupting, no telling him to cheer up or look on the bright side. Third, I sent a short, low-pressure email to his guidance counselor, just saying “My son is adjusting to the expectations in 7th grade math and has been pretty stressed about it. Could you check in with him in a couple of weeks to see how things are going?” I didn’t badmouth the teacher, I just said my kid was stressed. That let the school know there was an issue without starting a fight that would probably just make things harder for him in class.
It’s been six weeks now. He still doesn’t like her. Last week he came home and said she made a girl cry for asking to go to the nurse halfway through a quiz. He still complains about her at dinner most nights. But he hasn’t called her that word again. His last quiz was a B, all the points he earned, because he remembered the checklist. He’s started joking about her with his friends at the bus stop, rolling his eyes when her name comes up instead of shaking with anger.
I don’t know if she’s a bad teacher, or just burnt out from grading 120 quizzes a week and taking her frustration out on the kids. Some days I still want to go in and say something to the administration. But right now, this is working. My son learned how to adjust to a difficult person’s rules instead of waiting for someone to fix it for him. He learned that I’ll listen to him even when he says something wrong, instead of shutting him down to prove a point about manners.
There’s no big happy ending here. He still has her for the rest of the school year, and he’ll probably still come home upset sometimes. Some problems don’t get fixed perfectly, and that’s okay. Sometimes you just need a checklist taped to a notebook, a safe place to vent, and a little time to adjust.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » My Kid Hates Their Math Teacher: What I Learned When They Called Her A Bitch