My Dreams Were Crushed in 1994: What That Moment Taught Me About How Kids Hear Adult Words
The classroom smelled like floor wax and the faint metal tang of a forgotten thermos. It was a Thursday afternoon in April 1994, and I was nine years old. I had spent three weeks on the drawing—a knight on horseback, with a dragon twisting behind him, scales shaded so carefully I had worn through three pencils. It wasn’t for a grade. It was for me. I was going to be an artist when I grew up, and this was the proof.
Mrs. Alvarez walked past my desk during silent reading. She paused, looked down at the knight, and picked up the paper. I remember holding my breath. She tilted her head. Then she set it back down and said, “This is lovely, but you should spend more time on your reading. You won’t get a job drawing pictures.”
She said it kindly. That was the worst part. She patted my shoulder and moved on to another student. I sat there with my pencil in my hand and my dragon half-finished, and something closed off inside me.
I didn’t draw again for eleven years.
It wasn’t a dramatic moment. Nobody yelled. There was no punishment. But I had been told, in one sentence, that the thing I loved most in the world was a waste of time. And at nine years old, you don’t question that. You just believe it.
I thought about that afternoon this week when my own daughter put a sticky handful of dandelions in my hand. She’s six, and she announced at dinner that she’s going to be a flower farmer when she grows up. My husband laughed a little—the kind of laugh adults do when a child says something cute—and I saw her face flicker. Just for a second. She laughed along with him, but something in her shoulders changed.
I recognized it. I had felt that same flicker in 1994.
It’s strange how clearly we remember the moment our dreams got quietly put away. For me it was an art teacher’s offhand comment. For a friend of mine, it was her father saying “that’s not a real subject” when she told him she wanted to study history. For another, it was a basketball coach who told him he was “too small” to ever make the team. None of these people were trying to be cruel. They were adults being practical.
But kids don’t hear practicality. They hear a verdict.
Here’s the thing I’ve learned since becoming a parent myself: children are not looking for validation that their dream will come true. They know, somewhere deep down, that the odds of becoming a professional flower farmer or a knight-painting artist are actually pretty low. What they’re looking for is permission to be interested in something. To explore it. To bring it to you and have you not laugh at it.
When I started paying attention to my own words, I noticed how often I did it without thinking. “That’s nice, honey, now wash your hands.” “Those dandelions are weeds, you know.” “Maybe you can draw flowers when your homework is done.” It wasn’t mean. It was dismissive—the adult equivalent of a closed door.
So in the years since that dinner-table moment, I’ve been trying something different. When my daughter brings me a dandelion, I ask her about it. How does the fluff work? Why are some dandelions yellow and some white? She talks for ten minutes about pollen and seeds, and I find myself genuinely interested sometimes. Not because I care about dandelions, but because I care about watching her put her whole self into an idea.
It’s not about pretending every childhood passion is going to be a career. I don’t think that’s what does the damage anyway. The damage happens when we make a kid feel like their curiosity is too much, or their enthusiasm is misguided, or they’re asking the wrong questions. The damage happens in small moments exactly like that April afternoon in 1994.
If Mrs. Alvarez had said something different—”Show me how you made the dragon’s scales” or “What story is this knight part of?”—I would have talked her ear off. She didn’t have to support me becoming an artist. She just had to let me be one in that moment. Instead, she closed the door.
That’s the part I understand now that I couldn’t understand as a nine-year-old. She wasn’t a bad teacher or a bad person. She was an adult with a packed classroom and a test to prepare for. Art wasn’t on the test. So in her mind, it wasn’t real. She wasn’t trying to crush my dreams. She was trying to help me focus.
But the result was the same either way.
When my daughter started kindergarten this year, I had to physically stop myself from giving the same kind of “help.” We did the school supply list in August, and she picked out a purple lunchbox with a cartoon cat on it. My first thought was that she’d get made fun of. My second thought was to steer her toward something more neutral. It took me a minute to realize I was doing it again—teaching her that what she liked was an embarrassment.
I bought the purple lunchbox. She loves it. Do some of the older kids tease her about it? I don’t know. I haven’t asked, because I’m not sure I want to know. But I didn’t take it away from her. That I can do.
Here’s what I wish someone had told the adults around me in 1994: you don’t have to believe in the dream, but you do have to respect it. You don’t have to think your kid is going to be a famous painter. You just have to let them believe it for a while. That’s not delusion. That’s childhood. The world will start telling kids what’s realistic soon enough—middle school, high school, life, all of that. It doesn’t need a head start.
So we keep the drawing paper out. We let the dandelion stems sit in a glass water cup until they turn to goo. We talk about what kind of flowers we’d plant if we had a big backyard, and I let her correct my pronunciation of “ranunculus” over and over even though I’m pretty sure I’m saying it wrong on purpose now. I don’t know if she’ll ever actually grow a flower garden. I don’t know if that matters.
What matters is that she keeps bringing me things, keeps talking, keeps showing me whatever she’s made that day. And when she puts another limp, slightly dripping dandelion in my hand, I take it. I look at it. I ask her about it. I try not to rush that moment.
Because I know what it’s like to stop bringing things to adults. You learn quickly who is willing to look at your dreams and who is just waiting for you to move on to something more practical. And somewhere in 1994, I learned that lesson. I’m still unlearning it now.
I don’t know if Mrs. Alvarez ever realized what she did. I doubt she thinks about it at all. But I do. I think about it every time I’m tempted to tell a child that their drawing is nice but not as important as their homework. I think about it every time a word like “realistic” sits on my tongue.
She was right, in a way. I never got a job drawing pictures. But that doesn’t mean she was right about everything. I got something else that day—an understanding of how much weight our words carry. Kids don’t always say anything, but they hear everything. And they believe you.
So I’m trying to be more careful about what I say. I’m trying to leave the door open, even when I don’t know what’s behind it. I’m still figuring out the balance between practicality and letting them dream. Some days I get it wrong.
But at least now I’m looking at the dandelion.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » My Dreams Were Crushed in 1994: What That Moment Taught Me About How Kids Hear Adult Words