My child doesn’t want to go to school prize distribution: what to do
The crinkle of the neon yellow flier hit my ear before Leo looked up from his mac and cheese. “Mom,” he mumbled, stabbing a noodle, “I don’t really wanna go to the end-of-year prize distribution next week.”
The flier was stuck to the front of his Friday folder, bold text reading “All Parents Invited! Reception After In The Cafeteria.” Leo had gotten a note a week earlier that he qualified for the 100% perfect attendance award—he’d only had one delayed drop-off all year, for a dentist cleaning, so it made sense. My first instinct was to parrot the line every parent is conditioned to say: But you earned that! It’ll be fun, Grandma’s even coming to watch. But I stopped when I saw the pink creeping up his neck, the way he pushed the flier around the table like it was something sticky he didn’t want to touch. I remembered my own 5th grade prize day: I’d gotten honorable mention for the district writing contest, and I faked a fever so I wouldn’t have to walk across the stage. My mom made me go anyway, said I was being silly, I’d regret it. That was 25 years ago, and I still remember the way my hands shook so bad my certificate slipped out of my hand when I got it, and a kid in the back row snickered. I haven’t forgotten that feeling.
So I leaned back and said, “Okay, what don’t you like about it?” He spilled everything at once: he didn’t want 300 people staring at him while he walked across a wobbly stage. What if he tripped, like Jake Miller did last year, and everyone laughed for the rest of the school year? And anyway, all the big prizes go to the straight-A kids and the basketball team, no one cares about perfect attendance. He’d just be up there for 10 seconds and no one would even remember it, but he’d be nervous for three straight days leading up to it.
That makes sense, if you spend any time in elementary school classrooms. I’ve volunteered with Leo’s class for three years, and I see this dynamic every week. When the teacher asks for a volunteer to come up front to get a star or a prize, the same 5 or 6 kids shoot their hands up. The rest slide down in their seats, stare at their desk, hope they don’t get picked. We talk a lot about building confidence, but we forget that confidence doesn’t look the same for everyone. Standing on a stage in front of a crowd isn’t a marker of how confident you are. It’s just a marker of how comfortable you are with crowds.
That night, I emailed Leo’s teacher. I didn’t ask for him to skip the whole school day, I just said he was really anxious about getting called up in front of the entire school, and we wanted to see if we could work out an alternative. She wrote back 20 minutes later, saying she’d gotten three of those emails that same week. Half the kids who earn awards don’t actually want to go up on stage, she said, but most parents make them do it anyway. She said we could pick up his prize from the front office after the assembly, no questions asked.
We laid out all the options for Leo, no strings attached. He could skip the whole assembly and hang out in the nurse’s office if he wanted. He could go, sit with me in the back, and not stand up when his name was called. He could change his mind last minute and go up if he felt like it. We didn’t frame any option as the “brave” one. I just told him, whatever he picked, I was fine with it, and I’d still take him for his favorite chocolate mint ice cream after.
On Friday, we went. Leo decided he wanted to go to the assembly because all his friends were going, and he wanted to clap for his friend Mia who won the art award. We sat in the back row, right by the exit, and he held my hand when the awards started. When they called the perfect attendance group, he squeezed my hand tighter and shook his head a little. I didn’t nudge him. I didn’t whisper “it’s okay, you can go if you want.” I just left it there.
After the assembly, we stopped by the office, grabbed his certificate and his $10 book fair gift card, then drove to the ice cream shop down the street. He got sprinkles all over his shirt, and didn’t mention the assembly once. That weekend, he spent his gift card on a new graphic novel about astronauts, read it cover to cover on the couch Saturday.
What I’ve learned from this, that I wish more parents and teachers talked about, is that achievement doesn’t need a public moment to matter. Your kid doesn’t have to perform their success for other people to have earned it. A lot of the common advice I see says you have to push kids out of their comfort zones to help them grow, but the best first step is to actually ask them where their comfort zone is, and respect it. If they want to try stepping out, that’s great. If they don’t, that’s also okay.
A few concrete things that worked for us, that you can try too: First, email the teacher as soon as you can, and ask for alternatives. Most schools are happy to work with you, they just don’t offer it up front because they assume everyone wants the public recognition. Second, let your kid pick their own level of participation. Don’t frame their choice as “being brave” or “being scared” — just a choice that’s theirs to make. Third, celebrate the win their way, after. It doesn’t have to be on the school’s timeline or in front of the school’s crowd. It can be ice cream and a new book, just the two of you.
Leo mentioned the other day that he wants to try out for the school play next year. It’s a small part, one line, but he said he wants to do it. I didn’t say “see, you could have done the prize distribution!” I just said that sounds fun, we can go get the audition packet after school. Some days he’s up for being in front of people, some days he’s not. That’s how it is for most of us, right? I still skip the PTA open mic night, so who am I to force him to walk across a wobbly stage for a certificate he can just pick up at the office?
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » My child doesn’t want to go to school prize distribution: what to do