My 20 Month Old Still Wants Formula: Why It Happens and What I’m Doing About It
It’s 7:12 a.m. and I’m leaning against the kitchen counter, half my coffee poured into a chipped mug, while my 20-month-old, Mia, yanks on the hem of my sweatpants and signs “milk” over and over, her lower lip starting to puff out. The open sippy cup of cold whole milk, set out 20 minutes ago on the table, sits three feet away, completely untouched. The dented can of formula I stashed behind the oat box last week after my sister teased me about still buying it is within arm’s reach, and I know exactly what she’s asking for. She wants the yellow milk.
I’ve read all the guidelines. Every parenting blog, every well-child visit handout, every casual mom chat at the playground says you should wean off formula by 12 months, full stop. At Mia’s 18-month checkup, our pediatrician mentioned it as a gentle nudge, and I nodded along like I already had it handled, then went straight to the store and bought two more cans on the way home. I tried to wean cold turkey when she turned 1. Put all the formula in a storage bin in the back of the closet, filled her cup with whole milk, and waited. She cried for 25 minutes before bed, refused every other snack I offered, woke up three times that night screaming, and by 4 a.m. I was digging formula out of the dark closet with a flashlight, too tired to care about guidelines.
Mia was a slow weight gainer her first six months. I struggled with low supply, we started supplementing early, and formula became this safety net for both of us. When she turned one, I was ready to be done with it, but she wasn’t. I tried half and half, she’d pick up the cup, smell it, push it away. I tried flavored milk, organic whole milk, grass-fed, even oat milk like a friend suggested. Nothing stuck unless the ratio was three parts formula to one part anything else. I started scrolling mom groups at 10 p.m. after she went to bed, panicking that I was ruining her eating habits, rotting her teeth, making her too dependent, all the things the internet says you’re doing wrong if your toddler still wants formula.
Then last month, I stepped back and actually looked at what’s going on, not just what the checklists say. Mia eats three full meals a day. She steals cheese off my plate, shovels peanut butter toast into her mouth, eats more blueberries than I thought possible for a human her size. She drinks water with snacks, licks yogurt off her spoon, her weight is perfectly on the 50th percentile, her doctor says her development is right on track. The formula isn’t for nutrition, not anymore. It’s for comfort. 20 months is such a weird, big age. She’s just learning to run, to open doors by herself, to throw tantrums because I cut her sandwich wrong. Everything is new and loud and overwhelming, and formula is the one thing that’s been there since she was tiny enough to fit in my arms in the middle of the night. It’s her version of a lovey, or a pacifier, or the stuffed rabbit my cousin’s kid still sleeps with at 4. That’s all it is.
Once I stopped seeing it as a failure and started seeing it as a comfort need, I came up with small, low-fuss changes that are working for us, no screaming required. First, I stopped hiding it, but I limited it to only two times a day: first thing when she wakes up, and right before bed. Those are the times she’s fuzziest, most craving that familiar routine. During the day, we only offer whole milk or water with meals and snacks. That cut our formula usage in half, which helped with the cost (let’s be real, formula isn’t cheap, so that’s a win). Second, I made whole milk feel more fun. I bought her a new sippy cup with the blue dog from Bluey on it, the character she’s obsessed with right now. I add one tiny drop of vanilla extract to it a couple times a week, just enough to make it taste a little different. I let her sip from my glass when I drink milk, because she wants to do everything I do these days. Third, when she asks for formula during the day, I don’t say “no” and walk away, and I don’t give in immediately. I say “We get yellow milk after nap, remember? Right now let’s try your blue milk, then go build the block tower.” Ninety percent of the time, she forgets about it two minutes later when we’re stacking blocks.
Last week, she fell off the slide at the playground, scraped her knee, and cried so hard she couldn’t catch her breath. When we got to the car, she immediately signed for yellow milk. I used to hide the bottle in my diaper bag, embarrassed that other moms would judge, but this time I just pulled it out, warmed it up a little in the gas station microwave, and gave it to her. She drank half, wiped her eyes, and asked to go look at the ducks in the pond across the street. That’s when it clicked for me. This isn’t a problem I need to fix this week. It’s just a need she has right now.
I know what people will say: what about tooth decay? What about too much sugar? I just brush her teeth right after she drinks her bedtime bottle, same as I brush them after she eats a banana or a cracker. It’s not rocket science. Is it delaying her eating solid food? She’s eating more solid food every week, so that’s not an issue for us. Every kid is different.
Right now, we’re at two bottles a day, down from four just two months ago. Some days she drinks a whole sippy of whole milk with breakfast and doesn’t even ask for formula until bedtime. Some days, when she’s teething or extra tired, she asks for it three times. I don’t know when she’ll be fully weaned off. It might be next month, it might be six months from now. I stopped beating myself up over it. The guideline to wean by 12 months is just that: a guideline. It’s not a test I failed because my 20 month old still wants formula. Right now, this is working for us. That’s enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » My 20 Month Old Still Wants Formula: Why It Happens and What I’m Doing About It