My 13-Year-Old Got an AI Mark on His Essay, and I Still Don’t Know What to Think
I was waiting in the pickup line at soccer practice last night, goldfish crumbs stuck to the screen of my phone, when I pulled up the parent portal to check Leo’s latest English grade. The essay was on Jonas in The Giver, which I remember him moping about for two nights last week, saying he couldn’t get the conclusion right. The grade was a B minus, which isn’t terrible, but the comment at the bottom made me sit up straight: “Deducted 10 points for failing to disclose AI use. Great argument, just remember to tell me when you use it to brainstorm or draft next time.”
I called him over when he got in the car, soccer cleats clicking on the pavement, smelling like cut grass and spearmint gum, and showed him. He just rolled his eyes and threw his duffel in the backseat. “I forgot,” he said. “I got stuck for, like, an hour, so I asked it to give me three different ways to end the thing, and I picked the one I liked and rewrote it. Ms. Henderson just makes us write a little note at the end if we use it for anything. I forgot.”
That’s when I started really noticing how all this is shaking out, because there’s no one unified approach around here. Leo’s in 8th grade, my older daughter Maya is 16 in 11th grade, and their two schools (same district, five miles apart) handle this completely differently. Even different teachers in the same building handle it completely differently. No one’s got it all figured out, that’s for sure.
I met Maya’s AP Bio teacher last month, Mr. Carter, for parent-teacher conferences, and he spent the first ten minutes of our slot talking about how AI is the end of original thinking. He has a strict zero-tolerance policy: if any part of any assignment is AI-generated, it’s an automatic zero for plagiarism, no exceptions. He said he can always tell when a kid’s voice isn’t their own, and that using AI rots their ability to problem-solve. I nodded along, because that’s what you do at parent-teacher conferences when a teacher is on a roll, but then I accidentally said offhand that I use AI to sort out my grocery list every week – it takes what I’ve got in the fridge and gives me three recipes, saves me 20 minutes of scrolling Pinterest. He just stared at me for a second, then moved on to talk about Maya’s lab report. It was super awkward, I left the conference feeling like I’d just admitted I do my kid’s homework for him.
Maya says half the kids in her AP Bio class use AI anyway. They use it to make flashcards from the chapter, to outline lab reports, even to answer the discussion questions at the end of the reading. They just rephrase it enough that Mr. Carter can’t tell, or they don’t get caught. Maya won’t use it, because she’s scared of getting a zero that’ll tank her GPA, but she complains every other night that it’s unfair – she spends three hours hand-writing flashcards when some kid just plugs the whole chapter in and gets a perfect set in two minutes, and gets the same grade if not better.
Contrast that with Leo’s math teacher, Mr. Lopez, who does the exact opposite. He tells all the kids they can use AI to check their homework answers, as long as they write down every step of their own work before they check. Leo says it’s actually helpful – if he’s stuck on a problem for 20 minutes, he can plug it in and see where he messed up the algebra, instead of just erasing the whole thing over and over until the paper tears. But then he also told me last week that three quarters of the kids in his class just copy all the steps straight from AI and turn it in, and Mr. Lopez can’t check 150 homework sets every night to tell who did the work and who copied. So it’s this messy middle where the good students get a helpful tool, and the kids who don’t want to do work get an easy out, and nobody’s really figured out how to fix that gap.
The school district sent out that big official AI policy email a couple months back, all fancy jargon about “responsible AI integration” and “developmentally appropriate guardrails.” I opened it, got through the second paragraph, got a text from the orthodontist saying they needed to reschedule Leo’s appointment, and closed it. I still haven’t read the whole thing. I bet half the teachers haven’t either, not the whole 10-page thing.
I go back and forth on it myself, honestly. Some days I’m convinced the schools are going too easy, that kids aren’t gonna learn how to work through a hard problem or write a clear sentence if they can just ask a bot to do the heavy lifting for them. Other days I think the schools that ban it entirely are just being stubborn, that AI’s not going away, and when my kids get jobs they’re gonna be expected to use it, so why not teach them how to use it well now instead of pretending it doesn’t exist?
Last week I was waiting for Leo to finish after-school play rehearsal, hanging around by the gym entrance drinking a lukewarm coffee I’d bought on my way over. I overheard two teachers talking by the water fountain down the hall. One was a math teacher I recognized from back when Maya was in middle school, the other was a new English teacher I’d never seen. The younger one was saying how tired she was of running every paper through AI detection, how those things are wrong half the time anyway, how she’d rather just ask kids to be honest and grade their actual ideas than waste time playing cop. The older one laughed and said she uses AI to grade her multiple choice quizzes and write draft progress report comments, so she’s got no room to yell at kids for using it. “We’re all just using it to get more work done,” she said. “Why would we pretend the kids shouldn’t?”
I stood there sipping my cold coffee, and I still don’t have a neat answer. Some teachers are figuring it out as they go, some are digging in their heels, all the official policies are half-baked, and every adult I talk to – parents, teachers, everyone – is just as confused as I am. It’s not a crisis, not exactly, but it’s not fine and sorted either. We’re all just fumbling through, right? I guess that’s just how new things go. (Word count: 1182)
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » My 13-Year-Old Got an AI Mark on His Essay, and I Still Don’t Know What to Think