MAP Testing: What Parents Need To Know, From A Classroom Teacher
Last week, I stood by my car after school waiting for my own kid to finish art club when Lila, one of my former 4th graders, wandered over, rain boots squelching in the puddles, her MAP score report crumpled in one fist. She was blinking hard to hold back tears, and when I asked what was wrong, she held it out to me and pointed to a red number: her math RIT score had dropped three points since fall. “Am I still bad at math?” she asked. Cherry blossom petals stuck to her rain jacket, and I pulled a peanut butter granola bar out of my purse for her while we waited for her mom, who was stuck running late for a work call.
When her mom pulled up, she sighed and told me she’d been doing 20 minutes of MAP math practice every night after dinner for a month. The district email said scores would be used for 5th grade math grouping, and she was terrified a low score would stick Lila in the lower level forever. We pulled the report back open and walked through it together: Lila had left her final math session early that week to go to the nurse with a stress-induced stomach ache, leaving 6 multiple-choice questions blank. MAP automatically scores blanks as wrong, so it pulled her overall score down even though every question she answered was correct. Her reading score, which no one had bothered to highlight, was up 12 points – more than the 8-10 point annual growth expected for 4th grade. That’s the thing no one tells parents about MAP: the most eye-catching number on the report is almost always the one that matters the least.
I’ve administered Measures of Academic Progress tests twice a year for seven years as a 4th grade teacher, sat through all the district trainings, and helped hundreds of parents unpack their kid’s results. I get asked all the time what I really think about it, so let’s be honest: it’s not the evil testing monster some parents make it out to be, but it’s nowhere near the accurate, full picture of a kid’s ability that districts pretend it is. There are three concrete, low-friction things I tell every parent who asks what to do with their kid’s score, and none of them involve panicking or buying expensive practice workbooks.
First, look at growth before you look at percentiles or benchmarks. MAP is normed on a sample of kids from 2015, so percentiles only compare your kid to a group of students from almost a decade ago, not the current group at your school. If your kid grew six or more points since their last test, that’s real progress, even if they’re still sitting below the published grade level benchmark. Growth tells you far more about how your kid is doing than their rank against a decade-old sample.
Second, if the score doesn’t match what you see at home, ask your kid’s teacher for the test session log. MAP tracks how long a kid spends on each question, how many they left blank, and if they clicked through a string of wrong answers in a row that points to a bad day, a glitchy laptop, or distraction, not a lack of skill. Last year, a parent asked if we should hold her son back a grade because his reading score was 12 points below benchmark. That same kid checked out 300-page fantasy novels from my classroom library every week and could explain the plot better than most of his peers. When I pulled his session log, I saw the glitchy trackpad on his assigned laptop kept clicking wrong answers when he moved the cursor. He’d rushed through the test to get away from the broken device, and 15 questions were wrong for no reason. Most schools will let you retake the test for free if the result doesn’t make sense – that’s not something they advertise, but it’s almost always allowed.
Third, you don’t need weeks of MAP prep to get a good score. If your kid has taken a computer adaptive test before, a 10-minute practice quiz the night before is more than enough. I’ve seen parents cancel soccer practice and skip family dinners to drill MAP practice questions, and that just gives kids test anxiety before they even sit down. The only time extra prep makes sense is if your kid is taking MAP for the first time, just to get used to how the test gets harder when you get questions right. That’s it.
After we walked through Lila’s score, she stuffed the crumpled report back in her backpack and asked if she could go play on the swings. Her mom laughed and canceled the 2 pages of practice problems she’d printed for that night, admitting she’d been so stressed she’d forgotten Lila always gets stomach aches when she’s nervous, and the whole test week was just bad timing.
I don’t think MAP is all bad. It can flag kids who need extra small-group support that we might miss early in the year, when we’re still getting to know 25 new personalities and skill levels. But it’s just one data point. In my classroom, I weight daily class work, kid-led projects, and the work kids do when they don’t know they’re being tested at 80%, and MAP at 20%. It never makes a grouping or placement decision on its own. I started adding a 1-sentence handwritten note to every score report I send home now: either “This matches what I see in class” or “This score doesn’t reflect what I see from your kid daily – let’s chat.” It takes 30 seconds per kid, and it cuts down on so much unnecessary stress.
I still don’t have a clear, black-and-white answer on whether MAP testing is worth all the time and stress it takes. It’s a tool, and like any tool, it’s only as good as how you use it. Last weekend, I saw Lila running a lemonade stand in her front yard, quickly adding up change for customers and double-checking her math to make sure she didn’t short anyone. No one was timing her, no one was scoring her, and she got every single problem right. That 3-point drop doesn’t show up there. It doesn’t know how hard she works, or how much she’s learned, or what she’ll do next. That’s the part we always have to remember, no matter what the score says.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » MAP Testing: What Parents Need To Know, From A Classroom Teacher