Is Unstructured Play For Kids A Waste Of Time? A Teacher’s Perspective
The oak tree at the edge of our 4th grade playground drops huge branches every October, and for the past two weeks, half my class has been hauling them into a pile against the trunk to build a fort. Last Tuesday, Mia’s mom pulled me aside after pickup, her iced coffee sweating through the sleeve of her workout jacket, and asked the question I get at least once a month: “Is this a waste of time?”
She’d pulled Mia from after-school art to add extra math tutoring this semester, because her scores on the last practice test were just a little below the benchmark for the state exam. Between tutoring and soccer practice, the only free time Mia has all week is recess, and all she does with it is work on this stupid fort. “I don’t want to be that mom,” she said, glancing over at Mia who was swinging her backpack waiting by the car, “but what’s she actually learning out here, anyway?”
I told her I get it. I’m a parent too, and I’ve had the exact same thought. Two weeks ago, I stood in my own 10-year-old son’s bedroom doorway ready to nag him about his unfinished science fair outline, only to find him cross-legged on the floor, sorting his 72-rock collection by how much light they reflect. He’d already spent four hours on it, and the outline was due in three days. All I could think standing there was this is such a waste of time.
I walked Mia’s mom over to the edge of the playground, and we stood far enough back not to interrupt the ongoing fort debate. They were hashing out whether to add a back wall. One kid said it would block their view of the kickball game, another said the wind would blow their snack crumbs all over the inside if they didn’t. Mia pulled out a crumpled sticky note from her pocket and drew two quick options, then counted votes out loud: 3 for back wall, 2 for no back wall. She compromised by suggesting they build a half-wall that only comes up to their knees, so they can still see the game.
I pointed that out to Mia’s mom. That’s problem solving no worksheet can teach. She’s also been keeping track of how many sticks each kid brings, so no one says they did more work than everyone else. That’s addition and basic data tracking, just without the word problem at the top. When they decided to make a map for the fort so the first graders wouldn’t get lost (their words, not mine), they spent an entire recess figuring out how big to draw the tree compared to the fort. That’s scale. That’s exactly the math unit we’re working on right now.
I used to think free time that didn’t have a clear learning goal was wasted, too. When I first started teaching 10 years ago, I filled every minute of indoor recess with educational games or silent reading, because I thought any time kids weren’t “producing” something was lost. Then I had a student, Javi, who spent every single indoor recess drawing tiny dinosaur skeletons in the margins of his notebook. His dad pulled me aside for a conference and asked if I could make him stop, said he was wasting time he could be using to finish extra credit. I agreed at first, I told Javi he had to draw after class. But he just snuck it in anyway, so I let it go. Three months later, for our end-of-year passion project, Javi turned in a 12-page report on the Cretaceous extinction, with his own hand-drawn diagrams of T-Rex bones, and gave a 15 minute presentation that had the whole class asking questions. He ended up joining the local elementary science club, and last I heard he’s volunteering at the natural history museum on weekends. That all started with “wasted” margin time.
Now when parents ask me if something their kid loves is a waste of time, I give them three small, concrete things to try instead of shutting it down. First, instead of asking “what did you learn today?” ask “what did you work on today?” If they can tell you about a problem they solved, or a thing they figured out that they cared about, it’s not wasted. Second, if you’re worried about it cutting into assigned work, set a clear time limit instead of shutting it down cold. Say “you have 15 more minutes to work on your fort/rock sorting/drawing, then we need to shift to homework” instead of “put that away right now, it’s silly.” That honors their focus, which is one of the most important skills kids can build, and still keeps your schedule on track. Third, if they keep coming back to the same thing week after week, that’s not distraction—that’s interest. Interest is what makes all the hard work of learning stick way more than any tutoring session or assigned reading.
Mia’s mom ended up saying she’d think about putting Mia back in art, by the way. The fort fell down two days ago, when we had that big wind storm that knocked out power across town. The kids were disappointed at recess yesterday, but they’re already talking about rebuilding it bigger this time, so I guess that’s that.
I still have my own days where I forget this. Last week, my son spent an hour after school watching videos of people restoring old mountain bikes instead of working on his algebra homework. I stood in the kitchen grinding my teeth, ready to go yell at him, before I remembered the rock collection. I went in and asked him what he was learning, and he told me he was figuring out how to fix up the old bike his uncle gave him for his birthday. We still set a timer for 20 more minutes of video time before he switched to homework, but it wasn’t a waste.
Not all learning looks like the work we recognize. Some of it looks like forts, and rocks, and paper airplanes, and dinosaur drawings. It doesn’t fit on a test score sheet, and it doesn’t always have a clear end product. But that doesn’t make it a waste. I’m still learning that, too.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Is Unstructured Play For Kids A Waste Of Time