Is unstructured play for kids a waste of time? What an elementary teacher sees
Last Tuesday, after the final bell rang, I was brushing crushed Goldfish crumbs off my conference table when Mia’s mom leaned forward, twisted the strap of her work tote, and asked the question I get at least once a month from parents: “All this time you let them spend building blocks and drawing whatever they want… is this a waste of time?”
She’d just looked over Mia’s first quarter progress report, where all her marks were on or above grade level, but she’d left a neighbor’s brunch that weekend panicking. A first grader down the street was already doing 30 minutes of math worksheets every night after school, and the neighbor had clucked that “free play is fine for little kids, but they need to get ready for middle school now, right?” Mia’s mom works full time as a dental hygienist, and she told me she stays up 20 minutes late every night grading Mia’s homework worksheets she bought off Amazon, because she doesn’t want her to fall behind.
I told her about the week before, when Mia and two friends spent the entire 45-minute morning free play block building a veterinary clinic for their stuffed animals in the block corner. The first 10 minutes were just arguing: one girl brought a 3-foot stuffed giraffe that couldn’t fit under the first table they built, and they wouldn’t let me help them fix it. They counted out 12 long unit blocks to make a new table, stacked two extra on each end to make it tall enough, and when the first roof caved in half an hour in, they didn’t cry or come get me. They took it apart, made the base wider, and tried again. By the end of the block, they’d made a waiting area, a sign that said “NO BULLDOGS ALLWED” (because their class hamster’s name is Bulldog and he “bit a patient”), and Mia had made a triage list, sorted the stuffed animals by how sick they were, and propped the clinic door open with a spare block because it kept swinging shut on people’s tails. I didn’t learn that last part from watching them the whole time. I was working with a reading group across the room. They did all of it on their own.
I get the worry, honestly. When my own son was in kindergarten, six years ago, I was that parent too. I bought a set of phonics and math workbooks, and we did one page every night after dinner, because I’d heard all the talk about summer slide and kindergarten readiness, and I was scared I’d mess him up if we didn’t do enough. One night, I noticed he’d finished his worksheet in 10 minutes, and then spent 40 minutes in the living room folding and refolding a sheet of printer paper, throwing it across the room, adjusting the wings, throwing it again. It was just a paper airplane. He failed 16 times before he got one that could fly all the way from the couch to the front door. I stood in the kitchen leaning against the counter watching him, and I realized: the 10 minutes of worksheets he’d half rushed through to get to this? That felt like a waste of time compared to the 40 minutes he spent focused, problem solving, adjusting, trying again.
Most of the time, when parents ask me if something is a waste of time, they mean “is this thing that doesn’t look like learning actually doing anything for my kid?” The answer almost always is yes, even if it doesn’t come with a grade or a completed worksheet.
I don’t tell parents to throw out all their homework or quit all their kids’ structured activities. That’s not realistic, and a lot of kids love soccer or piano or art class. What I do tell them to try is small, concrete changes. First, leave 20 minutes a day that’s totally unplanned, no screens, no adult direction, no agenda. You don’t need fancy toys: old cardboard boxes, a jar of buttons, a collection of rocks, some crayons, that’s more than enough. Second, don’t fill every dead minute with a screen. When you’re waiting 10 minutes for your table at a restaurant, or sitting in car pool line, don’t hand them your phone to watch videos. Let them stare out the window, or count the blue cars, or fiddle with the rubber band on their wrist. That’s not wasted time, that’s thinking time. Third, if you’re not sure what to ask after school, skip the generic “what did you learn today” and ask “what did you play today?” It’ll give you a better sense of what they’re actually working on, and it makes them talk more about their day anyway.
After we talked, Mia’s mom told me she’d been cutting Mia’s rock sorting time short after dinner to make her do extra reading practice. Mia’s been collecting rocks from the park every weekend, and she likes to sort them by size, by color, by how shiny they are. She’d been telling Mia it was a waste of time to sort them every night. She said she’d try cutting out the extra 15 minutes of worksheet time they were doing, and let Mia sort her rocks instead.
She texted me three days ago. She said Mia hasn’t had an after-school tantrum in a week, which is the first time that’s happened in months. Last night, Mia sorted all her rocks by how much they weighed, using the plastic toy scale she got for her birthday, and counted them all out loud all the way to 17, which is further than she’s ever counted without stopping.
It’s not all perfect, of course. I still deal with pressure from the district to add more structured lesson time to our day, and just last month I had to cut 10 minutes from our daily free play block to make room for a new required phonics program. I noticed by the end of the first week, kids were fighting more on the playground, and more of them were coming to me with tiny problems they could have solved themselves. I still fight to keep that time for them, but it’s an ongoing fight, not a win I get to check off a list.
Some days, kids are just messing around. Some days, that messing around is the most important work they’ll do all day. I still get the question, every month, from a parent sitting where Mia’s mom sat, wondering if it’s all a waste. I tell them what I told her: look closer. It’s not just playing. It’s learning. And it’s almost never a waste.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Is unstructured play for kids a waste of time