Is Unstructured Free Play a Waste of Time? A Teacher’s Real Perspective
The sticky spot on my conference table from yesterday’s juice spill hadn’t dried yet when Mia’s mom leaned forward, twisting her workout gloves between her fingers and got to the point. She’d already asked about Mia’s reading level, commented on the cat drawing Mia taped to my wall, and now she asked the question I get at least once every semester: “All that 20 minutes of free choice you do first thing every morning… is that a waste of time? I know she loves it, but between coding after school and her reading tutor, I can’t help thinking we’re losing time she could be using to get ahead.”
I didn’t answer right away, because I’d asked myself the exact same question just two months prior, about my own 10-year-old son Leo. Last July, I stood in the doorway of Leo’s room for 20 minutes watching him rearrange his rock collection for the third time that week. His half-finished summer reading packet sat on his desk, his clarinet lesson was in two days and he hadn’t practiced once, and I kept my hand on the doorknob, biting my tongue to keep from telling him to put the stupid rocks away and get to work. I thought exactly what she was thinking: this is a waste of time.
Instead, I told her what I’d watched that very morning, before she arrived for our conference. Mia and Javi, the boy who sits next to her, had been building a block tower they swore would reach the ceiling. They’d spent 12 minutes stacking, adjusting, bickering a little about where the top flag went. Then Javi turned around too fast to grab a sticker for the flag, and the whole thing toppled. I saw Mia’s face go red, saw her cross her arms, and I started walking over because I was sure there was going to be yelling. Before I got within three steps, though, Mia stomped over to the art bin, pulled out a big sheet of corrugated cardboard, and said, “We can make the base wider so it doesn’t fall again. But you have to ask before you turn next time.” Javi apologized, they carried the cardboard back to the block corner, and spent the rest of the 20 minutes rebuilding. No teacher intervention, no time-out, no big drama.
Most of the time when we ask if something is a waste of time, we’re measuring it by the things we can count: how many reading minutes logged, how many math problems finished, how many skills checked off a list. That 20 minutes of free choice doesn’t show up on any test score report, so it looks empty. But what it’s actually doing is the work that makes all the other learning possible.
I tested that myself my second year teaching. The district pushed for more uninterrupted literacy time first thing in the morning, so I cut free choice and started with phonics drills. After two months, I switched back. I was stopping three times as many petty arguments during the day, kids were coming to the nurse with stress stomachaches three times a week more than they do now, and half the class was still zoning out for the first 15 minutes of lessons anyway. Kids don’t flip a switch the second they walk through the classroom door. They’re still thinking about the fight they had with their sibling in the car drop-off line, or the bad dream they had the night before, or how nervous they are about the spelling test later. That 20 minutes of unstructured time lets them decompress, settle in, and get ready to learn. It’s not wasted. It just doesn’t look like work to an adult.
I’ve picked up a few small, concrete things over the years that help other parents stop panicking when their kid is doing something that looks like nothing. The first is the 10-minute watch rule: if you’re convinced what they’re doing is a waste of time, don’t yank them away immediately. Stand back, set a timer for 10 minutes, and just watch. When I did that with Leo and his rocks, I realized he was keeping a handwritten list in his notebook of where each rock came from, that’s writing. He was sorting them by weight and shininess, grouping them by size, that’s the same classification and comparison skills he’ll be formalizing in 5th grade science. He was also calming down after a terrible week of Little League where he struck out every time he got up to bat. That whole day of rearranging rocks was his way of resetting, just like our morning choice time at school.
The second is to carve out 15 minutes of unplanned, no-agenda time every single day, even on busy school nights. It doesn’t have to be a huge block. It can be right after homework, before you start making dinner. No screens, no scheduled activities, no prompting them to “do something productive.” If they complain they’re bored, don’t jump in with a list of ideas. Wait two minutes, let them figure it out. Boredom isn’t a waste of time, it’s how kids learn to create their own fun and solve their own problems.
Mia’s mom left the conference saying she’d stop bugging Mia about putting her crayons away when she draws horses for an hour after dinner. Last week, she sent me a text with a photo: Mia had organized a whole neighborhood horse show in her backyard, made paper tickets for everyone, drew a judging scorecard, and collected $2.50 to buy lemonade for the whole group. I still wonder sometimes, when testing season rolls around and admin reminds us every week about maximizing instructional time, if I should cut that 20 minutes to fit in more phonics practice. Then I look up, see a first grader sitting in the reading corner petting our class hamster after a bad morning with his parents’ divorce, see a group of kids building a cardboard spaceship negotiating who gets to be captain without fighting, and I remember. Time that isn’t spent checking a box on a lesson plan or a to-do list isn’t wasted. It just doesn’t get counted on anyone’s report card. And that’s okay.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Is Unstructured Free Play a Waste of Time