Is My Kid’s Unstructured Play a Waste of Time? What I’ve Learned As a Teacher and Mom
I stepped on a 2×2 blue Lego mid-cleanup last Saturday, bit my tongue to keep from swearing, and stared at the 3-foot cardboard truck stop my 7-year-old had built in the middle of the playroom. It had been 10 days since he’d touched it. My sister was coming into town that night, we needed the floor space for the air mattress, and I’d already moved three piles of scrap cardboard and a bag of bottle caps just to get this far. I grabbed the edge of the main building, ready to fold it up and toss it in the recycling bin, when small socks skidded around the corner. “Mom! Don’t!” He was breathless, fresh from digging worms out in the backyard, dirt under his fingernails. “That’s where the zombie apocalypse survivors refuel their motorcycles. You can’t throw it away.” I sighed. That morning, I’d reminded him twice to practice his multiplication flash cards and start sketching his school dinosaur diorama, due next Friday. Instead of either, he’d spent an hour that morning tweaking the truck stop’s parking lines. I stood there, leaning on the cardboard, and thought the same thing a hundred parents have thought before: Is this actually a waste of time?
I ask myself that question all the time, actually, and not just at home. I’m a 4th grade teacher, and every month I get at least one email from a parent panicking about something their kid is obsessed with that doesn’t “count” as learning. Last month it was Mia, a quiet kid in my class who spent three full 45-minute art periods drawing nothing but different sneakers she’d seen her classmates wear. The assignment was to draw a landscape of your favorite place. Mia’s mom emailed me after school, worrying she was wasting time, avoiding the work, should she make Mia start over before we turned the projects in for the bulletin board.
I told her no, let me check in with Mia first. When I asked Mia what was up with the sneakers, she pulled out her sketchbook and pointed to each one, telling me which brands had more cushion, which ones fell apart after a month of recess, which kids got theirs as hand-me-downs vs new. She’d been counting how many of each color she saw at recess every day for a week. I told her mom that wasn’t a waste, that if she wanted, Mia could turn it into something that checked the boxes for the assignment if she really needed to, but there was no harm in letting her draw what she cared about. Two months later, Mia entered that sneaker project in our school’s small science fair. She’d graphed her data, calculated average costs, interviewed 12 kids about how their sneakers held up. She got honorable mention. Her mom texted me a photo of her holding her certificate, and said she never would have guessed that drawing sneakers would turn into that.
Back to my living room, I caved. We squeezed the air mattress onto the couch in the front room instead of clearing the playroom, and the truck stop stayed. Over the next three days, I watched my son and my 10-year-old nephew play with it for almost four hours straight when my nephew came to visit. They negotiated roles, made up new rules for the zombie virus when one of them got “bitten”, and argued for 20 minutes about whether a motorcycle could fit through the entrance I’d accidentally narrowed when I leaned on it. Later that week, I heard my son explaining to my husband how he’d figured out how many parking spots he could fit. He counted the width of each semi, added 6 inches for space between each, and subtracted two spots for the gas pumps. That was the multiplication he was supposed to be practicing. I hadn’t even made him do it. He did it because he needed it for his truck stop.
I’ve started testing a little rule of thumb when I catch myself wondering if something is a waste of time, and I tell other parents to try it too. First, check three quick things: Is anyone getting hurt, is anyone breaking a rule that matters, and does your kid actually care about what they’re doing? If they can tell you what they’re working on, even if it’s a silly story about zombie survivors, and they keep coming back to it without you pushing, it’s not a waste. It doesn’t matter if it doesn’t look like learning to you.
What if it’s actually a problem? Like you need the floor space, or it’s cutting into homework that actually has to get turned in next day? You don’t have to let it take over forever, and you don’t have to feel guilty for clearing it away. One concrete trick I use is: if it’s a physical build like the truck stop, take three photos to save in their kid’s photo album before you take it down, and schedule a 30-minute block next weekend to rebuild if they still want to. I did that with the truck stop two weeks later when we needed the space for a birthday party. My son didn’t even cry, he just picked out his favorite photo to tape to his fridge. If it’s a kid veering off on a school assignment, try asking “Can you show me how what you’re working on can fit what your teacher asked for?” before you tell them to stop. More often than not, they can connect the dots, and you end up with a more interesting project than the generic one they would have turned in. If they can’t, negotiate: 20 minutes working on your thing, 20 minutes working on the required assignment. That’s easy to stick to, no big screaming fight.
Last week, I found a half-built mouse hotel behind my couch, made out of empty toilet paper rolls and scrap fabric. It’s blocking the air vent a little, and my son has been working on it for three days after school instead of finishing his spelling practice early. I still had that little twinge, the one that says this is mess, this is wasted time, shouldn’t he be doing something that matters? I moved the hotel a few inches to the side so the air can flow, and asked him how the mice would order room service. He pulled out a tiny notepad he’d made for the front desk and explained the whole system for 10 minutes. I still get it wrong sometimes. Some nights I’m tired and I make him stop building to do his flash cards before he’s ready, and there’s a fight. There’s no perfect way to do this. But I’ve stopped calling the messy, unplanned stuff a waste of time. It usually turns out to be the stuff they remember anyway.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Is My Kid’s Unstructured Play a Waste of Time