Is My Child’s Constant Doodling a Waste of Time? What I Learned As A Mom And 4th Grade Teacher
I was grading 4th grade fraction quizzes at my kitchen table last Tuesday, half-listening to my 10-year-old son Leo hum next to me. He was supposed to be wrapping up his required 20 minutes of independent reading for homework, but when I glanced over, his chapter book was closed face-down on the table. His notebook was covered page after page in tiny, detailed doodles of spaceships, each with a different hand-drawn flag painted on the side in colored pencil. My first reaction was a familiar little spike of irritation. Here we go, I thought. Another 45 minutes wasted when he could be practicing multiplication flash cards, or finishing that extra credit book report he’s been putting off, or even just cleaning out the fish tank like I asked three days ago.
Before I could say anything, my phone buzzed. It was a text from my sister, whose 9-year-old son spends every after-school minute folding origami dinosaurs. The photo showed a dining table covered in a hundred crumpled paper dinosaurs, and her caption read: Is this just a waste of time? Should I make him stop and do something productive?
That question hit close to home. I’ve been a 4th grade teacher for 12 years, and I’ve heard it from dozens of parents: Is all that Lego building a waste? Is it bad that they just sit and draw instead of doing learning apps? Is this thing a waste of time? I used to answer the way most people do, with a vague “oh, it’s fine, creativity is good” but I didn’t really believe it myself, not all the way. Not until last school year, when I had a student named Mia that changed my mind.
Mia sat in the back row of my class, and she doodled through every single lesson. I’d remind her a dozen times a day to put the pen down and pay attention. I’d even taken her notebook away once during a reading quiz, convinced that was why her scores were stuck right below grade level. At fall parent-teacher conferences, her mom brought the notebook back, and spread the pages out on the table. Every doodle was a map of the Amazon rainforest, labeled with tiny, neat names of every plant and animal Mia had learned from the nature documentaries she watched every weekend. Some of the names were words I didn’t even know. Her mom told me Mia couldn’t focus if her hand wasn’t moving. If she couldn’t doodle, she’d zone out completely.
I decided to stop nagging her. I told her she could keep doodling as long as she joined our class discussions when I called on her. Within a month, her participation went up. She started raising her hand to talk about ecosystems, because she’d already learned so much from the research she did for her maps. By the end of the year, her reading test score jumped up a full grade level. That’s when I started to see what I’d been missing: what looks like wasting time is often just work that doesn’t look like school work.
After that conference with Mia’s mom, I started checking in with myself when I got that irritated spike with Leo. It’s easy to get caught up in the idea that every minute of a kid’s day needs to be productive, that if it’s not counting towards a grade or a skill on a list, it’s wasted. I’ve fallen for it too, scrolling through mom groups and seeing people talk about summer slide and enrichment activities and wondering if I’m letting Leo fall behind because he’d rather draw than do a math workbook.
But over the last year, I’ve tested out three small changes that work for me, and I tell other parents about them all the time. First, we keep a short list of non-negotiable tasks every day: finish homework, 20 minutes of reading, feed the dog, put your dirty clothes in the hamper. Once those are done, any extra time is Leo’s to do whatever he wants, no questions asked (well, almost no questions). Second, if I do feel that twinge that this is a waste, I ask one simple question before I intervene: “What are you working on here?” Nine times out of ten, there’s way more going on than I see. When I asked Leo that about his spaceships, he pulled out the back page of his notebook and showed me a whole list of crew members, each with a backstory, and a map of the galaxy they’re traveling through. He’s been writing little snippets of their story between drawings, working on it for a month. That’s planning, that’s storytelling, that’s way more creative than any of the writing prompts I give my 4th graders. Third, I just keep his supplies out on the edge of the kitchen table instead of making him put them away after every session. That way I don’t have a fight about getting them out, and I don’t trip over them when I’m trying to make dinner. It’s a small adjustment that cut out 90% of our arguments.
Last weekend, Leo spent three straight hours rearranging his doodle notebook, gluing all the spaceships in order by fleet. He didn’t start the extra credit volcano project I suggested he work on, and I felt that familiar little twinge of worry. But I asked him when he planned to do it, and he said he’d get it done after soccer on Saturday, which he did. It turned out fine.
I still catch myself sometimes, looking at an afternoon spent doodling and wondering if I should push him to do more. I still text my sister sometimes, panicking that Leo is spending too much time on this one little hobby, that he’s missing out on something more useful. But lately, I’ve been remembering Mia, and her rainforest maps, and how much she learned when no one was making her stop. It doesn’t show up on a test score right now, that time spent doodling or folding origami or building tiny Lego cities. But it’s not wasted. Some days, it feels like it’s the stuff that matters most. I don’t have it all figured out, and some weeks we still fight about when to put the pencils down for dinner. But so far, leaving the colored pencils out hasn’t hurt anyone.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Is My Child’s Constant Doodling a Waste of Time