Is It Worth Letting Your Kid Turn In Low-Quality Work For School? A Teacher Mom’s Take
Last Sunday night, I was wiping flour off the kitchen counter while my 10-year-old Leo put the final touches on his regional landform project. He’d spent three weekends tramping around the creek behind our house, digging up clay for his hills and taking photos with his beat-up hand-me-down tablet to tape to the project board. When he pulled up the photos to print, I leaned over his shoulder and winced. The first was half out of frame, a big thumb smudged across the upper left corner. The second was so underexposed you could barely make out the creek through the dark. The third was blurry enough that the willow tree he wanted to highlight looked like a green blob. “Babe,” I said, “those are really low quality. I can run over there tomorrow before school and snap a few clear ones. It’ll take 10 minutes.” Leo shook his head, tapping the thumb photo with his finger. “I took that right after I saw a bullfrog. It’s my photo. I wanna use it.”
I’ve been a 4th grade teacher for 12 years, so I know better than to panic over messy kid work. But that doesn’t mean the panic doesn’t creep in. I still remember my oldest son’s first grade animal poster, back when I was a new mom and way too worried about what other people would think. His letters were lopsided, the glue was peeling up at the corners, and the picture he drew of a bear looked more like a lumpy potato. I waited till he fell asleep, redid the whole thing, and taped his original drawing in the corner as an afterthought. He got an A, but when it was his turn to present it to the class, he stood there and said my mom did most of it. He never even wanted to hang it on our fridge after that. That memory’s been stuck in my head ever since.
So I bit my tongue that Sunday night. I helped him feed the photos through our finicky home printer, which left faint streaks across all of them, and let him glue them on himself. He wrote captions under each in his messy, slanted handwriting, and drew a tiny stick-figure frog next to the thumb photo. He hauled the whole board to school the next morning, holding it in front of him like it was a museum piece.
A few days later, I sat in on his class presentations, because I team teach with his teacher this year. When Leo got up front, he didn’t skip past the blurry photos. He pointed straight at the thumb and laughed, told the class that’s what happens when you see a frog and panic so you move your camera. The whole class laughed with him, and then he spent five minutes telling them about how the creek erodes the bank every spring, how he found three different kinds of rocks there. When I graded the projects later, I didn’t mark him down for the photos. The rubric says 70% of the grade is content: can you name the landforms, can you explain how they change over time, did you complete all the requirements. The other 30% is effort. Leo put in the effort. He did it all on his own. A blurry photo doesn’t change that.
I get why parents want to fix it. We see the low quality, we think that means our kid isn’t trying, or that the teacher will think we don’t care. Most of the time, that’s not what teachers see. I get dozens of projects every year that are perfectly polished, and I can tell within 30 seconds that the parent did most of the work. The kid can’t answer basic questions about it when they present. Those don’t get better grades than the messy kid-made ones, not from me, not from most teachers I know.
If you’re staring at your kid’s blurry photo or lopsided project right now and itching to fix it, here’s what I do: First, step back and ask two quick questions. Is anyone going to get hurt if this stays the way it is? Will the grade be so unfairly low that it messes up their whole marking period? Nine times out of ten, the answer to both is no. Second, if you do offer help, only help with the stuff your kid actually can’t do. If they can’t operate the printer, help with that. If they need a heavy piece of cardboard cut, do that. Don’t redraw the diagram, don’t retake the photo, don’t rearrange the words to make them neater. That’s their part.
Last year, Leo did a science fair project and drew his bar graph by hand, and the lines were wonky and he mislabeled one axis. He got a B instead of the A he would’ve gotten if I’d fixed it. On the drive home, we talked about what he noticed: that next time, he can use the graph template on the school computer if he wants it to be clearer, that it’s okay to ask for help checking your work before you turn it in. That lesson stuck with him way more than if I’d made a perfect graph for him and he’d gotten an A he didn’t earn.
Just this week, Leo brought home a new assignment: a family history poster that needs photos of our grandparents. He dragged out our old photo album, propped the prints on the coffee table, and started snapping photos with his tablet. I walked past a minute ago, and all the photos are tilted, blurry, and have flash glare off the glass of the album pages. I opened my mouth to offer to scan them at work, and he looked up and said “Mom, I got this.” I closed my mouth, nodded, and went back to folding laundry.
I still get that little twinge of worry, that people will think we don’t care, that he could’ve gotten a better grade if we’d just fixed it. It doesn’t go away, even after 12 years of teaching and 15 years of parenting. But so far, every messy, blurry, low-quality thing that’s been entirely his has been worth it. We’ll see how the poster turns out.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Is It Worth Letting Your Kid Turn In Low-Quality Work For School