Is It Acceptable For Kids To Still Wear Masks: A Teacher’s Perspective
First day of fourth grade, I’m restocking glue sticks by the front door, coffee steaming in my chipped unicorn mug, when Milo walks in. He’s got his new backpack covered in planet stickers, and his familiar dark blue constellation mask pulled tight over his nose and chin. Before I can say good morning, Javi, who sits in the front row, leans over and yells across the room, “Why are you still wearing a mask? My mom says we don’t have to do that anymore!” A few other kids go quiet, turn to look. Milo’s shoulders hunch, and he tugs the edge of his mask down then up again, like he’s not sure what to do.
I remember last spring, his mom emailed me to say his two-year-old sister just finished chemo, and they were still being extra careful about germs. But that’s their family’s business, not something I need to announce to the whole class. So I just smile and say, “Milo gets to choose what makes him comfortable, just like Javi chose that awesome dinosaur shirt today. Let’s get everyone’s name tags out.” That’s the end of the conversation for that moment, but it stuck with me, because it’s the question I get asked all the time these days: is this actually okay? Is it acceptable for kids to still wear masks, when most people stopped years ago?
At recess that day, I sat on the bench next to Milo while he ate his Goldfish crackers. I asked how he was feeling about the first day, and he admitted it wasn’t just his sister. “When the class gets really loud during indoor recess, the mask makes it quieter. And I don’t have to worry if my face looks weird when I’m nervous.” I’d never thought about that before, but it made sense. For a lot of kids, masks aren’t just about germs anymore. They’re a small buffer against a loud, overwhelming world.
Over the next week, three more kids brought masks to school. Lila, who gets terrible fall pollen allergies, said it kept her from sneezing through the whole walk to the playground. Sam, who gets anxious presenting in front of the class, said he didn’t want everyone staring at his mouth when he forgot his lines. By the end of the first week, I had three emails from parents. One asked if it was allowed for her son to wear a mask, because he’d asked to start bringing one after seeing Milo. Another asked if I could ask kids not to wear masks, because it made her “anxious to see them back.”
I get where the uncertainty comes from. We all heard so many conflicting rules for so long, then suddenly everything switched, and everyone is left figuring out what works for their own family. Some parents worry masks get in the way of kids reading facial expressions, or that their kid will be teased for being different. I’ve thought about that too. But what I’ve seen this year is that forcing a kid to take off a mask they feel safe in causes way more harm than any potential downsides. Last year, Milo forgot his mask one day and spent the whole class period fidgeting, staring at his desk, not raising his hand once even when I know he knew the answer. He told me after he spent the whole day worrying he’d get his sister sick. That’s a level of stress no kid needs to carry just because other people think masks are “over.”
I didn’t do a big assembly or an hour-long lesson about masks. I just added one line to the classroom rules poster we made together the first week: “Anyone can wear a mask any day for any reason.” If a kid asks me why another kid is wearing one, I just say “It’s their choice, just like you get to choose what shoes to wear.” That’s it, no big drama, no oversharing someone else’s private business. This translates to home too, for parents. If your kid asks why their friend wears a mask, you don’t need to dig for a reason or whisper about it like it’s a secret. Just answer that it’s their choice, and leave it at that. If your own kid wants to wear a mask, you don’t need to pressure them to stop. Just check that they can take it off easily when they eat or play outside, and that it’s not too hot for the weather. If your kid teases another kid for wearing one, correct it the same way you’d correct them for teasing someone’s shoes or haircut: it’s not anyone’s business but the person wearing it.
It’s been almost three months now, and no one thinks twice about masks in our room. Some days Milo wears it, some days he leaves it crumpled in his backpack. Last week I wore one when I had a head cold, and no one made a big deal out of it. When a new student joined us two weeks ago, she wore a mask her first five days, and no one asked any questions. It’s just a normal part of our room now.
I still get questions from other teachers and parents sometimes. Some people still think it’s strange, a holdover from something we should all just move past. I don’t push the issue, and I never tell anyone they have to make their kid wear a mask. What I do tell them is that the point of school and parenting is to help kids feel safe enough to learn and be themselves. If a mask makes them feel safe, whether that’s because they’re protecting a family member, they’re anxious, or they just like how it feels, that’s a good enough reason. There’s no deadline for feeling comfortable, and no rule that says everyone has to do the same thing all the time. It’s working for us right now, and that’s enough for me.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Is It Acceptable For Kids To Still Wear Masks: A Teacher’s Perspective