Is an M.Com Worth It After B.Com? A Parent’s Guide To Making The Right Call
Last April, I was clearing dinner dishes when my 22-year-old nephew Aryan yelled from the dining table, asking me to come look at his screen. He’d just wrapped his final B.Com exams, crumbs of garlic naan still dotted his plate, and his laptop was split between a LinkedIn job search and the prospectus for a full-time M.Com program at a local college. My sister, his mom, leaned against the doorframe, arms crossed. “All his friends are signing up,” she said. “His cousin did M.Com, got a government job. Why would he skip it?”
Aryan just slouched back in his chair. “I don’t even know if I want a government job,” he said. “I did that three-month internship at Sharma Ji’s CA firm last year. I liked sorting client filings and sorting GST returns, but if I do two years of full-time M.Com, I lose two years of experience. What’s the point of that?”
Five years ago, my own daughter sat at that same table asking the exact same question. She turned down a full-time M.Com spot to do a six-month certification in digital accounting, and she’s now a senior accounts executive at an FMCG company, making more than many of her friends who stuck out full-time master’s. But one of those same friends, who did her M.Com straight after B.Com, is now a lecturer at a local community college, a job she loves that she never could have gotten without the postgraduate degree. There’s no universal “yes” or “no” here, that much I’ve learned. It all depends on what the person actually wants to do, not what everyone else expects of them.
A week after that dinner, I ran into Aryan’s B.Com department head at the local vegetable market, and we got talking about this question. She said the biggest mistake she sees parents and students make is assuming a higher degree is automatically better. Most private sector entry-level roles for commerce graduates don’t require an M.Com. They just require you to know how to use Tally, file GST returns, and manage a basic spreadsheet. A six-month certification will get you that faster and cheaper than two years of full-time master’s, and you’ll start earning and building experience much sooner.
But if you want to teach commerce at the college level, or apply for senior government finance roles that tie starting pay to your degree level, an M.Com is non-negotiable. Many state-level teaching jobs even require M.Com just to be eligible to apply, so that’s a hard line that doesn’t change no matter how much work experience you have.
We worked through this with Aryan step by step, no big speeches, just a quick list on a piece of scrap paper. First, we had him write down three things he could see himself doing in five years. He came up with: work as an accountant at a mid-sized firm, eventually start his own small practice for local clients, and if that doesn’t work out, teach commerce at a college or full-time tuition center. Then we matched each goal to whether M.Com was required. For the first two, it wasn’t required, but it wouldn’t hurt if he had it. For the third, it was mandatory.
That’s when we remembered the middle ground no one talks about much: distance M.Com. It’s recognized by UGC, it costs a third of what a full-time program costs, and you can do the coursework on your own time while holding a job or studying for professional certifications like CA or CS. Aryan applied, got accepted, and took that entry-level role at the CA firm he interned at. He works 9 to 5 Monday through Friday, does his M.Com assignments for an hour or two after dinner, and writes his exams once a year. It’s not perfect—he says some nights he’s too tired after work to open his textbook, and he can’t go out with his old college friends as much as he used to. But he’s already getting a paycheck, he’s built relationships with half a dozen regular clients at the firm, and he has the degree waiting for him if he ever needs it down the line.
As a parent, I know the pressure to check the “higher degree” box. My sister was worried at first what the neighbors and relatives would say if Aryan didn’t do a full-time master’s. “Everyone asks why he’s working instead of studying,” she told me a month in. But after Aryan got his first paycheck and paid for his own new bike, that worry faded. I’ve talked to too many parents who pushed their kid into a full-time M.Com just because it seemed like the right next step, only to end up with a kid who has a degree they never use and two years of work experience they missed out on.
Instead of defaulting to M.Com because that’s what everyone does, there are three concrete questions parents can ask their kid to sort this out: First, ask them to name one job they’d actually be excited to start right after B.Com. Second, pull up a couple of recent job postings for that role and check if it says a master’s degree is required. Third, if they don’t know what they want to do yet, ask if they’d rather work an entry-level job for a year while they figure it out, instead of starting a master’s they don’t feel committed to.
Aryan’s six months into his current setup now, and he’s recently started talking about applying for CA articleship next year. His distance M.Com will still count towards that requirement, so that works out for him. He might end up never using his M.Com degree, or he might decide in a few years that he wants to teach, and be grateful he has it already. There’s no perfect answer that fits everyone, and that’s okay. The right call is the one that fits what your kid actually wants, not the one that looks good on a family gathering conversation.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Is an M