I’m Worried About My 11 Year Old Girl: What Subtle Shifts Mean And Small Steps That Help
Last Saturday, I pulled the brownie pan out of the oven and set it on the counter to cool, just like I did when Lila, my 11-year-old cousin, was 7 and would climb on a step stool to swipe rainbow sprinkles before I could even screw the lid back on. This time, she leaned against the far counter, thumb scrolling TikTok, and only looked up when I said her name twice.
Lila’s my aunt’s only kid, and my aunt works two retail jobs right now, so Lila stays with me at least two nights a week and every other weekend. I’ve watched her grow up, so I notice the small changes that other people might brush off. She used to ramble all the way home from school about art projects or drama in her friend group, stopping every two blocks to point out a stray cat or a weird cloud. Now she walks out of the school building, plugs in her headphones, and doesn’t talk until I ask her a direct question. Her teacher sent a note home last month saying she used to get written up for talking too much during independent work; now she never participates in class discussions and has turned in three almost-blank assignments.
When I brought this up to a couple of friends, the most common response was “Oh, it’s just pre-teen hormones, all 11 year old girls get moody.” That line made my chest tight, because it’s not moodiness. Moodiness is snapping at you because you bought the wrong flavor of yogurt. This is withdrawal. This is a kid who used to fill three sketchbooks a month with drawings of rainbow cats and mermaids, now hiding her sketchbook under her mattress so no one sees it’s full of nothing but dark gray scribbles.
My first try at addressing it went exactly how you’d expect. I sat her down at the kitchen table, closed my laptop, and said “Lila, can we chat? I’ve noticed you seem really down lately.” She crossed her arms, stared at her shoes, and mumbled “I’m fine” before walking back to the couch. That’s when I remembered what I learned working as an after-school aide a few years back: kids don’t open up when you’re staring them down waiting for them to talk. They open up when you’re both doing something else, side by side, no pressure to perform or fix anything.
I switched up my approach. I went to the dollar store and bought a terrible floral adult coloring book and a pack of 24 cheap colored pencils, and I just started coloring on the couch next to her every night while she scrolls. I don’t ask her to join. I just complain out loud about how stupid the flower outlines are, how I can’t ever stay inside the lines. One night I said “This big rose is driving me crazy, can you scribble over it for me? I’m terrible at this.” She hesitated, then put her phone down and scribbled all over it.
After a week of that, she pulled her own sketchbook out one night. It took another three days before she said anything about what’s been going on. Turns out her best friend since first grade started hanging out with a group of older girls, and Lila got left out of their big end-of-summer sleepover. She didn’t tell anyone because she thought it was stupid to still care that much about a best friend at 11. Then, a couple of weeks later, her math teacher called her out in front of the whole class for not knowing her 7s times tables, and she decided it wasn’t worth turning in any work if everyone was just going to laugh at her for getting it wrong.
When she told me that, the first thing I wanted to do was call her teacher, call Mia’s mom, fix everything right then. But I didn’t. I just said “I remember when my best friend left me out of her 8th grade birthday party, I hid in the bathroom during lunch for three days and ate a whole bag of candy corn by myself. I was so embarrassed I didn’t tell anyone for a year.” That’s it. I didn’t say “you’ll find new friends” or “it’s not that big of a deal” I just told her a small bad thing that happened to me, to let her know it’s okay to feel bad about this.
The next week, I emailed Lila’s teacher. I didn’t demand anything, I just explained what Lila had told me, and asked if she could do one small thing: check in with Lila before class to go over what’s expected for the day’s assignment, instead of calling on her to answer out loud in front of everyone. The teacher agreed right away, it took her two minutes a day. We also got a $5 times table game app on her phone, and we play one 5-minute round every night while we wait for dinner or for brownies to cool. No grades, no pressure, just whoever gets the most answers right picks the dessert.
It’s only been a month, so it’s not like everything is fixed. Lila is still quieter than she was two years ago. She still pulls out her phone and zones out when something hard comes up, instead of talking about it. She went to Mia’s birthday party last weekend, and when she got back she just said “it was okay” and went back to coloring. It didn’t fix the friendship, but it didn’t break her any more than she already was. Last week, she turned in a full drawing for art class, and her teacher put it up on the hallway bulletin board. She showed it to me after school, which is more than she would have done a month ago.
I still worry about her. Some nights I lie awake thinking I’m not doing enough, that she needs more than just coloring on the couch and 5 minutes of math games. But I’ve also learned that with 11 year old girls, you don’t need to fix everything all at once. You just need to stop brushing off the quiet changes as “just hormones” and show up, even when they don’t want to talk. Right now, that’s enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » I’m Worried About My 11 Year Old Girl: What Subtle Shifts Mean And Small Steps That Help