I’m Worried About My 11-Year-Old Girl: What I Noticed And Small, Doable Steps That Help
Last weekend at my aunt’s backyard barbecue, I was sent to fetch Lila for burger buns when I spotted it, tucked behind her throw pillow: the beat-up blue sketchbook she used to carry everywhere. Three years ago, she’d pull it out at every family gathering, shoving it under my nose to show me new drawings of mermaids or our old golden retriever. That day, when I knocked, she jumped off her bed and slammed her laptop shut, like I’d caught her doing something she shouldn’t. “I’m not hungry,” she mumbled, not meeting my eye. “I’ll get something later.”
My aunt brushes it off, says all 11-year-old girls are moody, it’s just what happens when they hit middle school. She blames too much screen time, says Lila would be fine if she’d just put the phone down and go back to being the outgoing kid she used to be. I work as a paraprofessional in a local elementary school, so I see this shift all the time, but it still pulled at me when it was my cousin. I still have the crumpled portrait Lila drew of my cat taped to my fridge, next to my grocery list. I know what she looks like when she’s just being a kid, not just scrolling or hiding.
A month ago, I stayed over at their house and brought her the pack of scented glitter gel pens she’d begged for two Christmases prior. She twisted one open, sniffed it, and put it back down. “It’s stupid,” she said, picking at a loose thread on her comforter. “All the girls in my class post their art on TikTok. All of theirs look like they’re from a real book. Mine just looks like kid stuff.”
That’s when my worry clicked into place. It wasn’t just moodiness, and it wasn’t that she didn’t love drawing anymore. She’d just switched to a big new middle school this year, got split up from her best friend since kindergarten, and suddenly every hobby she used to do for fun became something she had to perform for likes. Every drawing, every grade, every photo from the weekend got posted and scored by her friend group, and she’d decided the things she used to enjoy weren’t good enough to share.
I talk to so many parents who say the same thing my aunt does: they just need to limit screen time, they’ll grow out of it. And sure, screen time limits can help, but I’ve never seen a hard cut off fix the root of this kind of shutdown. What I’ve seen work is small, slow shifts that let kids get back to liking things without the pressure to be perfect at them.
I didn’t start by telling Lila social media was bad, or that she shouldn’t care what other people think. That never works, anyway. I just asked her to show me the art accounts she follows. We sat for 10 minutes scrolling, and I pointed out that every single one of the artists she thought was perfect had been posting consistently for 5 or more years. Most started drawing when they were her age, but they only post their finished, edited work now. They don’t post the 12 crumpled bad sketches they threw away before they got one they liked. She nodded, said she’d never actually thought about that before.
After that, I suggested we do a no-phone art night at my apartment every Wednesday after school. The rules are simple: we leave both our phones in the entry closet, no taking pictures of anything we draw, no talking about likes or followers or how good anything is. We just draw whatever we want, and if we don’t want to draw, we just sit and eat popcorn and watch bad 90s cartoons. The first week, she sat on my couch picking at a loose thread for 20 minutes, said she didn’t know what to draw. I pulled out a pad and drew a really lopsided cat, and she laughed so hard she snort-laughed, then drew a terrible dragon breathing glitter on my cat. By the end of the night, she’d filled half a page with little dinosaurs for my coworker’s kid’s birthday, and she didn’t once ask me if it was good enough.
I also talked to my aunt about small changes she could make at home, no big fights or strict new rules. I told her instead of opening with “what grade did you get on your test” when Lila gets home from school, try asking “what was the weirdest thing that happened at lunch today.” Instead of saying “why don’t you ever draw anymore” – which just makes Lila feel like she’s failing at being the kid she used to be – try saying “I saw that artist you liked posted a new painting, can you show me what you think of it.”
She was skeptical at first, said it felt silly to change how she talks to her own kid, but she tried it. After a week, she told me Lila actually stayed at the dinner table for 10 extra minutes talking about how her friend put a gummy worm in the teacher’s coffee, instead of just picking at her food and asking to be excused.
It’s been two months now. Lila still spends a few hours a day on TikTok, she still gets quiet when her friends post group photos she wasn’t invited to, and we haven’t “fixed” anything. She hasn’t started posting her art again, and some weeks she’d rather scroll than draw at art night, and that’s fine. Last week, though, she brought her beat-up blue sketchbook to my place, flipped it open to a 12-page comic about her grumpy tabby cat that steals socks, and just let me read it. She didn’t ask if it was good enough to post. She just pointed to the panel where the cat hides the sock in the family Christmas tree and said, “that’s my favorite part.” It’s not a big, perfect win. But it’s something.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » I’m Worried About My 11-Year-Old Girl: What I Noticed And Small, Doable Steps That Help