I Tossed My Screen Time Chart and Tried This Instead For My Kid’s Tablet Habits
If you’d told me a month ago I’d be the mom letting her 7-year-old use a tablet for three hours straight on a Saturday, I’d have called you a liar. I had the whole system worked out: 90 minutes a day, split into two 45-minute blocks, no screens an hour before bed, no screens at the dinner table. I wrote the times down on a little whiteboard by the fridge, high fived myself for being consistent. Then last month I caught Leo hiding behind the linen closet, tablet propped on a stack of extra bed sheets, watching Minecraft roleplays after he’d already hit his limit for the day. I yelled, he cried, and then I went to the kitchen and stood there scrolling my phone while the pasta boiled, feeling like a total hypocrite. What was I even punishing him for, anyway? Wanting to watch the thing he cared about after I’d already spent an hour scrolling my own Instagram feed that morning?
I was complaining about the fight to another mom at the playground the next week, the one who brings homemade granola bars and never yells, at least not where anyone can hear. I expected her to agree that kids these days are too obsessed with screens, or give me some tip about rotating board games to wean him off. Instead she said she got rid of all her hard time limits a year ago, and swapped them for what she calls “tablet projects.” The idea is: mindless watching is fine in small doses, but if they want more time than that, they have to use the tablet to work on something they’re actually into. They don’t just consume, they make or learn something. I left the playground thinking that sounded like a bunch of hippie mom nonsense, and also definitely a loophole for kids to get way more screen time than they should. But by that Wednesday, I was so tired of the daily “can I have five more minutes please please please” begging that I decided to try it for a week, just to see.
The first day was a Saturday. I sat Leo down and explained the new loose rule, half expecting him to immediately ask to watch endless cartoon fail compilations. Instead he lit up and said he wanted to finish his Lego Minecraft fox. He’d gotten the set for his birthday two weeks before, and lost the paper instruction manual somewhere between the car and the living room. I’d told him tough luck, that he’d have to wait till I ordered a new one. That day, he pulled up a step-by-step video from some kid his age who built the same set, propped the tablet up on the coffee table, and got to work. I hovered in the hallway for the first 20 minutes, waiting for him to click over to something dumb. But he didn’t. He paused the video every time he needed to hunt for a tiny brick, rewound it twice when he put a wing on the wrong way, and didn’t ask me for a single thing for two and a half hours. I folded three loads of laundry, drank my coffee while it was still hot, and didn’t argue with anyone once. It was weird, how quiet and nice it was.
It’s not all peaceful coffee drinking, obviously. The slime incident last week is proof of that. Leo decided he wanted to make fluffy slime for his friend’s birthday, so he pulled up a dozen slime videos. I walked in halfway through and he was just watching some 13-year-old squish different colored slime for 10 minutes, rambling about how crunchy this one is. My first instinct was to grab the tablet and say this isn’t a project, this is just messing around. But I bit my tongue and waited. Ten minutes later, he clicked out and found the actual recipe, made a messy list of ingredients in crayon, and made me drive to the dollar store to buy glitter glue and extra baking soda. We made it at the kitchen table that night, and it got glitter all over my good wooden table, and half of it ended up on the dog when he tried to lick it. But Leo wrapped it up in a plastic bag with a bow and brought it to his friend, and the friend loved it. I still haven’t gotten all the glitter out of the rug, but whatever.
It’s not a perfect system, don’t get me wrong. Last Sunday, Leo got wrapped up in editing a stop motion video of his Lego guys fighting a dragon, and he lost track of time. We were supposed to go get ice cream at our favorite spot down the street at 2, and by 2:45 he was still saying “just five more minutes, I have to add the roar sound effects.” I got mad, we yelled at each other, I put the tablet away on the top shelf, and we ended up going to get ice cream but we were both sulky the whole time. I still feel guilty sometimes, when I see other parents posting about how their kids only use tablets for 30 minutes a day of curated educational apps. Some days he still just zones out for an hour watching those stupid 10-minute compilations of people falling off bikes, and I feel that old panic creep in, like I’m messing him up. I still put the tablet away an hour before bed, no exceptions. I still check what he’s watching every once in a while, because I’ve seen the weird inappropriate stuff that pops up on YouTube Kids that I don’t want him seeing.
But the thing is, I think I was approaching it all wrong before. I treated the tablet like a bad thing that had to be rationed, like a candy bar. But it’s just a tool, isn’t it? Last week we found a weird black and yellow caterpillar on the milkweed we planted in the backyard, and Leo ran inside, grabbed the tablet, looked it up, and found out it was a monarch caterpillar, right before we released it back. He taught me how to add text to a video last week, when I was making a little clip of my niece’s birthday to send to my sister. I never would have let him mess around with video editing apps if I was counting every minute, because that would have eaten up half his daily limit before he even figured out how the app worked.
The daily fight is gone, for the most part. No more whiteboard, no more counting minutes, no more hiding tablets behind linen closets. Sometimes we still fight, sometimes I still get annoyed, sometimes he wastes a whole afternoon watching dumb videos. But that’s okay, isn’t it? I waste whole afternoons watching dumb videos sometimes too. I don’t think that makes me a bad person. I guess it doesn’t make him a bad kid, either.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » I Tossed My Screen Time Chart and Tried This Instead For My Kid’s Tablet Habits