I Joined a New Plant Group Last Week and Finally Read All The Rules. Here’s What I Didn’t Expect.
I was sitting cross-legged on my couch at 10:17 last Tuesday, picking cold fried rice out of the takeout container with a fork that had a bent tine, half-watching a re-run of that GBBO season where everyone’s meringue collapsed, when I decided to finally join that local house plant swap group my coworker won’t stop talking about.
Normally I do what everyone does, right? Click join, wait for approval, scroll right past the giant pinned rules post, hit accept to the terms without reading a single bullet. Got stung bad last month, though. I joined a sourdough baking group, posted a quick question asking if anyone had a good egg substitute for a loaf I wanted to make for my cousin who’s allergic, and two hours later I got a notification that I’d been removed permanently. Never even got a note saying which rule I broke. I still wonder if it was rule 3, whatever rule 3 is. So this time, I figured I’d actually read the thing. No more banned for life over egg substitutes.
I expected the usual boring stuff: no spam, be nice, don’t be a jerk. A lot of that was there, sure, but most of the rules were way more specific than that. No marking up cuttings for sale above what you paid for supplies, no bringing one sad little cutting to the swap and walking out with five big healthy plants. No popping into someone’s post of a new variegated monstera to comment that they overpaid. No unsolicited care advice—if someone didn’t ask for tips, keep your “actually you should…” to yourself. I paused at that one. I can’t count how many times I’ve been on a plant post where 10 people are arguing in the comments about how wrong the OP is watering it, when the OP just posted a photo because they were excited about their new leaf. At the bottom of the rules, there’s a little line that said “Before you post, go check out this month’s community highlights. It’ll tell you more about what we actually do here than any rule will.”
I almost skipped that. I’ve seen community highlights in other groups, they’re just 20 photos of the same 5 popular people’s perfect, giant, Instagram-worthy plants that make you feel bad for your sad little collection that’s half eaten by fungus gnats. But I was already here, I’d already read all the rules, so I clicked. It wasn’t that at all.
First post up was a guy sharing his snake plant that he’s had for seven years. It only has two leaves. It leans so far to the left that he has to prop it up with a vintage wooden spoon he got from his grandma’s kitchen. He titled the post “My imperfect baby that’s survived three moves and my worst neglect, still going strong.” The comments were all people sharing their own lopsided, half-dead, long-lived plants, not a single “you should repot it” comment in sight. Next was a thread of propagation fails. A woman posted a photo of her flooded laundry room, a broken glass jar, and one sad little pothos cutting that survived her cat’s attack. Someone else shared a photo of their cactus that turned to complete mush after they forgot it existed while they were on vacation. Another said they overwatered their brand new fiddle leaf fig and it dropped every single leaf in three days, and they’re still waiting to see if it’ll grow back.
I’d been meaning to post my own pothos, the one I’ve had for a year that keeps growing one new leaf and dropping one yellow leaf every month, that I can’t for the life of me figure out what I’m doing wrong. I was just gonna take a blurry photo from my couch, type “why is this dying?” and hit post. But the rules said if you’re asking for care advice, you have to include a photo of your soil, tell people how much light it gets and how often you water. So I got up off the couch, turned on my phone flashlight, and leaned in to look. Turns out I’ve had a laundry basket full of clean folded sheets that I never put away leaning against the window right next to the pot, blocking 70% of the light. I didn’t even notice it had been there for two weeks. That’s the thing I never would’ve done if I’d just skipped the rules, right? I would’ve posted my blurry photo, gotten 10 different conflicting pieces of advice, and still not figured out the obvious thing right in front of me.
I also didn’t expect that the rules weren’t just arbitrary. Half of them had little one-sentence notes after, like “we added this rule after someone got harassed for sharing what they paid for their plant last year” or “we had a problem last swap with people scamming new members, hence the rule about pricing.” Rules aren’t just there to ruin your fun, I guess. They’re just the community writing down what they’ve already learned hurts people, so they don’t have to deal with it over and over. And the highlights? They weren’t highlighting the best, they were highlighting the posts that fit what the group actually wants to be. That’s way different than what I’ve seen anywhere else, where highlights are just for the people who post the prettiest content and get the most comments.
I still haven’t posted my pothos, honestly. I moved the laundry basket, I cut off the yellow leaf, I’ve been watering it a little less, and it’s got a new little leaf bud popping out already, so that’s nice. I still think 9 times out of 10, reading the rules is a boring waste of time, and community highlights are just a popularity contest. I still skip the rules for most groups I join. I still haven’t figured out what I did wrong in that sourdough group.
But this one time, it was different. It wasn’t life changing, I didn’t find my people or whatever cheesy thing people write about in these posts. It was just… nice. Nice to see a group that actually says what they mean, instead of making you figure it out after you accidentally step on someone’s toes. I guess that’s more than you can ask for most of the time, right? I’ll let you know if the pothos makes it.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » I Joined a New Plant Group Last Week and Finally Read All The Rules