I Asked Myself Which System I’d Pick. I Didn’t Expect the Answer to Be This Messy.
Last Tuesday I stood in my kitchen wiping coffee off the floor with a paper towel that disintegrated halfway, while my boyfriend leaned against the fridge scrolling through his Google Calendar. The dog had chewed through my headphone charger an hour earlier, I was already late to a work check-in, and we were supposed to figure out who was picking up what for the weekend trip we’re taking next week.
His system is perfect, on paper. Color-coded blocks for every task, even “buy oat milk” gets a 10-minute slot on Wednesday afternoons. Every bill has three reminders: one a week out, one three days out, one the night before. Chores get rotated on a fixed schedule, so we never end up with moldy coffee mugs growing in the sink for two weeks. Okay, almost never.
My system is… less organized. I have a single note in my phone called “stuff don’t forget” that I add to when I remember something, and I never sort it, never delete old stuff, so if I scroll up I can see “return sweater to H&M” from October 2022. I leave sticky notes on the microwave, but half of them fall off behind the toaster and I don’t find them until we move the fridge six months later, when I discover a note that says “buy more toothpaste” that I’ve already bought three replacements for. I do chores when the mess bothers me enough to make me stop scrolling, which could be tomorrow or could be next Friday.
We had the big fight about this a month back, when my whole family was coming over for dinner. His system had us cleaning the living room at 3pm, picking up charcuterie supplies at 4, starting the pasta at 5. I woke up that morning, it was 70 degrees and sunny, the first nice day we’d had after three weeks of rain, and I dragged him and the dog to the park because I’d been cooped up inside and I wanted to get a soda from the corner bodega and sit on a bench. He checked his watch every two minutes the whole time, said we were blowing the whole schedule. We got back an hour late, he got snappy, I got mad because it was just my parents and my little brother, not the queen of England. In the rush I knocked over the whole jar of dill pickles I’d pulled out for the board, glass went everywhere, we had to run back to the grocery store in the rain, and we ended up eating frozen pepperoni pizza with everyone anyway, which was way more fun than the fancy dinner we’d planned.
After that I started thinking: if I had to pick one system forever, which would it be? All my life I’ve hated being boxed in by schedules, so I figured I’d pick my messy, go-with-the-flow thing. I’ve tried all those fancy productivity systems everyone raves about, the ones that promise if you just sort all your tasks into the right folders you’ll have your whole life together. I did that whole getting things done thing for three months once, bought fancy notebooks, labeled everything, and then I took a week off for vacation and forgot to empty my inbox once, and the whole thing just collapsed. I never went back. I tried the “no system at all” thing too, the whole “live in the moment don’t plan anything” thing, and that ended with me missing three dentist appointments and forgetting my best friend’s birthday. She still brings it up when we get drunk, which is fair.
But the thing is, his system bailed me out last month, when I was so wrapped up in that big work project I forgot I’d needed a new tire for my car for two weeks. He’d written it into his calendar when he got his own oil changed, set a reminder, dropped my car off at the shop while I was in meetings, and I didn’t have to think about it once. I would have remembered the day before I was supposed to leave for our road trip, panicking at 10pm when all the shops are closed. Two days after that, I bailed him out. He got a call from his sister, she’d just broken up with her long-term boyfriend, and he looked at his calendar and said he had an open call slot next Saturday at 1pm. I told him to close the laptop, grab his keys, go get her favorite ice cream and go sit with her right now. He did, and she told me later that it was the only thing that made her feel better that day.
We still fight about it, honestly. Last Sunday his system said laundry gets done and put away by 4pm. I left my pile of clean sweaters on the couch for three days because it didn’t bother me, and I was reading a good book and didn’t feel like stopping. He got huffy, I got mad that he cared more about a schedule than me being relaxed, we didn’t talk for an hour, then we ordered tacos and made up on the couch, sweaters still on the couch.
I saw a poll on a social media feed the other day: “Which productivity system do you swear by?” All the options were fancy named things, none of them said “half my partner’s calendar, half sticky notes that fall behind the toaster”. I voted for other, obviously. I thought I’d have a clear answer by now, that I’d pick one or the other. But the truth is, I don’t want to pick. Some days I need the schedule, when I have five meetings and a doctor’s appointment and a grocery run, and writing it all down in blocks keeps me from having a panic attack in the parking lot. Some days I want to throw the whole schedule out, sit on the fire escape and read until the sun goes down even though I was supposed to clean the bathroom.
I still forget things. I still miss calls. I still have a crumpled note from two months ago that says “return library book” taped to my laptop, and the book is still sitting by the door. But I also wrote “call grandma” on that same note, and I called her last Sunday out of the blue when I saw it, and we talked for an hour and a half about her garden and the neighbor’s cat that keeps stealing her tomatoes. That never would have happened if it was scheduled for 2pm on the third Sunday of the month. I would have been checking the clock the whole time, stressed about getting to the next thing.
No one asks what happens when your system is just cobbled together from bits of what works that day. I don’t have a neat answer to give. I still haven’t picked one, and I don’t think I need to. Maybe next year I’ll be a fully scheduled calendar person, maybe I’ll throw my phone in a drawer and just keep everything in a notebook. That’s okay. I’m not in a rush to have it all figured out. (Word count: 1128)
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » I Asked Myself Which System I’d Pick