How We’re Building a Natural Toy Collection (Without Buying Everything at Once)
Last week, I found myself standing in the toy aisle of our local big-box store, holding a plastic dinosaur that lit up and roared. My four-year-old had asked for it, and for a second I almost said yes. Then I remembered the similar dinosaur we bought last year—the one that chirped for a week, lost its tail by Tuesday, and now lives in a drawer with three missing batteries. I put it back and told my son, “Let’s see what we can make instead when we get home.”
That evening, we took out our basket of wooden animals. My son spent twenty minutes lining them up by height, then by color, then by “who’s the mama and who’s the baby.” No batteries, no lights, no sound effects. Just the weight of the wood in his hands and the quiet clack as he set each one down.
I don’t remember exactly when we started shifting our toy collection. It wasn’t a single decision. It was more like a slow realization that the plastic things didn’t last, both physically and in terms of my kids’ interest. They’d play with a toy for a day, then toss it aside. But the wooden blocks, the silk scarves, the basket of pinecones—those got used over and over, in different ways each week.
So we began building a collection. Not a huge one. Not an expensive one. Just a deliberate set of toys made from natural materials, added over birthdays and holidays, with the understanding that less is more when each piece has real depth.
The first thing we bought was a set of plain wooden blocks. Nothing fancy—just a cylinder, a few rectangles, a triangle or two. Our daughter was two then, and she used them as teethers. Our son stacked them into towers and knocked them down. Now they become bridges, garages, rocket ships, and, occasionally, “dangerous mountains” that need to be rescued by the wooden animals. The blocks have dents and chew marks, but they’re still solid. I expect they’ll still be solid when our youngest is in kindergarten.
From there, we added a Grimm’s rainbow. I know it’s almost a cliché in natural toy circles, but the thing earns its reputation. My kids use the arches as tunnels for cars, fences for sheep, rings for a circus, or just as something to sort and stack by size. It’s not a toy with a single purpose. That’s the key. When a toy doesn’t do anything on its own, the child has to bring the imagination to it. And that’s exactly what we want.
We also collected a few simple things that cost almost nothing. A basket of pinecones, for example. A pile of smooth river stones from a beach trip. A set of wooden rings in various sizes that we found at a craft store. These aren’t marketed as toys, but they function as such. My kids sort them, count them, hide them under silk scarves, pretend the stones are eggs or cookies. The oldest one often spreads everything out on the floor and narrates an elaborate story that I can’t follow but am glad to hear.
Silk scarves were a game-changer, too. We have about six of them in different colors. They’ve been capes, roofs, rivers, and baby blankets. Sometimes they’re just draped over a chair and become a waterfall. I remember one rainy afternoon when my daughter spent an hour wrapping a scarf around her shoulders and “flying” through the living room, making up a kingdom in her head. No soundtrack, no flashing lights, no pre-programmed phrases. Just her and a piece of silk.
The hard part was letting go of the idea that toys need to look like toys. We had relatives who bought us brightly colored plastic sets with buttons and levers. Some of those were appreciated, and some of them got donated quickly. It felt awkward at first to say, “We’re trying to focus on open-ended stuff.” But over time, I got better at asking for specific things. “He really loves the wooden animal set,” I’d tell a grandparent. Or, “She keeps asking for more stacking rings.” It helped that we had a list going in our phone—not a strict list, but a few ideas so that when someone asked, we had an answer ready.
One thing that surprised me was how much a natural toy collection changes the vibe of a room. With fewer plastic colors shouting from every shelf, the play space feels calmer. The toys blend into the house instead of fighting for attention. I notice my kids are more focused when there are only a few things out at a time, rather than a mountain of options. We rotate things: the wooden blocks stay out always, but the animals and stones go into a cloth bag that gets swapped with the rainbow or the rings every few weeks. Rotation made a huge difference—it’s like the toys become new again when they come back.
That doesn’t mean we’ve gone full minimalist. We still have some plastic Duplo bricks, and my son has a beloved toy car from his uncle that he refuses to part with. That’s fine. The goal isn’t to enforce some strict material purity. It’s to have a core set of things that will last, that feel good in the hand, and that can grow with my kids instead of being outgrown in a few months.
One practical tip I picked up from a friend who’s a Montessori teacher: offer one new natural toy at a time, not five. When we first got the rainbow, I tried to give it to my daughter while also showing her the wooden animals and the rings. She got overwhelmed and put everything back in the basket. But when I just left the rainbow on the floor one morning, she approached it on her own, turned the arches over, and started stacking them. Now it’s one of her favorites.
Another thing we did was set a “one in, one out” rule for the toy cabinet. If we bring in something new, we pick something to pass on or store away. That’s helped us avoid the buildup of stuff we don’t actually use. It also forces me to be more thoughtful about what makes it into the house in the first place. Is this something that will still be interesting in a year? Does it invite play or does it just make noise? If it’s the kind of toy that lights up and talks, we usually skip it.
Building this collection has been slower than I expected, and that’s okay. We don’t have a huge playroom full of beautiful wooden toys. We have a few baskets, a shelf for the rainbow, and a drawer of silk scarves. But what we have gets used daily. The blocks are wearing into a nice, smooth patina. The rainbow has a few small scratches from being dumped onto the floor. The stones have been washed more times than I can count.
Sometimes I still doubt whether we’re doing it right. My kids aren’t learning how to press buttons or follow pre-programmed prompts. They’re not building digital literacy, whatever that means at age four. But they are learning to make their own stories. They’re learning that a block can be a phone or a sandwich or a boat, depending on what the imagination needs. That feels like a richer kind of play, even if it’s quieter than the plastic dinosaur would have been.
We’re not done adding to the collection. There’s a wooden train set I want to find secondhand, and a set of nesting bowls that I think my daughter would love. But we’re in no hurry. The toys we have now are still doing the job, and there’s something comforting about knowing that the next addition will be something chosen, not just grabbed off a shelf. I’m still not sure what the next one will be, but I know it’ll be made of wood or wool or stone. And it’ll wait for my kids to tell it what it is.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How We’re Building a Natural Toy Collection (Without Buying Everything at Once)