How We Tried a New Approach to Help Kids Use Tablets Healthily (And What’s Working For Us)
The sock I was folding slipped out of my hand and landed in a half-eaten bowl of Goldfish crackers when the yell went up. “It’s your fault I lost my turn!” Jake, 7, had his tablet pressed against his chest, 9-year-old Lila leaning over him yelling that he’d taken too long already. It was 3:15 on a Sunday, their daily 30 minutes of screen time had run out 10 minutes earlier, and we were already 10 minutes into our daily argument about why they couldn’t have just five more minutes. The sidewalk out front was still shiny from the morning rain, I’d promised we’d go jump in puddles, and all I wanted to do was sit down and not talk for ten minutes.
For as long as they’ve been old enough to swipe, we’ve done the standard screen time routine: 30 minutes a day, no tablets in bedrooms, no screens an hour before dinner. But almost every day ended the same way: nagging, begging, at least one kid walking away huffing. I kept seeing all the advice about limiting screen time, making sure it’s high quality, but nothing ever changed the daily fight. I’m a part-time para at the local elementary school, so I’m in a Facebook group for local parents and teachers, and that night after the kids were in bed, I saw a first grade teacher talking about how she does project-based tablet time with her own kids. Instead of splitting minutes into daily chunks, they pool all their weekly screen time to make something, instead of just playing or scrolling. I was so tired of the fight I figured I’d try it, what’s the worst that could happen?
I brought it up over breakfast the next Saturday. I told them they’d still get the same total amount of time they usually get—three and a half hours a week, same as 30 minutes a day—but it all got pooled into one big block they could use whenever they wanted, as long as they were making something instead of just playing games or watching videos. I told them “making something” could be anything: a stop motion video of your toys, a birthday meme for grandma, a custom drawing for the fridge, even a top 5 list of your favorite Lego sets to send to your cousin. Lila immediately perked up, she’d been seeing stop motion videos on YouTube for months and kept saying she wanted to make her own. Jake just blinked and said “can I make a video explaining why Adopt Me is better than Brookhaven to show Milo?” I said sure, that counts. The only rule was they had to write or draw their plan on a post-it before they got the tablet, just so they knew what they were working toward before they started.
That first week, Lila spent an hour and a half drawing a quick storyboard on scrap paper first, then another hour and 15 minutes moving her fairy garden figures a centimeter at a time for her stop motion. That used up almost half her weekly time right there, but she didn’t care. When she finished, she dragged both Jake and me over to the couch to watch it three times in a row, grinning the whole time. Jake spent the whole first Saturday afternoon working on his video, writing down his five points, practicing his lines, recording it three times until he got it right. That used up all his three and a half hours for the week. When he was done, he sent it to Milo, put the tablet away, and went outside to dig in the dirt. No begging, no argument. I just stood there by the kitchen sink surprised, because that never would have happened before.
I started thinking about why this worked, when all the other standard rules didn’t. The problem with daily 30 minute chunks of passive consumption is that games and short videos are designed to keep you hooked. One more level, one more clip, right when the timer goes off, you’re right in the middle of something good, so of course kids throw a fit. When they’re creating, though, there’s a natural end. You finish the video, you’re done, you’re the one who gets to stop, not me. The timer isn’t cutting you off in the middle of the fun, you already got to the end of what you wanted to do.
The small adjustments we made that anyone can try are pretty simple. First, we don’t count homework or video calls with extended family against their project time, so there’s no pushback about tablets being a punishment or a restricted privilege that gets taken away for school needs. Second, they can save up unused minutes from week to week if they want to do a bigger project. Last month Lila saved two weeks of minutes to make a 15 minute birthday video for her grandma that included clips of all the grandkids, and that worked out fine. Third, if they use all their time up early in the week, that’s their call, no do-overs. Jake did that a couple weeks ago, used all his time on Monday, moped for an hour on Wednesday when his friend was playing Roblox after school, but then he dug out his old wooden train set that he hasn’t touched in a year and played for two hours.
It’s not perfect, of course. Some weeks they can’t think of anything they want to make, so I let them use an hour just to play with their friends, no project, that’s fine. We had a sick day last month where they both watched animated movies on the tablet all day, and no one made anything, that’s just how sick days go. It’s not a hard and fast rule that we never break.
It’s been two months now, and we haven’t had a daily fight about getting off tablets since we started. I still catch them sneaking the tablet to watch short clips when I’m on a work call sometimes, and I still have to remind them to put it away for dinner sometimes. I don’t know if this is the right approach for every family, and I don’t know if it’ll still work in a year when they get older and want different things. But right now, it’s way better than the constant nagging and hurt feelings we used to have. And honestly, it’s kind of nice getting to see what they come up with. Lila’s fairy video is still saved in my camera roll, and I pull it up sometimes when I’m waiting in the pickup line at school. Tablets don’t have to be just something to stress about, I guess. Sometimes just switching up how you do them makes all the difference.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How We Tried a New Approach to Help Kids Use Tablets Healthily (And What’s Working For Us)