How To Support A Hardworking Student At Risk Of Losing College Due To Financial Issues
The bell for after-school detention had rung ten minutes earlier, and I was stacking attendance slips when Mia knocked on my office door, holding her crumpled in-state college acceptance letter in one hand. She’d stopped by my desk every other week for the last four years to ask for transcript copies or letters of rec, so I was used to her hovering in the doorway instead of coming in. This time, she sat down in the hard plastic chair across from my desk, folded the acceptance letter into a tiny square, and said she wouldn’t be going.
She’d worked 25 hours a week at the downtown Kroger since sophomore year, had a 3.8 GPA, and got into the elementary education program she’d wanted since she was 12. But after her mom, a nurse aide at the nursing home three towns over, slipped on a wet floor and tore her rotator cuff, she couldn’t pick up the extra weekend shifts that were supposed to cover Mia’s tuition gap. The $5,200 gap between her grants, loans, and savings wasn’t going to close. She’d already decided to just keep working full time and put college off forever.
I’ve been a high school guidance counselor for 12 years, and this is the story I see more often than people think. It’s never the kid who doesn’t work hard or doesn’t get in. It’s the kid who does everything right, but a few thousand dollar gap is enough to derail the whole thing. Most people assume if you get accepted, you’ll get enough aid to attend, but that’s not how the system works. Mia didn’t want to ask anyone for help. She said she didn’t want handouts, she’d worked for everything so far. I didn’t say “it’s okay, don’t worry” – I know kids like Mia hate that. It feels dismissive, like all their hard work doesn’t matter. I just pulled my calendar up and said “I’ve got 45 minutes free after school tomorrow. Bring your aid offer, your mom’s pay stubs from the last three months, and the doctor’s note for her injury. We’re going to do this step by step, you don’t have to ask anyone for anything by yourself.”
The first thing we did was a special circumstances appeal to the college. Most parents and teachers don’t know that the initial financial aid offer is not final. If your family’s income changes after you submit the FAFSA – a job loss, a medical injury, an unexpected bill – you can ask the college to re-evaluate your offer. That’s the exact phrase to remember if you ever need to do this: ask for a “special circumstances review.” You don’t need fancy language, just proof of the change in income. We put together a short letter, attached all the paperwork, and sent it off. Two weeks later, the college added $2,800 in institutional grant money that wasn’t in the original offer. That cut the gap almost in half right away.
Next, we targeted small, local scholarships instead of the big national awards that tens of thousands of students apply to. Our local PTA gives a $1,000 scholarship to seniors who work 20+ hours a week while in school – most years, they only get three or four applicants, because everyone is too busy chasing the $10,000 national awards. The downtown business association has another $1,500 for local kids going into education. Mia already had a personal statement written for her college apps, so we just trimmed it to fit the requirements, and I dropped the applications off at the chamber of commerce myself. She got both. That covered the rest of the gap for her first year.
The last piece was adjusting her work schedule so she wouldn’t burn out once classes started. She’d originally planned to keep working 25 hours a week at Kroger, which would have made keeping up with education student teaching almost impossible. I told her to ask the college’s work study office if she could get a higher allocation than her initial offer, since she had to cut back on off-campus hours. They gave her a 10-hour a week position in the campus education library, which pays $12 an hour and is flexible around her class schedule. She now only works 8 hours at Kroger on weekends, enough to cover books and gas, without eating all her study time.
The biggest mistake I see people make with these kids is waiting for them to ask for help. Hardworking kids who’ve always carried their own weight won’t ask. They see asking as admitting they failed, that all their work wasn’t enough. Saying “let me know if you need anything” is useless – they’ll never let you know. Instead, name the specific thing you can do, and set a time to do it. Remove the burden from them. Another mistake is jumping straight to crowdfunding. It’s well-meaning, but putting a kid’s financial business out in front of the whole town often just adds to their shame. Start with the college first, then local scholarships, before you consider public fundraising. It’s more private, and it teaches the kid how to advocate for themselves down the line, when they’ll likely need to do it again.
Mia’s moving into the dorms two weeks from now. We still don’t have the next three years fully sorted out. Her mom’s physical therapy is going well, but she still can’t lift more than 10 pounds, so extra shifts are still out of the question for at least another year. Mia’s planning to take two gen ed classes over the summer at our local community college next year, which costs a third of what the state college charges, to cut down on the number of credits she has to pay for there. She’s already talked to the financial aid office about doing another special circumstances review next spring, if her mom’s income is still lower than expected. It’s not a perfect fix, and there’s still a lot that could go wrong. But right now, she’s picking out bed sheets for her dorm, and she’s registered for her first semester of classes. That’s more than she had a month and a half ago. That’s enough for right now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How To Support A Hardworking Student At Risk Of Losing College Due To Financial Issues