How to respond when your kid wants to ask an older crush out: practical parenting advice
Last night, my 8th grader Lila leaned against the kitchen counter twisting the cap off a blue Gatorade, her half-finished algebra worksheet tucked under one arm, and wouldn’t meet my eye. I was wiping down the stove after dinner, waited her out. After three full minutes of silence, she blurted, “Mom, I need advice. I want to ask Jace out. He’s two grades above me.”
I almost dropped the sponge. My first gut reaction was to jump in with all the automatic parent lines: Isn’t he too old? What if he rejects you? You’re too young to date anyway. But I caught myself. Fifteen years ago when I was a sophomore, I had a crush on a senior who worked at the local record store, and my mom laughed when I told her, said it was just a silly schoolgirl crush, and I never told her anything even remotely personal about my love life after that. I’ve also been a middle school counselor long enough to know that crushes aren’t just silly fluff. They’re one of the first ways kids practice being vulnerable with someone outside their family.
I pulled a wooden stool out from under the counter, sat down so we were eye level instead of me looming over her, and asked the first question I always ask in these situations: “What do you like about him?” That’s not just small talk. So many parents skip this step and jump straight to rules or warnings, but this tells you right away if there’s anything to worry about. Lila’s cheeks went pink, and she started talking: how she met him when she helped decorate for the fall dance back in September, how he carried three of her heavy poster boards to the gym when she dropped them, how he remembered her name when she ran into him at the cross country concession stand two weeks later, how he posts photos of his rescue hamster on Instagram and it’s the cutest thing she’s ever seen. No red flags, no stories of him pushing her to do something she didn’t want, just a nice older kid who was polite to her. That’s all it was.
We got down to the actual advice, step by step, nothing fancy. First, I asked her what she actually wanted out of asking him out. She said she didn’t want a big relationship or anything, just wanted to get ice cream after school one day and see if they had fun together. That made sense. So we walked through the options for how to ask. She wanted to send him an Instagram DM, since she sees him on the app all the time and sees him at school too rarely to catch him alone. I didn’t lecture her about talking to people online, or tell her she had to ask in person to be “brave.” I just helped her craft a line that didn’t put too much pressure on either of them. She originally wrote “Do you want to go out with me?” and we changed it to something specific: “I thought it was so cool when you talked about growing succulents at the garden sale last month, would you want to get ice cream after school this Friday?” Specific is better, because it references a shared memory, it’s not out of the blue, and it keeps the ask low-stakes.
Then, we talked about the thing no one likes to plan for: rejection. I didn’t say “don’t worry, it’ll be okay” because that’s useless when you’re 13 and your whole world feels like it’s hanging on a DM. I asked her what she thought she’d feel if he said no. She said she’d be embarrassed, that all her friends would tease her, that she’d want to hide. So we made a plan. If he says no, she just replies “No worries, have a good week” and turns her phone off, and comes straight home. We’ll order her favorite mint chocolate chip ice cream, put on that terrible 2000s vampire show she loves, and not talk about it unless she wants to. That’s concrete. She knows exactly what happens next, so the fear of the unknown doesn’t feel as big.
I also addressed the two grades thing head on, because that’s what most parents panic about. It’s normal to see a 10th grader and an 8th grader and jump to worst case scenarios, but in my experience, 9 times out of 10, this isn’t a dangerous situation, it’s just a kid liking someone who has traits they’re drawn to. Jace isn’t some manipulative upperclassman, he’s just a kid who’s had two more years of middle school and is a little taller, a little cooler to a younger kid. The only question that matters here is whether your kid feels safe with that person. If the answer is no, you step in. If the answer is yes, this is just good practice for all the vulnerable, scary asks they’ll have to make later in life.
Today is Tuesday. Lila’s been tapping away at her math homework all afternoon, and every 10 minutes she glances at her locked phone on the desk. She’s planning to send the DM tomorrow after school, when Jace usually posts his weekly run photos and is active on Instagram. I haven’t brought it up once. I just left a bag of her favorite sour gummy bears on her desk when I brought her a glass of water an hour ago.
Whatever happens tomorrow, it’s not going to break her. If he says yes, we’ll go over basic ground rules: check in every hour, be home by 6, meet in the public ice cream shop downtown where all the kids hang out, no going anywhere private. If he says no, we’ll stick to the vampire show and ice cream plan. Either way, she’s learning something she can’t get from a textbook: how to ask for what she wants, how to handle disappointment, how to trust that her parent will have her back no matter what. There’s no perfect outcome here, but that’s okay. This is how growing up works.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How to respond when your kid wants to ask an older crush out: practical parenting advice