How to Help Your Teen Choose Between Psychology, Linguistics, Law, or Physical Therapy
It was 10:17 pm on a Tuesday, and I was folding soccer socks at the kitchen table while my 17-year-old daughter Lila prodded a cold pepperoni pizza slice and stared at her laptop. The dryer hummed in the next room, and our neighbor’s golden retriever barked at a raccoon in the backyard, when Lila pushed her screen back hard enough to make her water bottle slosh. “Mom,” she said, “should I study psychology, linguistics, law, or physical therapy?”
All four options made sense, which is why the question was so hard. Lila is the kid who notices when the new kid sits alone at lunch, who spent all last summer tutoring three 10-year-old ESL students after volunteering at elementary recess, who argued with her uncle for two hours at Thanksgiving about whether our state should expand Medicaid, and who tore an ankle ligament during cross country season last year and left every PT appointment rambling about how cool it was that her therapist got her running again. Every option fit her strengths and interests, so it wasn’t that she had no clue what she liked. It was that she had too many good clues.
I almost blurted out the first thing that popped into my head: that law pays well, that PT always has openings, that any of them would be fine. But then I thought of my friend Sarah’s son, who picked pre-law three years ago because Sarah and her husband insisted it was a safe, stable choice. He dropped out mid-sophomore year, hating every class, and now works at a coffee shop while figuring out his next step, stressed out about thousands in wasted tuition. So I shut my mouth, poured us both hot cocoa, and pulled out a scrap of notebook paper from the junk drawer.
I didn’t give her advice. I just asked her to write down one small, regular thing she does for each major that makes time fly by, that doesn’t feel like work. For psychology, she wrote: “Listen to my friends vent after bad days, notice when people are acting off before they say anything.” For linguistics: “Figure out why my ESL kids mix up pronouns and make up silly tricks to help them remember.” For law: “Win debates at club meetings about unfair dress code rules.” For physical therapy: “Helped my teammate stretch after her knee injury and watched her get back to playing in two weeks.” That exercise alone cut through a lot of the noise about what she “should” pick, because suddenly it wasn’t about job titles or prestige—it was about what she actually does every day that feels worth it.
Next, I suggested we not decide that week. Instead, we’d go watch someone do each job for half a day. I texted my cousin who’s a PT at the local outpatient clinic, my neighbor who teaches linguistics at the state college, my old high school friend who does family law downtown, and our school counselor who got a master’s in psychology before moving into guidance. All of them said yes, no questions asked. Most people are happy to let a curious kid hang out, turns out—they don’t get asked that often, and many enjoy talking about their work.
What Lila learned surprised both of us. After shadowing the attorney for a morning, she said she cared about the work the attorney did for parents fighting for custody, but she didn’t like that three hours of the morning was spent filing paperwork and negotiating over small bills that didn’t seem to matter to the actual people involved. She crossed law off her list for now. After sitting in on an introductory linguistics class and helping grade beginner quizzes, she said talking about how people learn language felt like solving fun puzzles, not work. After shadowing PT on a Saturday, she liked connecting with patients and helping them feel better, but was caught off guard by how much of the day was updating notes and arguing with insurance companies over coverage. She still liked it, though. For psychology, after talking through the path with our school counselor, she realized she’d need at least six more years of school after college to do the kind of work she was interested in, and she doesn’t want that many more years of school right now. So that went off the list too.
I’ve talked to enough other parents to know we often treat picking a college major like picking a forever identity, like one wrong choice will ruin your whole life. But that’s not how it works anymore. Most people I know change careers at least twice, and all of these majors overlap more than people think. A linguistics major can go to PT school later if she changes her mind. A PT can get a master’s in linguistics to work in speech therapy if they want. None of these choices lock you in forever.
What I tell other parents who ask me about this kind of choice is simple: don’t lead with salary stats or what sounds impressive to other people. Start with what your kid actually enjoys doing day to day, not the end career title. Don’t stress if all their options are good—that’s a good problem to have. Shadowing is way more useful than any college brochure, and it’s almost always easy to arrange. And finally, apply to schools that let you wait until sophomore year to declare a major. You don’t have to check that box before you graduate high school.
Right now, Lila’s still stuck between PT and linguistics. She signed up to volunteer at the PT clinic one afternoon a week starting next month, and she’s going to take an intro linguistics class at the local community college this spring to test it out. She’s only applying to schools that let her come in undecided. Last night, she was sitting at the same kitchen table, eating mint chocolate chip ice cream, scrolling through course catalogs, and said she’s still scared she’ll pick the wrong one. I told her I majored in English originally, switched to education in my sophomore year, and now I write this blog and don’t teach full time anymore, and none of that schooling was wasted. It all taught me things I use now. She rolled her eyes, but she smiled, and went back to scrolling. We’ll see what she picks. No rush.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How to Help Your Teen Choose Between Psychology, Linguistics, Law, or Physical Therapy