How to Help Your Kid Get Ahead at a Competitive School: Real Tips From a Parent Who’s Been There
The gym at Westside Magnet still smells like old floor wax and the day-old coffee the PTA brews for fall parent-teacher conferences. I was leaning against a cinder block wall in October two years ago, twisting the cap of my disposable water bottle off and on, waiting to talk to Lila’s 10th grade biology teacher. Lila had been top of her class at our old middle school, the kid who turned in extra credit just because it was there. That first semester at Westside, she’d started coming home with B minuses, eating dinner standing over the sink, and staying up till 11:30 re-writing lab reports that other kids turned in an hour after class.
When Mrs. Henderson called us over, she didn’t beat around the bush. “She’s trying to outwork every kid in this room,” she said, tapping Lila’s grade book on her laptop. “She thinks getting ahead means being first at everything. But she’s burning out before midterms.” That hit me, because we’d moved across the county specifically to get Lila into Westside. All the parent forums said it was the best competitive public school in the area, that it got kids into top colleges, that the challenge was good for them. No one told me the challenge would look like my 15 year old crying into her cereal because she got one question wrong on a pop quiz.
Over the next year and a half, we tried a bunch of small things, not the big “hire a tutor for every class” or “force a rigid study schedule” stuff that everyone online suggests. Most of it didn’t cost anything, and it didn’t require us to rearrange our whole lives.
The first thing we did was sit down with each of Lila’s teachers during the first week of the semester and ask one question: what assignment types count for the largest share of the final grade? A lot of kids at competitive schools jump into every assignment like it’s make or break. Lila was spending three hours a week on daily biology homework that only counted for 10% of her grade, while her unit tests, which counted for 60%, were getting half that study time. We made her keep a tiny index card in the front of each notebook that just had the breakdown written down: math: tests 70%, homework 15%, participation 15. English: essays 50%, quizzes 20%, homework 10. It sounds tiny, but it stopped her from pouring time into low-stakes work just to feel like she was keeping up.
Next, we stopped talking about other kids’ grades at home. Before, Lila would come home every day and vent about how the girl next to her in chem got a 100 and posted her score on Snapchat, or how the top rank kid had already finished all his AP classes junior year. It would send her into a spiral for hours. We made a simple rule: if you bring up someone else’s grade, you have to follow it with something you did that day that you liked. If you don’t want to do that, you can’t talk about it. At first she thought it was stupid, but after a week she caught herself starting to complain, rolled her eyes, and started talking about how she messed around in art club that day and made a lumpy ceramic mug that she still thought was cool. It didn’t eliminate the comparison entirely, but it cut down on the hours she spent feeling bad about where she stood.
Another small shift that made a big difference was scheduling 20 minutes of unplanned time right after school before homework starts. Lila used to walk in the door, flop on the couch, scroll Instagram, and lose an hour and a half before she felt guilty enough to start working. Now, she sets a timer when she walks in: 20 minutes, do whatever you want. Eat a cookie, walk the dog, text your friends, scroll. When the timer goes off, she plugs her phone into the charger by the front door, and doesn’t touch it again until homework is done. It cuts down on the guilt and the endless scrolling, and it gives her a real break before she dives back in. We also worked with her to block 15 minutes of work time in one of her free periods every other day, to knock out small assignments that would have taken an hour of tired brain work after dinner. That alone cut 3 to 4 hours of unnecessary school time out of her week.
I used to think getting ahead at a competitive school meant being the smartest, or the hardest working, or the kid with the longest resume. Now I see it’s more about learning to pick your battles, something most adults still struggle with. When every kid around you is gunning for the same top spots, it’s easy to think every single assignment, every single test, every extracurricular has to be perfect. But that kind of effort is impossible to sustain for four years.
Lila’s a junior now. She still has bad weeks. Last month she spent three nights working on an extra credit history project that only counted for 3% of her grade, and she was exhausted and grumpy for the whole weekend. But this month, she caught herself doing the same thing for physics, and she cut her work short an hour early so she could go see a movie with her friends. Her GPA isn’t as high as it would have been if we’d stayed at our old zoned school, but she sleeps seven hours a night most nights, she shows up to art club every week, and she’s applied for a summer graphic design program that she’s been talking about for a year.
We still don’t know if she’ll end up at the top university she had her eye on when we moved here. But she’s learning how to get done what matters, and still leave room for the things that make her happy. That feels like getting further ahead than any straight A report card ever could.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How to Help Your Kid Get Ahead at a Competitive School: Real Tips From a Parent Who’s Been There