How to Help Your Child When They Are Hated by Their Classmates: Practical Parenting Tips
I was leaning against my car by the elementary school bike rack last October, scrolling through a grocery list on my phone, when I saw my 10-year-old daughter Mia trundling toward me. Her neon pink backpack was slipping off one shoulder, and she was twisting the blue friendship bracelet she’d spent three nights making for her best friend Lila between her fingers. By the time she reached me, the clasp was broken, the threads frayed. She didn’t cry until we pulled out of the parking lot, great heaving sobs that shook her whole body, and told me Lila and the two other girls they’d been friends with since first grade hated her now. They’d written “Mia sucks” on the stall in the girls’ bathroom, she said, and refused to save her a seat at lunch.
My first instinct was to slam on the brakes, turn around, and march straight to the principal’s office. I also wanted to text the group mom chat and call out the girls’ parents, and tell Mia she never had to go back to that class if she didn’t want to. I’ve been there, that rush of protective anger when your kid comes home hurt. But two years earlier, when a boy on the soccer team kept taking her ball, I’d pulled the coach aside mid-practice and it had only made the other kids tease her for having a “mommy that yells”. So I bit my tongue, and pulled into the parking lot of the hot chocolate shop down the street instead.
We got inside, she ordered extra marshmallows, stirred hers until it was all melted, and I didn’t push her to talk faster. When she finished telling me the whole story—she’d accidentally knocked over their group diorama for the fall fair, three weeks of work, and the clay sun Lila had made crumbled into dust—I didn’t say any of the stupid things that pop into your head first. I didn’t say “they’re just being silly” or “just ignore them” or “it’s not that big of a deal”. I just said, “That sounds so awful. I’d be broken too if my best friends turned on me for something that was an accident.”
A lot of chatter out there says you need to fix this problem right away, but what I’ve found is that most of the time, kids just need to feel heard before they can do anything else. If you jump in to fix it before they’ve gotten all the hurt out, they leave the conversation thinking their feelings don’t matter, not that you’re helping.
The next day, I emailed Mia’s teacher. I didn’t demand she punish the girls or call them out in front of the class. I just told her what was going on, and asked if she could keep an eye on group work over the next few weeks, make sure Mia wasn’t stuck working alone every time we have a group project. The teacher wrote back an hour later, said she’d noticed the group being snappy, that they were all stressed about the fair project and had been taking it out on Mia, and she’d make sure to mix up groups for the next assignment. It was quiet, low-drama support that didn’t draw more attention to the conflict, which was exactly what I wanted.
Mia came home a couple days later and said she wanted to make chocolate chip cookies for the whole group, to say sorry again for breaking the diorama. I didn’t tell her that was a bad idea, that it wouldn’t work, that she shouldn’t have to beg for their friendship. I just helped her measure the flour, and I said, “It’s okay to try this if it feels right to you. But if they’re still mean after, that’s not on you. You did everything you could.” She brought the cookies, Lila took one and said thank you, but still didn’t sit with her at lunch. Mia came home a little disappointed, but not crushed. She said she at least tried.
That’s the thing I’ve had to learn as a parent: letting your kid try their own solution, even if you think it won’t work, teaches them to trust their own judgment. If I’d told her not to bring the cookies, she’d always wonder if that would have fixed it. Now she knows, and she can move on.
After that, I started making small changes, instead of pushing for a big fix. I’d noticed that after school, Mia kept rereading the same graphic novel series about a girl detective, and the girl who sat next to her in art class posted about loving the same series on her mom’s Instagram. I texted the mom, asked if her daughter wanted to come over after school one Friday to bake cookies and watch the cartoon adaptation. It was low pressure, no big formal play date that feels awkward for everyone. The girls ate half the cookie dough raw, talked about the books for an hour, and now they sit together at lunch once or twice a week. I also signed Mia up for the after school rock climbing club that started after winter break—something that had nothing to do with her regular class, so she could meet kids that didn’t already have this idea of her as the girl who broke the diorama. People always say “just make new friends” like it’s that easy, when you’re 10 and you’ve sat at the same lunch table for three years. You can’t just flip a switch. But creating small, low-stakes opportunities is way easier than forcing it.
It’s been almost four months now, and it’s not all fixed. Some days Mia still comes home and says Lila and her group laughed when she messed up a line in the school play rehearsal. Some days she eats lunch in the library because she doesn’t want to sit with anyone. But more days than not, she comes home talking about the new girl from rock climbing, or the art friend she drew comic strips with during recess. We don’t talk about being excluded every day, either. I stopped asking “are the girls still mean to you” a while ago, because that just made her feel like that’s all I care about when she walks in the door. Now I just ask, “What’s the silliest thing that happened at school today” when we’re making dinner, and if she wants to talk about the hard stuff, she brings it up. If she doesn’t, we just talk about the silly stuff instead. I don’t know if she’ll ever be friends with Lila again, and I don’t know if this whole thing will blow over by the end of the school year. What I do know is that right now, this slow, small approach is working better than any big, dramatic fix I ever thought of doing.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How to Help Your Child When They Are Hated by Their Classmates: Practical Parenting Tips