How to help a quiet kid who won’t participate in class: Lessons from a Chinese primary school
It’s 9:15 a.m. on a Tuesday, third-grade math class at a public school on the outskirts of Suzhou, and we’re going around the room doing oral word problems. I’m the volunteer TA, walking between rows to check work, when I stop at the back desk. Xiao Ming is slouched in his chair, gray school hoodie pulled up over his hair even though the classroom heater is cranked too high, and his eraser has rubbed a thumb-sized hole through the page of his workbook. I say his name soft, and he freezes. His cheeks flush bright red, he stares at his desk, and doesn’t make a sound. A few kids in the row in front of him start snickering, and the main teacher waves me off. “Don’t bother,” she says, loud enough for most of the room to hear. “He never talks. Just move on.”
I’d been working at this school for two weeks by that point, and I’d already noticed Xiao Ming. He always finishes whatever work we hand out faster than any other kid, but he leaves more than half of it blank. He never hands in homework, and he spends most of recess leaning against the cinder block wall by the playground, watching the other kids play soccer instead of joining in. After that math class, I pulled the homeroom teacher aside during lunch break to ask about him. She told me his parents work at a car parts factory 400 kilometers away in Guangdong, and they only come home once a year for Spring Festival. He lives with his grandma, who cleans stairwells at the nearby apartment complex and can’t read more than a handful of Chinese characters. She can’t help with homework, can’t sign his report cards, can’t even read the notes teachers send home. Xiao Ming started falling behind in second grade, and by the start of third grade, he’d just stopped trying. Most of the staff had written him off as lazy, or slow, and no one pushed him much anymore.
A few days later, I waited by the school gate after dismissal to talk to his grandma. She was still in her gray cleaning uniform, broom propped over her shoulder, and she sighed when I asked about Xiao Ming. “He doesn’t talk at home either,” she said. “He does the dishes and takes out the trash like I ask, then he sits on the balcony and watches dinosaur videos on my old phone. I don’t know what he’s thinking. I can’t help him with his school stuff, I’m sorry.”
I didn’t have a big plan, and I don’t work full time as a teacher, so I started with the smallest thing I could think of. Every morning after self-study, I’d walk past his desk and leave one tiny, low-pressure thing. Sometimes it was an extra mandarin orange from the break room snack basket. Sometimes it was a dinosaur sticker I’d bought from the stationery shop down the street, after I noticed he drew tiny stegosauruses on the edges of all his worksheets. I didn’t stop to talk, didn’t ask for a thank you, just left it and kept walking. For the first three days, he didn’t react at all, just stuffed whatever I left into his desk drawer. On the fourth day, he looked up and nodded at me when I walked by. That was the first win.
After a week of that, I started stopping by his desk for two minutes during break, before the next class started. I didn’t lead with homework or grades. I asked about the dinosaurs he drew. Turns out he can name every species, rattle off their weights and time periods, and could tell me more about recent fossil digs in China than I ever learned in college. That’s when I started digging into the work he did turn in. I realized he wasn’t bad at math—every problem he bothered to do was correct. He just hated writing out all the steps the teacher required, because he’d missed so much early practice writing characters that his handwriting is slow and messy, and he’s embarrassed by it. He’d rather get a zero for a blank page than turn in something he thinks is messy and wrong.
I talked to the homeroom and math teacher about small changes, no big overhauls. First, we stopped calling on him in front of the whole class until he chooses to speak. Instead, he can write his answer on a small personal whiteboard and hold it up just for me to see, no one else has to look. Second, instead of sending him home with the same two pages of homework every other kid gets, he only has to do one problem a night. If he brings it back the next day, we go over it together in those two minute breaks. That’s it. No extra tutoring after school, no big intervention that makes him stand out as different from the other kids.
A lot of people talk about left-behind kids in China like they need huge donations or special programs to turn things around, and that’s true for some. But what I’ve seen with Xiao Ming is that most of the time, the biggest thing missing is just small, consistent respect that meets him where he is. Most adults either ignore him or treat him like a project, and that’s the last thing he wants. If you have a kid like this in your class or life, the first thing you can do is stop forcing them to perform before they’re ready. It doesn’t help to push them to speak up in front of everyone just to “build their confidence” — that just makes them more ashamed. Small, private interactions first build trust way faster. Adjusting expectations to something they can actually achieve keeps them from shutting down entirely.
It’s been almost three months now. Last week, in science class, the teacher was talking about prehistoric fossils, and I saw Xiao Ming’s hand creep halfway up off his desk. The teacher noticed, and called his name. He talked for almost two minutes about the new tyrannosaurus rex dig in Liaoning, and the whole class went quiet listening. When he sat down, the kids clapped, and his face went red, but I saw him smile a little into his hoodie. He still doesn’t join the soccer games at recess most days. His parents still aren’t coming home until Spring Festival, and he’s still years behind the rest of the class in writing. We haven’t “fixed” anything. But he says good morning to me now, he brings his one problem back every single day, and he raised his hand. That’s enough for right now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How to help a quiet kid who won’t participate in class: Lessons from a Chinese primary school