How to Deal With a Bad Teacher: Practical Tips From a Parent Who’s Been There
I was leaning against the bike rack last October, wiping pine sap off my jeans, when my fourth grader Lila trudged out of school, one strap of her backpack snapped, kicking at a crack in the sidewalk. She didn’t jump in to chatter about her best friend’s new unicorn sneakers like she usually did. She just said, “I hate Mrs. Henderson. She’s a bad teacher.”
She told me what happened: her stomach had started cramping halfway through math, which happens when her anxiety flairs up. She raised her hand to ask for the nurse, waited 10 minutes while Mrs. Henderson pulled a small group through fraction problems, and finally whispered to the girl next to her to pass along that she needed help. Mrs. Henderson blew up, called her out in front of the whole class, said she was just faking to get out of work and needed to stop being so dramatic. She made Lila sit out recess to think about her behavior.
That night, when we pulled out her homework, I saw her reading log marked with a big red C at the top. A note scrawled in the margin read: 3 out of 4 entries are graphic novels – these do not count toward required reading. Lila has read a full Wings of Fire arc that year, carries a graphic novel in the car every afternoon, and I was furious. I typed a half-scathing email to the principal at 9 pm, Lila laughing at a TikTok in the next room, and almost hit send before I remembered to text my sister, who teaches third grade at a different elementary, to rant. She wrote back 2 minutes later: Don’t do that. Wait.
Most of the time, she said, “bad teacher” isn’t some cartoon villain who hates kids. It’s a person who’s overloaded, burnt out, or just a bad fit for your kid. Jumping over their head to the principal just makes them defensive before you even get a chance to fix anything. I took her advice, and first I sat down with Lila and asked her to walk me through the whole incident again, step by step, instead of just taking the emotional high point. I didn’t ask “was she mean?” I asked “what did she say exactly? Where were you standing? Did she see you raise your hand the first time?” Turns out Lila had shifted her hand down after 5 minutes to hold her stomach, and Mrs. Henderson never saw it. She only caught the whisper. That didn’t excuse calling her out publicly, but it meant there was a gap to bridge, not just a bad person to punish.
Next, I emailed Mrs. Henderson directly, not the principal. I kept it short, focused only on Lila’s needs, no blame: “Hi Mrs. Henderson, this is Sarah, Lila Mendez’s mom. Lila came home yesterday upset about what happened during math when her stomach hurt, and I wanted to connect to make sure we’re on the same page about her needs. She has a history of anxiety that shows up as stomach aches, and she never fakes to get out of class. Would you have 10 minutes this week after school to chat?” She wrote back the next day, and we met by the front office. She was stiff at first, clearly expecting a fight, but when I told her I just wanted to make things easier for both of them, she softened. She admitted she has 28 kids in her class, 10 are a full grade level behind in math, and she’s up most nights dealing with her own teenage son’s ADHD meltdowns. She just snapped. That’s all.
We worked out two small concrete changes: Lila could sign her name on the clipboard by the door anytime she needed the nurse, no need to wait for permission if her stomach hurt. And one out of every three reading log entries could be a graphic novel, as long as she wrote two sentences about what happened. That was it. It didn’t turn Mrs. Henderson into Lila’s favorite teacher, but it cut out the daily stress.
Of course, this doesn’t work for every situation. My neighbor Mia had a first grade teacher a couple years ago who yelled at kids for wetting their pants, never returned emails, and refused to adjust for a kid with asthma. When she tried to meet, the teacher brushed her off. So Mia did something simple that worked: she wrote down every incident, with dates and what her kid told her, saved every unreturned email, and made an appointment with the principal. She didn’t come in yelling about firing the teacher. She just asked for one specific thing: a transfer to the other first grade class that had an open spot. She got it within a week.
If a transfer isn’t possible, which happens a lot when classes are full, you build a buffer at home. This isn’t vague “be supportive” talk. What it looks like for us is setting aside 10 minutes every afternoon right after school for Lila to complain as much as she wants. I don’t interrupt to fix it, I don’t tell her to be nicer, I just say “that sounds so unfair” and nod. I also say out loud, once a week usually, “How Mrs. Henderson treats you isn’t a reflection of how good you are. She’s having a hard time, and that’s not your job to fix.” That’s concrete, it’s something you can do even when you can’t change the teacher.
It’s been almost a year now, and Lila still doesn’t like Mrs. Henderson. She still comes home some Fridays saying Mrs. Henderson cut recess short because two kids ran in the hallway, and she thinks that’s unfair. It’s not the perfect classroom I would have picked for her if I got to choose. But it’s not the daily crisis it was that October. Most of the time, bad teaching isn’t some big dramatic evil that needs to be burned to the ground. It’s just a bad fit, or a burnt out person, or a system that’s stretched too thin. You don’t have to fix the whole system to make it bearable for your kid. You just have to get the full story, ask for what you need clearly, and catch your kid when it’s still hard. Some days that’s enough, and some days that’s all you can do.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How to Deal With a Bad Teacher: Practical Tips From a Parent Who’s Been There