How to Annotate Books for School: Simple, Low-Stress Tips for Students
The kitchen table was still scattered with Goldfish crumbs and my 10th grader Lila’s half-finished math worksheet when she dumped her backpack on the chair last Wednesday, pulled out her dog-eared rental copy of To Kill a Mockingbird, and groaned. The broken pink eraser on her favorite pencil snapped when she pressed it too hard to the page. “Ms. Henderson says we need three annotations per page,” she said. “I don’t even know what I’m supposed to write. If I write in the book I’ll get a fifty dollar fine at the end of the semester, and if I underline nothing I fail. This is stupid.”
As a former high school English teacher who now helps out at our local homeschool co-op, I’ve heard this complaint more times than I can count. Kids are told to annotate, but no one ever breaks it down to something that doesn’t feel like another arbitrary homework hoop. I got up, dug through the box of my old high school books on the shelf above the fridge, pulled out my own tattered copy of To Kill a Mockingbird and slid it across the table to her. The spine is held together with packing tape, the margins filled with scribbles from 16-year-old me, random notes from college, and quick comments I added when I taught the book 10 years ago.
Lila flipped through it, snorting at a note I wrote next to the first Atticus scene that says “this guy is so boring why can’t we just talk about Boo.” “You wrote that?” she said. “I thought annotations were supposed to be fancy literary stuff.”
That’s the biggest myth I see kids buy into: annotation isn’t for the teacher. It’s for you. It’s just a way to leave breadcrumbs for your future self, so when it’s time to study for a test or write an essay, you don’t have to re-read the whole book to remember what you thought. And it doesn’t have to be fancy.
The first thing I tell every kid who’s stressed about it is to ditch the fancy supply list. You don’t need six different colored highlighters for theme vs. character vs. setting. That just wastes 10 minutes of your study period and makes a mess. All you need is a regular erasable pencil and a pack of 1×3 inch sticky notes. If it’s a school rental, write all your notes on the sticky notes tucked into the margin, pull them out when you turn the book back in, and you’re done. No marks, no fine, no stress. That solves half the problem right there.
As for what to actually write, I give kids three simple categories to work from, no literary jargon required. First, write down anything that confuses you. If you don’t know what an entailment is, or don’t get why a character would make that choice, just jot “what is this?” next to it. That’s a great annotation. Teachers don’t expect you to understand everything the first time you read, and when it’s time for class discussion, you already know what questions you want to ask.
Second, write down anything that makes you react. It doesn’t have to be a deep literary insight. If you get mad at a character’s choice, write “this is such a bad move.” If a line reminds you of something that happened to you, write that down. When Lila got to the part where Jem loses his pants climbing over the Radley fence, she wrote “my dad made me climb a tree once to get our cat and I lost my favorite sneakers same vibe.” That’s a perfect annotation. It means you’re connecting the book to your own life, which is the first step to real analysis, even if it feels silly at first.
Third, mark anything you notice that repeats. If Atticus says “climb into someone’s skin and walk around in it” for the second time, just circle it and write “repeat.” That’s enough. You don’t need to write a whole paragraph about the theme of empathy right there in the margin. You just need to mark it so you can find it again later when you’re working on your essay.
Last month at co-op, a 9th grader named Javi told me this system still didn’t work for him, because stopping to write every few pages ruined his reading flow. He likes to get invested in the story, read a whole chapter straight through without interruptions. I told him there’s no rule that says you have to annotate as you go. He can read the whole chapter first, enjoy the plot, then go back and spend three or four minutes adding his notes after. He tried it, and his teacher told me his annotations are actually better now that he’s not just rushing to get them done while he’s trying to follow the story. It’s a small shift, but it makes a huge difference for kids who process stories that way.
A lot of parents ask me how they can help if they haven’t annotated a book since they were in school. I tell them the last thing you want to do is grade your kid’s notes or tell them they should have written something deeper instead of that silly note about their English teacher’s cat being named Atticus. Just ask one simple question when they’re done reading for the night: “What’s the most random thing you wrote in the margins today?” That gets them talking about the book without it feeling like a quiz, and half the time they end up explaining the plot or themes to you without even realizing it, which helps them remember it better anyway.
Yesterday, Lila came home from school grinning. Ms. Henderson called on her to talk about the scene where Scout meets Boo Radley for the first time, and Lila pulled out her book, pointed to the sticky note in the margin that said “Scout thought he was a monster this whole time, but he’s just shy. That’s like Mia from my math class who never talks because she has social anxiety.” The whole class talked about it for 15 minutes, and Lila got to lead most of it.
She still complains about the three annotations per page rule. Last night, I saw she wrote “this rule is dumb” in pencil in the margin of page 127, with a tiny sticky note that says “still don’t get what entailment is” stuck next to it. I told her both are perfectly good annotations. We’ve got three more chapters to go, and I don’t know if she’ll keep this system when she takes AP English next year, or if she’ll go back to underlining half the page when she’s cramming for a test. But right now, it’s working. She doesn’t groan when it’s time to do her reading homework, and she can pull out the exact line she needs when it’s time to study or write an essay. That’s all annotation is supposed to do, anyway.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How to Annotate Books for School: Simple, Low-Stress Tips for Students