How Long Do You Let Your Kids Ramble? Practical Tips for Parents
I was buckling my 7-year-old daughter Mia into her car seat last week when she opened her mouth and didn’t stop. It started with a crack in the third-grade blacktop, the one with dandelions growing out the middle. She told me about an ant she’d watched carry a Cheeto crumb three times its size, how it got stuck on a dandelion root for two whole minutes of recess, how another ant came to help but then stole the crumb instead. That led to a tangent about how she once stole a sticker from her cousin, how that made her feel, how the new strawberry eraser Lila got for her birthday definitely wasn’t stolen, even though it’s really fancy. I glanced at the clock on my dash: I had a work call starting in 11 minutes, and I still needed to swing by the grocery store for the milk I’d forgotten for breakfast.
I used to cut her off right about here. I’d say “honey, that’s nice, tell me later, we’re in a hurry.” And I did that, three or four times in one week a couple of months back. By the fourth time, she just snapped her mouth shut, stared out the side window, and wouldn’t say another word the whole ride home. When I asked her what was wrong, she mumbled “you never care about the stuff I want to tell you.” That stung, enough that I started thinking about what rambling actually is, instead of just seeing it as a kid being distracted or wasting my time.
I talked to a friend who teaches second grade, and she said she notices this dynamic all the time. Parents will ask why their kid can’t stay on topic, why they jump from one thing to the next when they tell a story. But she says that off-topic rambling is just how little kids practice organizing their thoughts. When they ramble, they’re trying out connecting one idea to another, testing what’s interesting, working through a problem out loud before they even know they have a problem. She told me last year she had a student who rambled through every single share time, and by the end of the year, he was writing the longest, most creative stories in the class. He’d just been practicing his flow out loud first.
After that conversation, I started testing small, specific changes instead of just telling myself to “be more patient” — which I never remember to do when I’m already rushed. First, I started naming the time I have up front, instead of letting her start talking and cutting her off mid-way. If I’m on my way out the door or have a call coming, I say “I have 3 minutes right now to listen. Tell me the most exciting part, and we can finish the rest at dinner tonight.” That’s way better than cutting her off, because she gets to say the thing that’s most important to her right now, and she knows the rest will get heard later. If I have time, I just step back and don’t interrupt, even if the story goes all over the place.
That’s what happened two Saturdays ago after dinner. She started talking about how she wanted to set up a lemonade stand out front. For 12 minutes straight, she went: the sign needs to be pink, not red, because pink draws more people. What if we charge 25 cents a cup? What if a dog knocks over the pitcher? Do we need a tarp if it rains? Can we save the extra lemonade for Daddy? I was standing by the sink wiping down counters, and I kept having the thought that I should cut her off, tell her to go brush her teeth, we can talk about it tomorrow. But I didn’t. I just nodded and said “mmhmm” every once in a while. When she was done, she looked right at me and said “so can we do it next weekend?” That whole ramble wasn’t just random noise. She was working through her plan out loud, step by step, before she asked me for permission. I never would have gotten that if I’d cut her off at the 2 minute mark like I used to.
Another small trick I use: if I’m not sure how much time she needs, I ask one simple question: “Is this the main part you wanted to tell me, or are you just getting started?” Half the time she’ll say “that’s it, just wanted to tell you about the ant” and we can move on. The other half she’ll say “I’m still getting to the good part” and I know I need to block out a little more time. And if I do have to cut her off, I always circle back later. I’ll say at bedtime, “remind me what happened to that ant that stole the Cheeto crumb” so she knows I didn’t forget, that her story matters even when I’m busy.
I still get it wrong, a lot. Some days I’m so overwhelmed with work and chores and the million things that need to get done that I cut her off before she even gets three sentences out. I see her face shut down, and I know I messed up. It’s not like I now have unlimited time to listen to 20 minute tangents about playground cracks and ant dramas. I still have deadlines, I still need to get dinner on the table, we still have to get to soccer practice on time.
I don’t have a magic number for how long you should let your kids ramble. Some days it’s 2 minutes, some days it’s 15. The only thing I’ve changed is that I don’t automatically see rambling as a problem to fix, or a waste of my time. It’s just how kids think, before they learn to condense their thoughts into the 30 second soundbites adults use. Last weekend we did that lemonade stand, Mia made $12, and she donated all of it to the local animal shelter. That whole thing started with a 12 minute ramble that I almost cut short. I still don’t always get the timing right, but I’m trying more often to pause, and wait, and let them talk until they’re done.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How Long Do You Let Your Kids Ramble