How Hard Is It to Switch Careers Into Teaching? A First-Year Teacher’s Honest Take
Last Tuesday, I stood by the elementary school copy machine at 7:12 a.m., staring at a stack of 28 half-cut 3rd grade fraction worksheets, wondering why the machine kept eating my red cardstock, and trying to mop spilled oat milk latte out of my canvas tote with a crumpled used tissue. A 4th grade teacher stopped next to me, glanced at my leaky tote and lopsided worksheets, grinned, and said, “First career switch year, right?” I nodded, and she added, “I left nursing 10 years ago. I still forget to restock my glue sticks sometimes.”
That line stuck with me, because for the year before I quit my 8-year career in marketing to teach, all I heard was two extremes: either switching to education is impossible for career changers, or it’s the most perfect, rewarding thing you’ll ever do and all your problems will disappear. No one told me what it’s actually like, day to day, how hard it really is, and what parts are easier than you expect.
I got into marketing right out of college, climbed the ladder to a senior role that paid well, but by the end I was spending 10 hours a week in meetings talking about engagement metrics for a granola brand, and I couldn’t remember the last time I’d done something that felt like it stuck. I loved working with kids through my church’s after-school program, so I started looking into teaching. I expected the hard part to be the certification, or learning how to write lesson plans, or corralling 28 8-year-olds who all want to tell you about their new puppy at the same time. Some of that is hard, sure, but the hardest parts are the things no one warns you about before you switch.
The first surprise was how much of your own money you’ll spend on basic supplies. I’d read that teachers spend hundreds of dollars a year out of pocket, but I’d never had a job where I couldn’t expense a $15 pack of crayons. My first month, I spent almost $300 on fidget tools, extra snacks for kids who come to school hungry, and art supplies that the district said were “out of stock this semester.” That stings when you’re already taking a pay cut from your old corporate job, and it’s a bigger hurdle than any certification test I took.
The second surprise was the emotional weight. In marketing, if a client was upset, I could send a revised deck or a small discount and move on. Last month, one of my students had a full meltdown in reading group after he turned in his work and his pencil broke. It took me 10 minutes to get him to calm down enough to tell me his mom had lost her job the night before, and they’d slept at his aunt’s house on a couch, and he hadn’t gotten any homework done because there was no desk for him to work at. I stood there holding him while he cried, and my mind went blank. I’d gone through all my summer PD training, but there’s no script for that. There’s no quick fix. After a few minutes, I walked him down to the counselor, who helped me get him signed up for the weekend food program, but I went home that night thinking I’d messed up, that I wasn’t cut out for this.
What’s easier than I expected, though? The actual teaching part. I was convinced I’d forgotten everything I learned about 3rd grade math, and that I’d stand in front of the class and not know how to explain long division. But every district I looked at gives you a pre-written, step-by-step curriculum. If I don’t understand how to teach a lesson, I can walk down the hall to the teacher who’s been doing this for 18 years, and she’ll walk me through it in five minutes. You don’t have to reinvent the wheel as a new career switcher, no matter what people say. I also assumed I’d have to go back to school full time for two years to get licensed, but my state has an alternative certification program that lets you work while you finish your requirements, which made the switch possible when I still had a mortgage to pay.
I’ve picked up a few small things that make the switch a lot easier, too, that I tell my friends who are thinking about making the jump. First, set a hard $50 monthly limit for personal spending on classroom supplies. Before I set that limit, I’d buy every cute activity on Teachers Pay Teachers and end up broke by the middle of the month. Now I check the school’s storage closet first for extra supplies, and 9 times out of 10, there’s a box of unopened crayons or construction paper someone left behind from last year. Second, make a go-to list of three people you can ask silly questions at 7 a.m. Don’t just rely on your assigned mentor—mine is great, but she’s also the team lead and has 12 meetings a month. My go-to is the part-time para who’s been at the school for 12 years, and she answers my text about how to log attendance in two minutes. Third, leave all your work at school at least one full evening a week. I used to bring grading home every night, and I was burned out by October. Now I work through my prep period and stay until 4:30, then close my bag and walk out. Some worksheets don’t get decorated the night before, and no one cares.
Last week, that student who had the meltdown ran back to me after school to hand me a blue rock he’d painted with a lopsided yellow sun. It’s sitting on my desk right now, next to my half-empty coffee pot and the stack of worksheets I didn’t get graded on Friday. I still can’t get the smartboard to connect to my laptop half the time, I still forget to order snack for the class once a month, and some days I leave school with a headache and wonder why I quit my old job with the steady 401k match. But it’s not as hard as the people who never switched make it sound, and it’s not as perfect as the social media posts say either. It’s just work, most days good, some days hard, and I’m still figuring it out as I go.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How Hard Is It to Switch Careers Into Teaching