How a veteran special education teacher’s legacy helps us support kids who shut down
The cardboard box was tucked behind a broken bookshelf in the back of the elementary school storage closet, its edges softened by 20 years of temperature swings and mouse nibbles. The handwriting on the side in blue ballpoint read “M. Henderson, reading interventions 1998-2022”. I knew it was hers before I lifted the lid; it smelled exactly like I remembered: lemon drops and burnt coffee.
I was volunteering over spring break to clear out the old wing for the new kindergarten addition, and Mrs. Henderson died last November, just a few weeks after she came out of retirement to cover a medical leave no one else would take. She was 72, had beat breast cancer 10 years earlier, and one morning she just didn’t show up for work. The principal called to say she’d had a heart attack in her sleep, and the whole school went quiet for a day.
I started at this school as a 22-year-old para right out of college, and I had no idea what I was doing. There was a third grader named Javi, who’d moved here from Mexico the year before, who would put his head down on his desk and refuse to speak any time we pulled him out for reading. I’d tried everything the training manual said: sticker charts, extra recess for participation, calling home, even sending him to the principal’s office for defiance. Nothing worked. One afternoon I was so frustrated I walked him down to Mrs. Henderson’s room, thinking she’d know how to “fix” him. I hovered by the door after I dropped him off, because I felt guilty for passing him off.
Javi put his head down on her desk immediately, same as he did for me. Mrs. Henderson didn’t lean in, didn’t beg him to try, didn’t call him out for being rude. She just pulled a lemon drop out of the jar on her desk, pushed it across the desk to his elbow, pulled the crumpled Ninja Turtle comic book out of his hoodie pocket, and opened it to the folded page he’d marked. She started reading out loud, in this rough, gravelly voice that always sounded like she had a cold, all about a mutated turtle fighting a rogue scientist. When she got to the end of the page, she stopped, closed the book halfway, and said “I can’t turn the page without you. The bad guy’s gonna get away if you don’t tell me what happens next.” After a minute, Javi lifted his head, reached over, and turned the page. He read one sentence out loud, quiet enough that I could barely hear it from the door, and that was the start.
I went through her box that day after I found it, and most of what was in it wasn’t fancy test results or polished lesson plans. It was index cards, one for every kid she’d ever worked with, each with three or four lines of scribbled notes. No IEPs, no percentile scores, just small, specific details: “Stutters when he reads out loud, let him read to the teddy bear instead”, “Only reads soccer books, that’s okay, just let him”, “Mom works two nights, forgets to sign logs, don’t mark it missing, just text her a quick reminder on Sunday when she’s off”.
I’ve been teaching 3rd grade here for 8 years now, and before I found that box, I’d half forgotten all the small things she taught me that don’t make it into teacher training or parenting Instagram. A lot of the advice you see now for kids who shut down is big: new evaluations, specialized programs, 10-step behavior plans. But Mrs. Henderson’s tricks are all small, things any parent or teacher can do tomorrow, no extra budget or special training needed.
First, always start with two minutes of nothing related to work. If your kid shuts down when it’s homework time, don’t jump straight into the math problems. Ask them about the TikTok they were watching five minutes ago, or how their soccer practice went, before you mention anything school related. It takes two minutes, and it lets them drop the guard they put up when they think they’re going to be told they’re doing something wrong. Second, let them do the work on their terms first, before you push them to meet your expectations. If your 10 year old won’t read because they think the assigned book is boring, let them read comic books or sports articles or YouTube descriptions for a month. The habit of reading is way more important than reading the “right” book. Confidence comes before progress, not the other way around. Third, let the small stuff go. If your kid forgets their homework three weeks in a row, or can’t sit still at the dinner table while they do it, don’t punish them. Chances are, they’re already overwhelmed, and the punishment just makes them associate school with feeling bad.
I used these rules this year with Mia, a girl in my class who wouldn’t write a single word for the first six weeks of school. She’d just sit there, twisting her hair, staring at the blank page. Instead of sending her to the counselor or marking her work missing every day, I started checking in with her about her new kitten for two minutes every morning. I let her write about the kitten instead of the assigned personal narrative about summer vacation. I didn’t mark off points for spelling or messy handwriting the first month. Last week she turned in a three page story about her kitten learning to jump on the couch. It has 17 spelling mistakes, and the handwriting is so messy I can barely read half of it, but it’s hers. That’s what Mrs. Henderson would have wanted.
The school is naming the new reading intervention room after Mrs. Henderson. They’re putting a plaque up by the door with her name and a nice quote about teaching. I brought the box of index cards to the office last week to add to the display, but I kept a handful of the cards in my desk drawer. Some days when I’m frustrated, and I have a kid who won’t do anything I ask, I pull one out and read it. It doesn’t fix every problem. I still have kids who shut down all year, no matter what I try. No one has a magic fix, not even Mrs. Henderson. But that’s the thing about her legacy: it wasn’t about turning every struggling kid into a straight A student. It was about showing up, every single day, with a lemon drop and a little bit of grace, and meeting the kid where they are. That’s the part that doesn’t make it into the plaques, but it’s the part that stays.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How a veteran special education teacher’s legacy helps us support kids who shut down