How a Messy Kitchen Experiment Helped My Niece Get More Confident (and Have Fun)
My niece and I were at the kitchen table last Saturday, and she was drawing a horse. She’s seven, and she loves horses, but the horse on her paper had a neck that was too long, and one leg was floating somewhere near its ear. She stared at it, then crumpled the page into a tight ball. “It’s wrong,” she said. Her eyes were starting to water.
I’ve learned not to say “No, it’s beautiful!” because she can tell when I’m lying. So I just sat there for a second. Then I asked, “Want to make a volcano instead? And you get to be in charge.”
She looked suspicious. “Like a real one?”
“Messier,” I said.
We found an old muffin tin, a box of baking soda, a bottle of vinegar, and a set of food coloring drops that had been hiding in the pantry since last Christmas. I put everything on a tray and told her the only rule: she had to be the one to pour, mix, and decide what happened next. I was just the safety lookout.
She acted like a tiny lab director. She spooned baking soda into three muffin cups, then carefully added drops of red and blue food coloring. When I handed her the vinegar, she paused. “What if I pour too much?”
“Then we’ll wipe it up,” I said. “But let’s see what too much actually looks like.”
She poured a small splash. It fizzed, bubbled, and died within three seconds. “That was it?” she said, disappointed.
“Try more,” I said. “All of it. At once.”
She tipped the whole small bottle in. The eruption was not majestic—it was a foamy, brownish-pink blob that crawled over the rim, slid onto the muffin tin, and kept oozing. It looked less like a volcano and more like a giant alien sneeze. Niece gasped, then laughed so hard she snorted. “Do it again,” she said. “Can I add soap this time?”
That was the moment I realized what was happening. She wasn’t just playing with baking soda. She was testing something. She started adding dish soap, then a raisin, then four extra drops of blue food coloring, then a handful of salt just to see. Every time it did something new, she turned to me and announced, “Look what I made.” She didn’t ask if it was good. She didn’t wait for approval. She just kept watching the fizz and saying, “I wonder what happens if…”
It might sound like I’m making a big deal out of a kitchen mess. But for my niece, this was rare. She’s a kid who likes things to be neat and right. She colors inside the lines, lines up her dolls, and gets genuinely upset when her drawings don’t match the ones in her picture books. She often asks, “Can you do it for me?” because she’s afraid her version won’t be good enough. That fear is something I know well, because I had it too as a kid. It’s not just about art. It’s about being afraid to try things when the outcome is unclear.
What the volcano did wasn’t teach her science, though it did. It gave her a place where unpredictability was the point. The whole activity was designed to surprise. There was no “right” way to make the volcano erupt, so she couldn’t fail. And because I let her be the one in charge—not me, the adult, holding the vinegar and saying “see what happens”—she got to feel the cause and effect of her own decisions. She poured too much; she saw what happened. She added soap; she saw what happened. Every choice she made produced a result she could observe, question, and build on. That’s confidence, but not the kind that comes from being praised. It comes from feeling like your actions matter.
After the volcano, we moved to the garden with my phone. I told her she was the photographer and she had to take ten pictures of anything she liked, but they couldn’t be of people. She walked around looking through the screen, suddenly very serious. She took a photo of a leaf with a hole in it. She took a photo of the garden hose coiled on the ground. She took a photo of her own feet standing in the dirt. When I asked to see them, I expected her to say they were “bad” like she does with her drawings. But instead, she scrolled through and said, “This one makes the hose look like a giant snake,” and “This is the exact shape of the crack in the sidewalk—look, it matches.”
I thought about how often we tell kids what to notice. We point at flowers and say “pretty,” or at birds and say “look!” But when a seven-year-old gets to decide what’s worth looking at, they start practicing something important: trusting their own taste. My niece didn’t need me to say “good job.” She needed to be the one deciding what was worth capturing in the first place.
Here’s what I want other parents or aunts or uncles to know. The activities don’t have to be elaborate. You don’t need a science kit or a curated craft. What matters is the setup: put the materials in front of the kid, make it safe enough, and then step back. Try phrases like “What did you notice?” instead of “That’s awesome.” Ask “What do you want to try next?” instead of giving instructions. If something spills, say “Okay, look at that pattern on the floor—interesting,” and hand her the sponge. Let her be the one who figures out how to fix it, or even decide not to fix it yet.
Another thing that helped: having ingredients and tools within her reach. I moved the baking powder, cornstarch, and food coloring to a lower shelf in the pantry so she could choose an experiment on a dull afternoon without needing to ask. It doesn’t have to be messy every time—sometimes she pours flour into a bowl just to watch it poof. But the point is she chose it. That sense of “I picked this” does a lot of quiet work.
I’m not pretending my niece is suddenly a fearless kid. She still crumpled up a drawing the other day and said it wasn’t good enough. She still asks for help whenever something looks complicated. But I’ve noticed she says “I have an idea” a lot more often now. Sometimes her idea is terrible, like adding olive oil to the volcano, and that’s fine. The oil created a weird layer of bubbles we hadn’t seen before. She studied it and said, “That’s not what I thought would happen.” And then she laughed. That little gap between expectation and result used to frustrate her. Now, at least sometimes, it feels like a game.
We haven’t found a perfect formula for confidence. I don’t think one exists. But I’ve learned that confidence at this age often isn’t about feeling good all the time. It’s about discovering that you can make a mess, observe what happens, and survive it. It’s about being the one who decides what to photograph, what to add, and what to do next. The volcano will dry to a dusty crust in our muffin tin. She’ll keep drawing wonky horses. But maybe she’ll also keep believing her own eyes and her own choices a little more than she did before. And if the only thing we ever do is make a spectacular mess together, that might just be enough for now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How a Messy Kitchen Experiment Helped My Niece Get More Confident (and Have Fun)