How A High School Literature Assignment Caused A Sibling Rift (And Useful Parenting Takeaways)
I was wiping cranberry sauce off the Thanksgiving dinner platter last month when Lila slammed her dog-eared copy of A Raisin in the Sun down on the kitchen counter. Post-its fluttered across the linoleum, and she crossed her arms, staring at the toe of her scuffed Converse instead of at me. “You know what my final paper assignment is?” she said. “We have to map the Younger family onto our own. I put you as Walter. I’m Beneatha.”
I laughed, wiping my hands on my jeans. “Why am I the angry brother who blows all the money?” I said. She didn’t laugh back. “Because you do the same thing he does,” she said. “Everyone does. You all think my wanting to go to RISD for illustration is just some silly hobby I’ll get over. Just like Walter thought Beneatha being a doctor was a waste of time and money.” Then she turned and ran up the stairs, slamming her door behind her. The football game on the living room TV blared on, and my dad yelled at a referee call like nothing had happened. I bent to pick up her post-its, my face hot.
I’m a senior education major, home for the holiday, and I’d written three papers on how “reader-response” assignments like this help kids connect 70-year-old plays to their own lives. I’d always thought it was such a smart, thoughtful activity. I never stopped to think what would happen when that connection dragged unspoken tension out into the open that no one had wanted to name.
I flipped open her book to the highlighted passage, the one she’d stuck a neon pink post-it on. It was the line where Walter leans into Beneatha, tired and sharp, and says, “Who even told you you had to be a doctor? If you so crazy ‘bout messing ‘round with sick people – then go be a nurse like other women – or just get married and be quiet.” Scrawled in the margin in Lila’s messy gel pen was, This is what Megan said last spring break about RISD.
Oh. I remembered that conversation. I’d come home from my classes, full of practical advice about how college works, how tuition adds up, how you have to be realistic. I’d said, “Have you looked at in-state programs with great art tracks? They’re a third of the cost, and you can still transfer later if you want.” I thought I was being helpful. I had gotten what I wanted – parents covered my in-state tuition for education, no one questioned my plan to teach high school – so I never stopped to see how my “practicality” looked from where she was standing.
I waited an hour, gave her time to cool off, before I grabbed the last chocolate chip cookie from the dessert plate and walked up to her room. I knocked soft, didn’t push the door open until she said come in. I didn’t start with “you’re overreacting” or “we support you, what are you talking about.” I just set the cookie on her desk and said, “I read your notes. I didn’t know that’s how what I said felt. Tell me more.” That’s it, that’s all I did. I didn’t have a solution, I didn’t promise we’d come up with tuition money tomorrow. I just listened.
That’s the thing no one really talks about with these personal connection assignments. Teachers love them because they get kids engaged, and they’re right – they do. But they don’t always prepare kids (or families) for the fact that this kind of work can pull up real hurt that’s been hiding. For anyone working with kids, that’s the first small change I’d suggest: if you’re assigning this kind of work, add a two-minute heads up at the start. Just say, “This might bring up feelings you haven’t talked about with your family yet, that’s okay, and you don’t have to share anything you don’t want to in this paper. If you want to talk about it after class, I’m here.” It takes almost no time, but it gives kids permission to feel whatever comes up instead of brushing it off to get a good grade.
If you’re a parent, don’t brush off your kid’s reaction as just drama from a homework assignment. It’s not drama. It’s often the first time they’ve had the words to name something they’ve been feeling for months. The biggest mistake you can make is jumping to defend yourself or fix the problem right away. Just ask them to show you what part of the story made them feel that way. That simple question lets them lead the conversation, instead of putting them on the defensive.
After that night, we didn’t fix everything. We still don’t know how we’re going to come up with RISD tuition, and there are still days I catch myself leaning into practicality before I listen. But we made small changes that matter. I’m driving her to the RISD national portfolio day next month in Boston, and I’m helping her sort through her sketches to pick the best ones for her portfolio, instead of questioning whether the trip is worth the gas money. When she teases me and calls me Walter now, it’s half joke, half reminder, and it works.
I still think reading A Raisin in the Sun and connecting it to your own family is a great assignment. I just don’t think anyone tells you that it can rearrange how you see your own family, for better or worse. Right now, it’s still a work in progress. But that’s better than the tension sitting there, unsaid, under every conversation about college and future plans.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How A High School Literature Assignment Caused A Sibling Rift (And Useful Parenting Takeaways)