Helping kids who fall through the cracks: What I learned teaching in rural China
I was stacking construction paper on a wobbly wooden table at a rural primary school in Guizhou when I first noticed Xiao Ming. All the other 10-year-olds crowded around, shoving each other to grab the brightest red and blue sheets, but he hung back, leaning against a cinder block wall, kicking at loose gravel. His school uniform was two sizes too big, hand stuffed deep in his pocket. I waved him over to pick a sheet, and he just dropped his gaze and turned to walk back to the empty classroom. His homeroom teacher followed me a minute later, wiping vegetable oil off her apron, and said, “Don’t bother with that one. He’s dumb, won’t talk. Parents work in a factory in Guangzhou, come back once a year. Grandma can’t control him, can’t even read his homework notes.”
I didn’t push it for a few days. Three days later, I was walking back from the outhouse after lunch and found him sitting on the cracked concrete steps behind the classroom, twisting a crumpled third-grade math worksheet between his fingers. What caught my eye wasn’t that it was blank—almost every question was filled in, even the longer word problems, though almost every answer was wrong. I sat down next to him, didn’t mention the worksheet at first, just watched him pluck dandelions growing through the step crack. After five minutes of quiet, he mumbled that he was looking for four-leaf clovers. I said I was terrible at finding them, asked if he could teach me.
Ten minutes later, he showed me the worksheet, and I realized the problem wasn’t that he couldn’t do math. He couldn’t read half the words in the word problems. He’d repeated third grade twice, and couldn’t read at a first-grade level. Back when he was in first grade, he missed a full month of school to get treated for pneumonia, and no one ever caught him up. Teachers moved on with the rest of the class, his grandma couldn’t sound out words to help him, and he learned that the safest thing to do was stay quiet. If no one asks you questions, no one finds out you can’t answer them.
I hear a lot of people talk about helping kids like Xiao Ming in China like it requires building a new school or shipping hundreds of brand-new textbooks. That’s part of it, sure, but the biggest gap I saw wasn’t resources—it was consistent, small daily attention that most kids take for granted. I didn’t have a fancy reading curriculum or extra funding for tutoring, so I started with the simplest routine I could think of: five minutes a day, right after snack time, before the afternoon group activities started.
I didn’t pull him out of class to do drills in the hallway, which would have just made the other kids tease him and made him more self-conscious. We practiced words around whatever we were already doing. If we were walking out to the playground, I’d point to the chipped sign that said “No running” and ask him to find the “run” character. If he pulled a lemon candy out of his pocket (his grandma always kept one for him), I’d ask him to read the brand name on the wrapper. The one rule I stuck to was waiting 10 full seconds after I asked a question before I said anything else. Most teachers and adults just jump in with the answer after two or three seconds of silence when kids like Xiao Ming don’t respond immediately, so he never had to practice thinking through it on his own. If he got it right, we just moved on—no big, embarrassing praise that made him hide his face. If he got it wrong, I just rephrased the question and waited another 10 seconds.
When I walked to his house for a check-in with his grandma halfway through the program, I found out she felt terrible that she couldn’t help with homework. She was 72, had never gone to school, couldn’t read a single character, and said she just told him to “do your homework” but had no idea if he was doing it right. I told her she didn’t need to know how to read to help. I gave her one simple routine she could do every night, even when she was tired from weeding the cornfield: after dinner, ask Xiao Ming to read just one sentence out loud from whatever textbook he has that day. All she has to do is sit there, listen, and say “That was good” when he finishes. No correcting, no quizzing, just listening. That’s it. She could do that, and it meant Xiao Ming got practice every single day, not just when a volunteer was around.
I stayed for six weeks, then had to go back to my college in Shanghai. The last day, Xiao Ming gave me a crumpled drawing of an ant nest, with four big ants colored in wobbly blue crayon. He didn’t say anything, just shoved it in my hand and ran off.
A lot of people ask me if I “fixed” him, if he’s caught up now. Of course he isn’t. He’s still behind grade level, his parents still only come home once a year, some days he still hides in the back of the classroom and won’t talk when called on. But last month, his homeroom teacher sent me a 10-second voice note. She said last week, Xiao Ming raised his hand and volunteered to read a paragraph out loud from the Chinese textbook. He stumbled over seven characters, stopped three times to think, but he finished the whole thing. No one remembers the last time he volunteered to do that.
The grandma still has him read one sentence a night after dinner. The new volunteer this summer is continuing the five-minute daily word practice. No one knows if he’ll catch up all the way, or if he’ll go to high school, or what will happen when he’s older. That’s the part no one talks about much, I think. Helping a kid like Xiao Ming isn’t about turning him into a straight-A student overnight. It’s about stopping the cycle of writing him off as “too far gone” to help, and doing one tiny, consistent thing that makes him feel like someone sees him, every single day. That’s all any of us can do, right now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Helping kids who fall through the cracks: What I learned teaching in rural China