Help Me With My Student Survey: Why Kids Get Stuck And What Parents And Teachers Can Do
The first thing Lila said when she climbed into the car after school last month was “help me with my student survey please.” She dropped her backpack at my feet, the side pocket bulging with a leaky water bottle and a crumpled gym uniform, and pulled out a three-page pink worksheet, smudged at the edges with pencil eraser and a spot of cherry popsicle.
It was the annual district student wellness survey, the one that gets sent home if kids don’t finish it during class. Lila’s teacher had sent a quick Remind text that morning saying a handful of kids needed extra time, so I’d been expecting it. But I wasn’t expecting the way she crossed her arms and stared at the paper like it was a final exam that would make or break her 4th grade year.
“What’s the problem? It’s just questions, right?” I said, pulling out of the pickup line. She shrugged and stared out the window. “All the girls in my group just checked ‘strongly agree’ for every single one so they could go outside early. But I don’t know if that’s right. What if someone sees what I put?”
By the time we got home, boiled mac and cheese for dinner, and spread the paper out on our kitchen table, I started to understand her worry. The questions were standard: “I feel like I belong at my school,” “There is an adult at school I can talk to if I am upset,” “My classes are not too easy or too hard.” Lila pointed to the first question and said, “What if I say I sometimes feel left out when Sadie sits with the cheerleaders at lunch? Will the principal call Sadie’s mom? Will my teacher talk to me in front of the whole class?”
As an elementary teacher of 12 years, I’ve helped hundreds of kids fill out these surveys during class. I’d never stopped to see the experience from their side. I remembered my own panic filling out the district’s annual teacher climate survey back in February: even though it was supposed to be anonymous, I held back from writing that our grade level had 10 extra kids that year and we didn’t have enough aides for reading groups. I was scared somehow it would get traced back to me. If adults hold back for that reason, it makes total sense that kids would too. They don’t know what “anonymous” actually means in a school setting, and they’ve learned that every comment they make can end up in a conversation they didn’t ask for.
I didn’t give her a big speech about confidentiality. I just pointed to the top of the paper. “See? There’s no spot for your name, right? No spot for your teacher’s name, no student ID number. All they do is count how many 4th graders check what box. They don’t look at individual papers. If 30 out of 50 4th graders say there’s not enough places to sit at lunch, the school will buy more tables. That’s it. No one gets in trouble, no one gets pulled out of class to talk about it.” That’s the first thing I’d tell anyone whose kid asks for help: skip the fancy jargon, explain what the data actually does in terms they can see.
Next, I told her to just say what she actually feels, not what she thinks she’s supposed to say. We went one by one. When she got to “There is an adult at school I can talk to if I am upset,” she paused and said, “I can talk to you at home, but that’s not school. I don’t want to bother my teacher with my stuff, she’s busy with the whole class. But the librarian knows my name and asks about my cat. So do I put ‘somewhat agree’?” I didn’t jump in to say “your teacher would love to talk to you!” or push her to check a more positive box. I just said, “That’s how you feel, so that’s the answer you put.” The second thing I learned from that afternoon: don’t correct their feelings to make the survey look better. The whole point of the survey is to get real input, not the answer adults think they should give.
When she got to a question asking if she’d been bullied this year, she folded her arms over the paper and said, “That’s none of their business. I don’t want to answer it.” I leaned over and checked the fine print at the top. “It says all questions are optional. If you don’t want to answer it, just leave it blank. No one will mark it wrong, no one will email me about it. That’s totally fine.” Third concrete tip: give them full permission to skip any question that feels uncomfortable. No pressure, no pushback.
We finished in 15 minutes, put the paper in her homework folder, and I didn’t think about it again for a month. Then last week, the district sent out an email with the full survey results for our school. It said 34% of 4th graders said they don’t have a trusted adult to talk to at school, and 41% said they don’t have a comfortable spot to eat lunch when they don’t want to sit with a big group. Within two weeks, the school set up two new lunch-time game tables near the library, and added two extra counselor drop-in hours every week.
Last Friday, Lila came home and said she sat at the new game table and played Uno with two girls from her class, and didn’t have to squeeze into the end of a bench next to people she didn’t know. She didn’t say it was because of her survey answer, and I didn’t ask. I just know that if every kid had checked “strongly agree” to every question just to get it done, those new tables never would have showed up.
I used to see these student surveys as just another chore, another box to check for the district. Now I see they’re a small, easy chance to let kids practice being honest about their experiences, and show them that their voice can actually change things. It doesn’t fix every hard part of middle elementary school. Sadie still sits with the cheerleaders most days, and Lila still doesn’t want to talk to the counselor about anything. But that 15 minutes we spent on a crumpled, popsicle-stained piece of paper ended up giving her a new place to eat lunch, and that’s more than any of us expected. Some of the smallest school chores turn out to matter more than we think.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Help Me With My Student Survey: Why Kids Get Stuck And What Parents And Teachers Can Do