Educational Programs for 9 and 13 Year Olds: What Worked (And What Didn’t) For My Two Kids
The stack of after-school program flyers landed on my kitchen counter last week, crinkled at the edges from being shoved in my mailbox, right next to a half-empty jar of pickles and my 9-year-old Lila’s permission slip for the 4th grade field trip. Lila was sprawled on the floor coloring a dragon with neon markers, and my 13-year-old Jake was slouched on the couch, one eye on his phone, pretending he couldn’t hear me talking about sign-ups. I stared at the flyers for a minute, and that old familiar stress crept in—last year I’d signed both of them up for the same district-wide STEM day camp, advertised as “perfect for 8-14 year olds.” It was not perfect. Jake spent the first three hours texting me from the bathroom, saying all the activities were “for little kids” and he wanted to come home. Lila cried on the third day because she couldn’t figure out the robot coding activity and the overstretched teen volunteer helping her didn’t have time to walk her through it. I picked them both up that day with a lighter wallet and a new rule: no more one-size-fits-all programs for my 9 and 13 year old.
I used to think educational programs were supposed to be an investment, something that would pad their college applications or teach them a skill they’d use forever. Now I know they’re mostly supposed to fit where your kid is right now developmentally, and 9 and 13 couldn’t be in more different places.
For Lila, 9 is that sweet spot where she still gets giddy about making a mess, she wants to show me every single thing she creates, but she hates being told exactly what to do every step of the way. I first tried a structured math enrichment program for her after school last fall, advertised to boost state test scores. She sat at a desk doing worksheets for an hour and a half after a full day of school, and by the second week she was faking stomach aches to get out of going. Then a friend told me about the Junior Inventors workshop at the local public library, run by a retired art teacher. It’s only once a week, for an hour and a half, and it’s exclusively for 8-10 year olds. The whole premise is that the kids pick a small problem they actually have, and build something to fix it out of recycled materials. There’s no test, no grade, no right way to do it. Lila’s first project was a holder for her water bottle that clips to her bike handlebars, after she dropped and cracked her last one. Her second was a locked box for her friendship bracelets, built to keep Jake from stealing them to tease her. She comes home every week covered in hot glue and talks nonstop about what her friends are building. It’s educational without feeling like school—she’s problem solving, measuring, figuring out what works and what doesn’t, but she thinks she’s just playing.
For Jake, 13 is the opposite. He’d rather die than bring a craft project home for me to hang on the fridge. He cares a lot about seeming cool, about not being grouped with kids who still sleep with stuffed animals. After the STEM camp disaster, I asked him what he actually wanted to do, not what I thought would look good on a high school transcript later. He mumbled something about making skate videos with his friends, but all the local film classes were either for little kids or college students. Then I found a teen filmmaking intensive at the local community college, only for 13-17 year olds, that meets one Saturday a month. It’s run by a part-time film teacher who lets the teens pick their own projects, no forced coming-of-age short films about your family’s vacation. Jake and three other boys made a 5-minute short about the hidden skate spots around our town. They filmed at the park, at the empty bank parking lot downtown, even in our driveway. He had to write a rough script, coordinate schedules, learn how to edit basic clips. I didn’t have to nag him once to go. He even asked me to help him adjust the sound on one scene a week before the screening, which is the most he’s asked me to engage with a hobby in a year.
I’ve picked up a few small, concrete tricks along the way that I wish someone had told me before I wasted all that money on the wrong programs. First, I always email or call the program coordinator a week before registering and ask, “What’s the exact age range of kids already signed up for this session?” If the group has more than a 3-year spread, I pass. All-ages sounds nice in theory, but 9 year olds learn and engage totally differently than 13 year olds, and most programs end up catering to a middle that doesn’t work for either. Second, I match the structure to their current stage. For 9 year olds, I look for low-stakes, hands-on programs with lots of room for choice. No worksheets, no tests, no pressure to perform. They’re still learning through play, so any educational program that feels like extra school is going to be a waste. For 13 year olds, I look for programs that give them real responsibility and let them lead. They don’t want to be taught every little step like a little kid, and they want to be around other teens who get where they are. Third, I let them opt out after the first week if they hate it, no guilt, no lectures about sticking things out. Lila tried a soccer program that she bailed on after two sessions, and Jake didn’t like the first teen book club he joined. It’s okay, not every program has to stick.
Last week, Lila told me she wants to switch out of Junior Inventors next semester to try the community garden program for young kids, where they get to grow their own tomatoes. Jake already signed up for a graphic design workshop for teens next quarter, because he wants to make t-shirts for his skate crew. I don’t know if either of them will stick with these new programs. I don’t know if any of this will matter when they apply to college, or what skill they’ll actually carry with them into adulthood. Right now, though, Lila comes home excited every week, and Jake has something that’s his, that I didn’t force on him. That’s more than I ever got from those overpriced one-size-fits-all programs anyway.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Educational Programs for 9 and 13 Year Olds: What Worked (And What Didn’t) For My Two Kids