Do Grades Measure Learning Or Just How Well Kids Follow Instructions? A Teacher’s Perspective
The coffee in my conference mug had gone cold by the time Mia’s mom sat down, leaning forward to stare at the B scrawled across Mia’s 4th grade science report. Mia’s hand-built display of local sedimentary rocks was propped against my desk, the labels scrawled in sparkly pen she’d brought from home. “She can name every formation we’ve hiked to within an hour of here,” her mom said, tapping the report card. “She spends Friday nights watching geology TikTok. Why is she getting a B in science?”
The B wasn’t because Mia didn’t know the material. It was because her final lab report on rock types listed her conclusion before her hypothesis, which was out of the order our grade-level rubric required. Ten points off for incorrect section order, five off for not using the standard 12-point font we’d specified, and that A dropped straight to a B. I nodded along with her mom, because I’d had the same argument at our grade-level meeting the week before.
A week earlier, I’d graded Javi’s multiplication test. He got every single answer right, but he used a mental math shortcut he’d learned from his dad instead of the lattice method we’d been taught that unit. Fifteen points off for not showing required work, so his 100% became an 85%. Javi can multiply three-digit numbers faster than I can, but his report card didn’t show that.
As a 12-year classroom teacher and a mom of a middle schooler, I’ve seen this play out on both sides of the desk. Two months ago, my own son brought home a C on a history research paper. His thesis was solid, his sources were correctly cited, and he’d spent three weekends interviewing local veterans for his project on the Vietnam War. He lost 20 points because he used bullet points for his working outline instead of full sentences, as the instructions required. I sat on the couch with him that night, crossing out the bullet points and rewriting them just to get the grade bumped, and I thought: this isn’t teaching him anything about history. It’s just teaching him to follow the rules, even when they don’t matter.
It’s easy to jump to the conclusion that all grades are useless, but that’s not true. If a child can’t decode basic reading words or solve simple algebra problems, that will almost always show up in their grade, no matter how well they follow instructions. But what we don’t talk about enough is how much of a typical student’s grade is tied to compliance, not mastery. Points off for late work, points off for wrong formatting, points off for not following the exact step-by-step instructions even when the end result is correct. That’s not measuring learning. That’s measuring how good a kid is at doing exactly what they’re told, when they’re told to do it.
I’ve started adjusting my own grading over the past two years, after that conference with Mia’s mom. Now I split my grading into two separate categories: content, which is 90% of the final grade, and compliance, which is 10%. If a kid forgets their name on the paper or turns it in a day late, they lose a point or two, not a full letter grade. If they get all the content right but solve it their own way, they still get full credit. I also post all rubrics online a week before assignments are due, and I add a line that says “Extra research and creative additions are always welcome, no points off for going off-script.”
For parents, the simplest change I recommend is to stop asking your kid “what grade did you get” as soon as they climb into the car after school. Ask “what’s the coolest thing you learned this week” instead. It shifts the focus back to actual learning, not just a number or letter. When your kid does bring home a bad grade, sit down and go through the paper with them to see where points were deducted. If most of the lost points are for formatting, late work, or not following instructions, point that out out loud: “Look, 18 of the 25 points you lost are because the outline was the wrong format. That means this grade doesn’t say anything about how good you are at history. It just says you didn’t follow that one rule.” It keeps kids from internalizing the idea that they’re bad at a subject just because they got a bad grade for something that has nothing to do with what they know.
After that conference with Mia’s mom, I brought the rubric issue back to my grade-level team. We ended up shifting all our rubrics to weight content 90% too, and Mia re-submitted her lab report with the sections in the right order, and her grade went up to an A. It was an easy fix, but it took a parent pointing out the obvious gap between what Mia knew and what her grade said for us to make the change.
Last week, Mia ran up to me before class with a chunk of granite she’d dug up at her grandma’s house, pointing out the tiny quartz crystals inside. She didn’t get points for that rock. It wasn’t on any assignment, it didn’t fit any rubric. But that’s the learning that sticks, right? I still have to follow some school-wide grading rules that I don’t agree with, and I still end up arguing for my own son when points get taken off for silly rule breaks. The system isn’t going to change overnight. But for me, the work starts with noticing when a grade isn’t telling the whole story. Some of the best learners I know are terrible at following every little instruction. And that’s not a problem to fix. It’s just something the grading system hasn’t caught up to yet.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Do Grades Measure Learning Or Just How Well Kids Follow Instructions