Do Grades Measure Learning or Just How Well Kids Follow Instructions? A Teacher’s Perspective
The half-eaten peanut butter granola bar on my conference table crumbled when I pushed it aside to pull out Milo’s dinosaur project. His mom leaned forward, squinting at the B+ scrawled at the top of his 4th grade science report card, and shook her head. “He spends three hours every night reading dinosaur research papers I can barely understand. He can name every species in the Jurassic period. Why is he not an A here?”
I flipped open the tri-fold poster to show her what had happened. The assignment called for students to fill in a pre-labeled T-Rex anatomy diagram, glue it to their poster, and list three key adaptations. It was a simple 100-point assignment, designed to assess whether kids could connect body structure to survival.
Milo skipped the pre-printed diagram entirely. He drew his own 2-foot T-Rex across the entire poster, labeled 17 different adaptations, and added side notes about how new research changed old ideas about T-Rex arm strength and speed. His work was far more thorough than any other project I’d graded that semester. But because he didn’t follow the first instruction to use the provided template, he lost 15 points. That dropped him from an A to a B+.
I admitted that to his mom that day: That grade doesn’t reflect what Milo knows. It reflects that he didn’t do the assignment the way I told him to. That conversation got me thinking harder about the question I hear from parents all the time: What do grades actually measure, anyway?
I see this play out almost every week in my classroom. Last month, our reading unit focused on character motivation. The assignment was a five-paragraph essay answering how the main character changed over the course of the novel. Lila, who reads way above grade level and loves picking apart plot holes and contradictions, turned in two tight, thoughtful paragraphs that analyzed the protagonist’s conflicting motivations in a way most high school students wouldn’t pull off. She refused to write three more filler paragraphs just to hit the required length. She got a C. The student who wrote five generic paragraphs that basically paraphrased the book’s back cover got an A. He followed all the rules, so he got the reward.
It’s not that following instructions doesn’t matter at all. Kids do need to learn how to meet basic expectations as they move up to middle and high school, and eventually into work. But the problem is, our current grading system weights rule-following so heavily that it often completely overshadows actual learning. A few years ago, a study out of Stanford found that a large chunk of the grade gap between low-income and higher-income students has less to do with academic ability and more to do with how much outside support students have to remember and follow every tiny direction—from signing permission slips to formatting essays with the correct font. That makes sense. A kid who goes home to watch their younger siblings while their parent works a second shift isn’t as likely to remember that the assignment needs a heading in 12-point Times New Roman. That doesn’t mean they didn’t learn the material.
For parents who’ve left a parent-teacher conference confused why their curious, knowledgeable kid has a lower grade than you expected, there are small, low-effort things you can do to shift the focus back to learning, instead of just grades. First, swap your opening dinner question. Instead of starting with “What grade did you get on your test?” ask “What’s the coolest thing you learned this week that didn’t get a grade?” That one small shift changes the whole conversation, and you’ll often be surprised by what your kid shares that they never mentioned before. If your kid comes home with a bad grade, don’t open with “Why didn’t you follow the directions?” First ask “Can you show me what you learned from this assignment?” Nine times out of ten, they’ll be able to walk you through the concept, even if they missed points for formatting. One last small thing: Keep a bin or a bulletin board at home for ungraded work. That’s where you put the 30-page dinosaur book your kid wrote, the extra art they drew, the essay they wrote that didn’t fit the teacher’s requirements. It’s a tangible reminder that learning doesn’t need a letter next to it to count.
For teachers, the small change I made a couple of years ago that doesn’t require admin approval or a full curriculum overhaul is simple: I cap points lost for not following instructions at 10% of the total grade. That means even if you don’t use the template, even if your essay is a paragraph short, you can still get an A as long as your content proves you mastered the learning objective. If a student can show me they understand the material, I let them redo the assignment for a higher grade without holding the original direction misstep against them. It’s a tiny change, but it’s encouraged more kids to bring their creative ideas to class instead of just checking boxes.
After my conference with Milo’s mom, I changed his grade to an A and wrote a note on the back of his poster that said “Your diagram is way better than our template anyway.” He still doesn’t like using pre-printed worksheets. He still loses a couple of points every now and then when he forgets to write his name at the top of his paper. He’s still more interested in pursuing his own dinosaur deep dives than following my step-by-step instructions. I still have to follow district grading guidelines sometimes, and I can’t always change grades the way I want. I don’t think we’ll rewrite the whole system overnight. But every time I enter a grade into my book, I try to remember: That letter doesn’t tell you half of what a kid actually knows.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Do Grades Measure Learning or Just How Well Kids Follow Instructions