Do GCSE Exams Get Disqualified If You Write Messages To The Examiner? A Teacher Explains
The kettle had just boiled in the year 11 common room on results day when Mia appeared in the doorway, twisting her old year 10 lanyard so tight her knuckles were white. She’d been waiting 20 minutes off to one side, and I could tell whatever she wanted wasn’t a quick question about sixth form enrolment. ‘Miss,’ she said, leaning in like she was about to admit she’d stolen a display board pen, ‘I need to ask you something. I wrote a note on the back of my maths GCSE paper in June. Am I gonna get disqualified?’
She explained the note was just three lines: Sorry I didn’t finish the last question. My nan went into hospital for emergency surgery the night before this exam, and I couldn’t focus. She’d seen a TikTok a week earlier that said any extra writing to examiners gets your whole paper thrown out, and she’d been spiraling ever since, convinced she’d lost her spot on the sixth form PE course she’d worked two years to get.
I remembered the same question coming up two years earlier, when a Year 11 boy wrote “Please give me a C I need this for bricklaying college” on the back of his construction GCSE, and his mum called the school at 8pm the night after the exam screaming that we needed to fix it before he got disqualified. I went to find Jean, our exams officer who’s been doing this job longer than I’ve been teaching, to ask what the actual rule is. She was sitting at her desk sorting exam access arrangement stickers, a half-empty PG Tips mug next to her cat-sticker-covered laptop, and she laughed when I asked.
“Three or four of these every exam series,” she said. “Kids see nonsense online and panic. No, a little note isn’t going to get your whole GCSE disqualified. Only time it’s a problem is if it breaks the actual misconduct rules.”
She went on to explain what actually happens: Examiners are trained to mark only the candidate’s answers, and ignore any extra notes, doodles, or messages that aren’t part of the answer. The only time a paper gets sent up for investigation is if the message is abusive, contains a confession of cheating, identifies the candidate when they’re not supposed to (a rule to stop bias), or threatens someone. Even then, disqualification isn’t automatic. If a kid writes an abusive note because they’re having a meltdown mid-exam, the school will usually get contacted first to talk about context, and only the really severe, deliberate cases end up with disqualification. The note that says “sorry I’m nervous” or “thank you for marking” or even “this exam was terrible I hate it” doesn’t even get a second glance from the examiner.
After Mia told me her story, I walked down to Jean’s office with her, and Jean pulled up the official JCQ misconduct rules on her screen to show her. No mention of extra casual messages leading to disqualification, just that misconduct covers things like cheating, bringing a phone in, or threatening behaviour. Mia relaxed a little, but she still hovered while we opened her results envelope. When she saw she’d got the 5 she needed, she let out a scream so loud the office next door popped their head round the door.
This question comes up so often now, mostly because of viral TikTok videos that overstate the risk to get views. I’ve had four parents email me in the last 12 months asking the exact same question Mia did, after their kid admitted to writing a note to the examiner. One was a kid who wrote “hope you have a nice day” on the back of his paper, and his mum was convinced he’d thrown away three years of work. That’s the thing people don’t talk about: 9 times out of 10, kids write these messages because they’re anxious, not because they’re being silly. They don’t know that the official way to get context like a family emergency considered is through the school’s special consideration process, so they think writing a note is their only shot at explaining why their work isn’t as good as it could be.
That’s where the practical stuff comes in, for parents and teachers. If your kid comes to you after an exam saying they wrote a note, don’t panic first. Don’t start firing off emails to the exam board or spiral with them. Pull up the JCQ’s public misconduct guidelines online, show them the actual wording, and remind them that only deliberate rule-breaking leads to disqualification. If the note was explaining an ongoing issue like a family emergency or a sudden illness, that’s when you contact the school’s exams officer to put in a special consideration request – that’s the official process that actually gets context taken into account, not the note the kid wrote on the paper. If you’re talking to kids before exams, take two minutes at the dinner table or in pre-exam registration to say this explicitly: If you need context about a problem you’re having during exams, tell your teacher or exams officer first, we’ll sort it officially. Writing a note on the paper won’t hurt you, but it won’t help you either.
Last month, I was marking year 10 mock papers, and I found a little note scrawled at the bottom of a literature answer: “Sorry this is bad, I stayed up late to watch the Champions League final.” I marked the answer exactly how I would have if the note wasn’t there, it got a solid 4 out of 10, which is where the kid’s work landed that day. I mentioned it to him after mocks, and he blushed and said he just felt like he needed to explain why it was worse than usual. I told him what I tell all my kids now: if something comes up during the real GCSEs, come find me first, we’ll do the official request. He nodded, grabbed his bag, and ran off to lunch.
There’s still going to be kids who write little notes, every single exam series. Most of the time, it’s just a nervous 15 or 16 year old wanting someone to know their side of the story. It doesn’t have to turn into a crisis, as long as we know the actual rules, and don’t buy into the viral panic that spreads online.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Do GCSE Exams Get Disqualified If You Write Messages To The Examiner