Did I Overprepare My Kid for College Freshman Year? Real Parent Lessons From Move-In Season
Last August, three weeks before my oldest son Sam’s college move-in, I stood at my kitchen counter sorting microwave popcorn and individual oatmeal into a hard plastic lidded bin. My sister texted a photo of her kid’s dorm pantry, which held exactly one jar of generic peanut butter and a crumpled bag of pretzels. My bin already held 12 travel-sized spice packets, a foldable set of measuring cups, three jars of low-sugar pasta sauce, and a pack of reusable paper bowls I’d grabbed on sale at Target. I stared at the photo, then at my overflowing counter, and the question popped into my head that I’d been pushing down for months: Did I just cook myself—wear myself out with all this unnecessary prep—for freshman year?
Back in March, I joined the parent Facebook group for Sam’s college, and that’s where the anxiety started. Every other thread was some parent warning that kids leave home unable to boil an egg or sort lights from darks, and it’s all our fault for doing too much for them growing up. I went home that night and made a “life skills checklist” that was two pages long. Every Sunday after graduation, we blocked off an hour to work through it. I taught Sam how to unclog a drain with a plunger, how to thread a sewing needle to fix a loose button, how to scramble eggs without burning them, how to sort laundry. One Sunday, he paused mid-fold of a fitted sheet and said, “Mom, I did all the laundry and cooked scrambled eggs every night for two weeks when you broke your ankle in 10th grade. I remember.” I waved him off. “That was here. It’s different when you don’t have me to ask.” He rolled his eyes but kept going.
Move-in was humid and chaotic; we hauled his boxes up three flights of stairs, I arranged his sheets on the extra-long twin, stocked the mini fridge with his favorite soda and cut-up fruit, slid my big pantry bin into the tiny closet under his desk. When we were done, I hugged him so tight he complained I was wrinkling his new hoodie, then got in my car to drive home. I spent the entire ride checking my phone every two minutes, waiting for the first panic text: how do I do this? Where do I buy that? The first text came two hours later: “Jake (my roommate) says thanks for the extra granola bars. Can you ship my blue baseball cap that I left on my desk?” That was it. No panic, no questions.
The first weekend he came home, I grabbed my keys to go get his laundry hamper out of the car, ready to throw a load in while he hung out with his old friends. He stopped me at the door. “I already did my laundry at the dorm,” he said, shifting his backpack. “Just brought my dirty sheets to swap out for clean ones from home.” Later, when I was unpacking the grocery bag he brought back to restock, I found half of my spice packets tucked in the bottom. Him and his three suitemates, it turned out, all had parents who packed them spice sets. They ended up with four bottles of garlic powder and three of oregano, so he brought the extras home to me.
That night, I went back to the Facebook group and saw a new thread asking what critical skills parents missed prepping their kids for freshman year. I scrolled through hundreds of comments, listing everything from doing taxes to changing a tire to roasting a whole chicken, and I finally asked myself the question out loud: why did I do all this? I knew Sam could do laundry. I knew he could scramble eggs. I just got caught up in the collective panic that if I didn’t prep everything ahead of time, he’d fail.
What I’ve learned six months in is that most of the prep we do as parents is for us, not for them. It’s our way of coping with the anxiety of letting go, not actually meeting a need our kid has. That said, there are a few small, concrete things that actually helped that I’d do again, and the rest I’d skip. First, instead of a three-month life skill bootcamp, do a one weekend check-in that sticks to three clear groups: things they’ll definitely need in the first 30 days, things they can learn when they need them, and things they can call you to troubleshoot. For the first group, I’d only keep five items: how to contact maintenance for a dorm issue, how to add money to their meal plan, how to wash a load of laundry if they’ve never done it, how to change a bed sheet, and where to find the free campus health clinic. Everything else—cooking a full meal, unclogging a toilet, changing the oil in their car—can wait until they actually need to do it. Sam didn’t need to know how to fix a loose button on his shirt the first week of school; he could ask his suitemate for a safety pin, bring it home when he visited, or learn to fix it when he actually has time.
Second, when packing, leave 10% of the space in their car empty. Don’t buy every single thing you think they’ll need before move-in. Let them pick up small items once they see their space, meet their roommates, and figure out what they actually use. This avoids wasted money and duplicate items like our extra garlic powder, a problem I still laugh about.
Third, when they call you with a problem, resist the urge to immediately tell them what to do or offer to drive up and fix it. Ask them what they’ve tried first. Last month, Sam called me because his laptop wouldn’t connect to the campus Wi-Fi. I almost said “I’ll be there in an hour and a half” then I remembered this trick, so I said “What have you tried so far?” He said he turned it off and on again, that didn’t work. I said “Okay, what does the campus IT website say to do next?” He looked it up, reset his network settings, and it worked. He was prouder of that than he would’ve been if I fixed it for him.
Last week, Sam called me after he tried to make spaghetti for his friend group. He forgot to salt the pasta water, so the whole thing was bland, and they ended up ordering pizza anyway. I offered to send him a quick cheat sheet for basic pasta cooking, and he said “No, it’s fine. I’ll remember next time.” We hung up, and I walked over to the desk where I already started a packing list for his study abroad trip next fall. I crossed out three lines of things I didn’t need to pack, closed the notebook, and went to make coffee. I still don’t know if I did the perfect job prepping him for freshman year. Some days I think I did too much, some days I’m glad I walked through the basics when I did. What I do know is that he’s figuring it out, one bland spaghetti dinner at a time, and I’m learning to stop cooking myself before he even needs the meal.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Did I Overprepare My Kid for College Freshman Year