Choosing Between AP Cybersecurity and Honors Spanish 3 for Junior Year: A Parent’s Real Experience
The pepperoni grease stain on my kitchen table is still there from 8:30 last Wednesday, when my 16-year-old Sam slid his Valley High School course selection sheet across the wood and stared at me like I held the answer to life. The only open elective slot for junior year, and it was down to two options: VHS AP Cybersecurity or Honors Spanish 3. Sam’s half-empty blue Gatorade sweated on the table next to his phone, which was open to a group chat of his friends all arguing over which one to pick. “Everyone’s saying the AP looks way better for comp sci,” he said, picking at the hole in the elbow of his Minecraft hoodie. “But Ms. Henderson, my guidance counselor, says if I don’t take Spanish 3 now, I can’t get into the state flagship even if my grades are good.”
I grew up taking four years of Spanish, so my first instinct was to just tell him to follow the counselor’s advice. That’s what I do when I’m stressed about big choices for my kids—default to the path that felt right when I was in school. But then I remembered last year, when I pushed him to take AP Bio because I thought it would look good for any STEM major. He hated it, pulled a C in the first semester, and didn’t talk about any college plans for almost two months. I bit my tongue and said we’d figure it out step by step instead of deciding over takeout pizza.
The first thing I suggested was that we talk to the actual teachers, not just rely on the course guide or a 10-minute meeting with a counselor who has 200 students on her caseload. We emailed both teachers the next morning, and they both had 15 minutes for us after school. Mr. Torres, the new AP Cybersecurity teacher, was straight with us from the start. It’s a new AP exam, he said, so not every four-year college accepts it for credit yet. The class is 4-5 hours of work a week, most kids who like computers get Bs or higher, but the portfolio you build of projects is way more useful for college apps than the AP score itself. He even said students don’t have to be enrolled to work on portfolio projects in the school’s computer lab after school.
Then we talked to Ms. Lopez, who’s taught Honors Spanish 3 at VHS for 12 years. She pulled up Sam’s transcript right there on her desk and pointed out that his high B in Spanish 2 meant he’d be fine in the honors section. She also confirmed that at our school, honors classes get the same 0.5 GPA weight as APs, so Sam wouldn’t lose any GPA points for picking Spanish over the AP. Most importantly, she restated what the counselor had said: the University of Oregon, where Sam wants to apply for computer science, requires three years of the same foreign language for admission, no exceptions, even for STEM majors. I’d heard that from other parents, but I’d also seen dozens of conflicting comments on our parent Facebook group saying two years was enough. It was good to hear it straight from someone who’d helped hundreds of kids apply to the school.
We stopped at the local ice cream shop on the way home, and Sam got a mint chocolate chip waffle cone. He kicked a rock across the parking lot and said, “I don’t even want to be a translator. Why do I need Spanish for a coding job?” I didn’t give him a speech about how useful Spanish is for every job now, because I knew he wasn’t going to listen. Instead I just asked him two questions, that’s it. First: “If you get home from soccer practice at 6, which of these classes are you actually going to sit down and do the homework for without me nagging you ten times?” He thought for a minute, licking ice cream off his wrist, and said the Spanish homework would probably be faster, because cybersecurity projects would suck him in and he’d stay up till 10 working on them and be tired for first period. Second: “What happens if it doesn’t work out? If you take AP Cy and you get a lower grade than you expect, and you still don’t have your third year of Spanish, can you fix that senior year?” He shook his head. Senior year he’s already planning on taking AP Comp Sci and Physics, and cramming a full year of Spanish on top of that would be impossible.
That’s when it clicked for both of us. I’ve spent a lot of time reading college advice that says you should stack as many APs as possible to impress admissions officers, but that advice misses the most basic step: check the actual requirements for the schools your kid actually wants to go to, not the rumor mill. I went home that night and pulled up the UO admissions page myself, and sure enough, the three-year world language requirement is printed plain as day on the first page of the admissions checklist. The second thing I’ve learned that other parents can copy is this: don’t make the choice for your kid. Ask them those two simple questions about daily effort and worst-case scenario, and let them work through the tradeoffs. It’s their schedule, after all.
We also found a good middle ground through that conversation with Mr. Torres. Sam joined the after-school cybersecurity club, which meets twice a week, and Mr. Torres said he can work on the same AP portfolio projects as the enrolled students, so he’ll still have that project to show admissions officers when he applies.
Sam ended up enrolling in Honors Spanish 3. He still complains about it every Sunday, when he has to finish his weekly vocab quiz before soccer practice. He’s at cybersecurity club right now, as I’m writing this, and he texted me 20 minutes ago that he’s halfway through a malware detection project he’ll add to his college portfolio. We still don’t know if this is the right choice long term. If he changes his mind and wants to go to a private college out of state that doesn’t care about the third year of Spanish, he’ll have wasted a slot on something he doesn’t care that much about. If he’d taken AP Cybersecurity, maybe he’d have a more impressive line on his transcript. But right now, it fits. He’s not overwhelmed, he’s still getting to pursue the thing he cares about, and he hasn’t closed any doors before he’s even gotten to the application stage. That’s enough for this year.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Choosing Between AP Cybersecurity and Honors Spanish 3 for Junior Year: A Parent’s Real Experience