Are Some DSOs Actually Better Run Than Others? What I Learned Picking a Family Dental Network
My coffee had gone cold and my two kids were fighting over the last chocolate granola bar on the floor when I realized I actually had to pick a new family dentist. Open enrollment for our dental insurance had popped up in my email three weeks earlier, and my long-time local dentist had just retired, so every option on the in-network list was new to me. Half of them were labeled as part of something called a DSO, which I’d heard a few friends complain about as corporate, money-grubbing chains. But one of my coworkers swore by her DSO dentist, said it was the most flexible, reliable care she’d ever had for her three kids. So I had the same question a million other parents probably have: are some DSOs actually better run than others, or is it all the same garbage?
I started with the closest option, 10 minutes from our elementary school, listed as part of a large national DSO. The waiting room was decked out in bright primary colors, with two blaring TVs playing kids’ cartoons and a vending machine full of soda. I signed in for my new patient cleaning and waited 25 minutes, even with a confirmed appointment. The hygienist rushed through the work, didn’t ask if I had any concerns about sensitivity, and left before I could ask a question about a weird spot on my gum. The dentist popped in 10 minutes later, flipped through my chart for 30 seconds, and told me I needed a $300 custom night guard for grinding, both my kids needed immediate new sealants (even though I’d written on my form that my 10-year-old got sealants just 12 months prior), and my 7-year-old had two small cavities that needed filling right away. I left feeling like I’d just walked out of a used car lot, like every recommendation had a price tag attached to it.
A mom from my older kid’s soccer team suggested I try another practice 15 minutes further out, also a DSO. When I called to book, the front desk asked right away if anyone in my family had allergies or anxiety about dental visits. I mentioned my 7-year-old’s peanut allergy and hatred of loud noise, and she said they’d keep peanut-free snacks on hand and turn down the office music when we came in. I decided to book my own cleaning first, to test the vibe before dragging the kids in. I waited 7 minutes, the hygienist adjusted the water pressure when I mentioned sensitivity, and explained every step of what she was doing before she started. When the dentist came in, she pulled up the old x-rays I’d emailed over from my previous dentist, agreed that my 10-year-old didn’t need new sealants, and said my occasional grinding was mild enough that a $10 over-the-counter guard would work just as well as a custom one. When I asked what being part of a DSO meant for her practice, she laughed and said, “They handle all the insurance billing and supply orders, so I don’t have to stay up until 10 PM doing paperwork every night. I get to leave work on time to pick my own kid up from soccer, same as you.”
That experience made me dig a little into how DSOs actually work, because I’d always assumed they were all just big corporate chains with the same rules. Turns out I was wrong. DSO just stands for Dental Service Organization—basically a group that handles all the non-clinical work for dental practices: billing, HR, marketing, bulk buying of supplies. The big difference between DSOs is what they ask for in return. Some DSOs, especially the ones owned by private equity, set monthly revenue quotas for each practice, requiring dentists hit a certain number of fillings, crowns, or cosmetic procedures to keep their contract. That’s where all the upselling and unnecessary treatments come from. Other DSOs are owned by the dentists themselves, and the only service they provide is taking admin work off the dentists’ plates so they can spend more time with patients. There’s no quota, no pressure to sell extra stuff. That’s why two DSOs can feel like completely different worlds.
I’ve shared this with three other parents in my neighborhood this year, all of whom were hunting for a new family dentist, and I have a few simple things I tell them to do that don’t take a lot of time. First, don’t cross every DSO off your list just because you heard one bad story, and don’t assume any DSO is automatically good because it has a big advertising budget. Second, when you call to book an appointment, just ask one straight question: “Do the dentists here set their own treatment plans, or are there required quotas for procedures?” Most front desk staff will answer you honestly, and if they hem and haw or give you a vague answer about “corporate guidelines,” that’s a red flag. Third, always go for your own cleaning first before bringing the kids in. It’s way easier to judge the vibe when you’re not distracted by calming a nervous kid, and you’ll see first hand how the practice treats patients. Fourth, call your insurance company and ask if the practice charges any extra facility fees that aren’t covered by your plan. The first DSO I visited charged a $25 “administrative fee” per visit that wasn’t covered, which adds up fast when four people go twice a year. The second one doesn’t charge any extra fees at all.
We’ve been going to this second DSO for six months now. Last month, my 7-year-old chipped his tooth falling off his bike at the park, and they got him in within an hour. They fixed it, didn’t try to sell us on a more expensive crown we didn’t need, and the bill came out exactly what the insurance said it would. It’s 15 minutes further from our house than I’d like, but it works for us right now. I still think it’s kind of messed up that picking a dentist for your kids requires this much detective work, just because there’s so much variation in how these groups are run. I don’t know what I’ll do when we move, or when my current dentist retires, or when open enrollment rolls around next year and all the in-network options change again. But I do know one thing now: asking a few simple questions up front goes a lot further than just assuming every DSO is the same.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Are Some DSOs Actually Better Run Than Others