Are Quizzes Enough To Learn A Skill, Or Do They Only Help Memorization? A Teacher’s Perspective
The chew mark on Mia’s pink eraser was deeper than it had been two weeks earlier, when she showed up to after-school tutoring confused about multi-digit multiplication. She slid her Friday quiz across the table, 10 out of 10 written in red pen at the top. “I don’t get it,” she said, twisting the end of her braid. “I got everything right here, but when Mrs. Lee put that cookie problem on the board this morning, I forgot what to do.”
The problem was simple on paper: the 4th grade was hosting a bake sale, needed 24 cookies for each of 12 classes, how many total cookies did they need to bake? The quiz she’d aced had only had straight calculation problems: 12 x 34, 56 x 78, all set up for her, all she had to do was recall the steps for carrying over the tens place and multiply. Staring at the word problem, she couldn’t even tell me which numbers she needed to multiply.
I’ve been a 4th grade intervention teacher for 8 years, and a parent for 10, so this moment wasn’t entirely new. But it stuck with me, because it cut straight to the question I’ve been asking myself a lot lately: are quizzes just for memorization, or can they actually help you learn a skill?
A week later, I saw the exact same thing play out at home. My 10-year-old son came home from his after-school cooking club bragging that he’d aced his measuring quiz. He could rattle off how many teaspoons are in a tablespoon, explain that you’re supposed to level off dry ingredients with a knife, all the facts the leader had quizzed them on. Sunday morning, I asked him to measure flour for pancakes, and he scooped straight from the bag with the measuring cup, packing it down tight like you do with brown sugar. We ended up with dense, flat pancakes that we ate anyway covered in syrup, but it drove the point home: the quiz had proven he could memorize the rules. It hadn’t taught him to actually measure flour correctly.
Quizzes get a bad rap sometimes, but I don’t think they’re useless. Memorization is a part of learning any skill. If you can’t remember your multiplication facts, you can’t focus on solving a word problem because you’re too busy counting on your fingers. If you can’t remember how many teaspoons are in a tablespoon, you have to stop and look it up mid-recipe, which throws off your whole rhythm. Quizzes are great for cementing that basic memorization, and for giving you a quick check to see what you still need to practice. The problem comes when we stop at the quiz. If the only practice you get is quizzing recall, you never learn to use what you’ve memorized in a new situation—and that’s what actually learning a skill is.
I used to think I needed to add big, time-consuming projects to get that application in, but I’ve learned it doesn’t take that much. After Mia’s quiz moment, I adjusted how I do practice sessions with my tutoring students, and I started applying the same small change at home with my son. It’s just this: after every 3 or 4 straight recall quiz questions, I add one quick application question. That’s it. It adds 5 minutes max to a study session, no extra prep work needed.
For Mia, that meant after we quizzed 3 multiplication problems, we’d do one quick real-life scenario. If we just did 12 x 24, I’d ask “how many trading cards do you have if you have 12 packs with 24 cards each?” It doesn’t have to be complicated. For my son’s spelling tests, that means after I quiz him on 5 words, I ask him to make up a silly sentence using two of them. When he was studying state capitals last month, after quizzing 4 capitals, I asked “which of these capitals do you think gets the most snow, and why?” It’s a tiny shift, but it makes a big difference.
A week after that first tutoring session, Mia took her unit test. She missed one straight calculation problem, but she got every word problem right. She told me she just stopped and asked herself “what do I actually need to find out here?” before she started writing numbers down. That’s the skill, right? Not just recalling steps, but figuring out when and how to use them.
I still forget to add those extra application questions half the time. Quizzes are easy. They’re quick to grade, quick to administer, and it feels like you’re getting something done when you drill flashcards for 20 minutes before a test. Last week, I caught myself just quizzing my son on vocabulary words for his science test, no extra questions, and I had to stop halfway and add one: “what’s an example of a plant that uses photosynthesis that we have in our backyard?” He stared for a minute, then pointed out the window at our rose bush, and we talked about it for two minutes. It wasn’t fancy, it didn’t take a lot of time, but it turned memorizing a definition into actually understanding what the word means.
Right now, that small shift is working for me. It doesn’t fix every learning gap, and it doesn’t mean every kid will master every skill on the first try. Mia still mixes up which operation to use on word problems sometimes, and I still catch my son measuring flour wrong when he’s in a hurry. But it answers the question I’ve been asking: quizzes help you memorize the basics you need to learn a skill, but they’re never enough on their own. You have to use what you memorize to actually learn it.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Are Quizzes Enough To Learn A Skill, Or Do They Only Help Memorization