Am I Wrong Or Right When My Kid Challenges My Rules? Real Parenting Guidance
Last Tuesday, I was wiping strawberry jam off the kitchen counter when my 10-year-old, Milo, slammed his math workbook down and yelled that I was wrong. Our standing rule is no Nintendo Switch until all homework is done and checked. He’d finished the required first two pages, skipped three extra credit problems at the end, and insisted his teacher said any unfinished work could be turned in the next morning at homeroom. I told him the rule still stood. He called me unfair, ran to his room, and slammed the door hard enough that the framed photo of our dog fell off the wall. I stood there holding a sticky sponge, cold coffee sweating through my mug, and thought exactly what lingers for most of us in these moments: Am I wrong or am I right?
I work part-time as a first grade teacher, so I spend most weekdays guiding other parents through these exact questions. Just that week, a mom emailed me asking if she was wrong to let her son skip his 20 minutes of nightly reading because he’d had a meltdown after soccer practice. Another asked if she was right to make her daughter apologize to a friend even though her daughter swore the fight wasn’t her fault. I give casual answers there, but when it’s my own kid yelling behind a closed door, all the generic advice flies right out of my head.
I leaned against the counter and sorted through both sides of the argument like I was sorting laundry. On the “I’m wrong” side: He’d had a six-hour school day followed by a 45-minute piano lesson. The extra credit problems didn’t even affect his grade. I was just being rigid because I wanted to stick to my after-school routine, not because this actually mattered. If I kept this up, he’d stop coming to me when he’s actually upset about something big. On the “I’m right” side: We made this rule together at the start of the school year, after he rushed through three assignments to play games and forgot to turn them in at all. He knew the expectation. If I back down now because he yelled, that just teaches him that raising his voice gets him what he wants.
I didn’t go knock on his door right away. That’s the first small thing I’ve learned to do that makes a difference, instead of storming in to keep fighting or caving immediately to stop the noise. I picked up the photo of the dog, wiped down the counter, poured that cold coffee into a new mug and drank it. I gave both of us 10 minutes to cool off. That’s it—10 minutes, no more, no less. It’s enough time to stop reacting from frustration, not enough time for me to spiral into overthinking every bad choice I’ve ever made.
After 10 minutes, I walked to his door and leaned against it, talking through the wood: “I’m not here to argue. I want to hear why you’re so mad, whenever you’re ready.” Three minutes later, he opened the door, hair messy from face-planting into his pillow, and said he’d already planned to play Minecraft with his best friend for an hour before dinner, and if he did the extra credit now, he’d miss the whole play session. I pulled his workbook out of his backpack, flipped to the end, and checked the teacher’s note stapled to the front. He was right—the three problems were optional extra credit, not required.
I used to think that if I set a rule, I had to stick to it 100% or I was a weak parent who couldn’t enforce boundaries. When I first started teaching, I thought the same thing about classroom rules: bend once, and the whole class will walk all over you. But after eight years in the classroom and 10 years of parenting, I’ve learned that almost no situation is fully black or white. I can be wrong about the detail and right about the core rule at the same time. That day, I told him: “You’re right, I messed up. I thought those problems were required. Our rule is no Switch until required homework is done, and yours is finished. You can go play, but if you forget to do the extra credit tomorrow, that’s your call. I won’t bug you about it.” He nodded, grabbed his Switch, and that was the end of the fight.
That’s the concrete thing I tell other parents when they ask me what to do when they’re stuck on this am I wrong or right question: separate the core from the detail. Name it in your head if you need to: what’s the non-negotiable thing we agreed on? In this case, it was that required homework gets done before screens. Everything else is detail. If you got the detail wrong, say it plainly. You don’t need to make a big, dramatic apology that undermines your authority—just “I got that wrong, let’s adjust.” It models that being wrong is okay, which is one of the most important things kids can learn anyway.
Last month, I insisted a kid in my class put away his fidget toy during a test, and later found out his doctor said he needed it to focus. I apologized, gave it back, and adjusted my rule for him moving forward. No one lost respect for me, the test didn’t descend into chaos, and that kid felt seen. Two weeks ago, I stuck to my rule that Milo can’t have a friend over on a school night even though he begged, and that turned out fine—he got enough sleep and didn’t fall apart in class the next day.
I still leave some moments wondering if I got it wrong. There’s no perfect answer that fits every situation. Sometimes I stick to my guns and it works out, sometimes I adjust and it works out, and every once in a while I get it fully wrong, and we clean that up the next day. Most nights, I don’t leave knowing for sure if I was 100% right or 100% wrong. I just leave knowing we talked about it, we adjusted what needed adjusting, and we’re all okay for tonight. That’s enough more often than not.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Am I Wrong Or Right When My Kid Challenges My Rules