Am I Wrong For Not Making My Kid Share Every Toy? A Parent’s Real Experience
Last Saturday, I was flipping burgers on the grill when I heard the sharp, clear “no” from my backyard. My 7-year-old Leo had his new birthday Lego dinosaur pressed to his chest, jaw set, as his friend Mia leaned in waiting. It was the set he’d begged for for three months, the one we spent two hours putting together the night before his party, the tiny rider figurine he’d slept with every night since. Mia’s mom laughed and shifted her potato salad on the picnic table. “Oh, come on, Leo. Sharing is caring, right?” She glanced over at me, the unspoken question hanging in the air: Aren’t you going to do something?
I wiped my hands on my jeans and walked over. “That dinosaur’s really special to Leo right now, isn’t it, buddy?” I said. “It’s okay to say no if you don’t want to share it yet. Mia, the water table’s out back, and there’s that new bubble machine we got last week if you want to go check that out.” Mia shrugged and ran off, and five minutes later she was chasing the dog around the yard, no tears, no hurt feelings. Leo carried his dinosaur around for another hour, then set it down to make a mud pie, and Mia picked it up and played with it no problem.
But after everyone left, and the grill was cold, and the last paper plate was thrown away, I found myself standing at the kitchen sink thinking about it. Am I in the wrong here? I’ve read a dozen parenting posts that say forcing kids to share teaches them kindness, that kids who won’t share are being rude, that it’s my job to teach them social skills. I grew up with that rule: anything you have, you share, no exceptions. When I was 8, I had a hand-me-down porcelain doll that I kept on my pillow, the only thing I had that was just mine. My little cousin fell in love with it when she visited, and my mom made me give it to her for the weekend. I cried in the hallway closet after everyone went to bed, and I still remember that hollow feeling of having something that mattered taken away because I was supposed to be nice.
I brought my question to Leo’s first grade teacher at our parent-teacher conference two weeks later. She’s been teaching for 22 years, and she leaned back in her chair and nodded like she gets this question all the time. She said most forced sharing doesn’t actually teach what we think it does. When you take a toy away from a kid who’s still playing with it to give it to another kid, they don’t learn kindness. They learn that their feelings don’t matter, that the adults in their life will take what’s theirs just to keep the peace. That’s not a lesson I want Leo to learn.
Over the last year, we’ve worked out a small system that works for us, and it takes almost no extra work. Before any playdate, Leo and I spend three minutes going through his toy bins. He picks up to three toys that are special enough to be off-limits, and we put them on the top shelf of his closet, out of sight. Everything else is fair game, but even then, he gets to say no if he’s still playing with it. If another kid asks, I don’t step in and force him to hand it over. I just say, “Leo is playing with that right now. When he’s done, he’ll let you know. Want to pick something else to play with while you wait?” I never call him selfish or rude for saying no. I just name the feeling for him: “I get it, you just built that, you want to look at it a little longer. That makes sense.”
It’s not perfect. I still get side-eye from other parents sometimes. Last month at a playground playdate, another mom made a comment loud enough for me to hear about how some parents let their kids run wild and don’t teach them manners. I felt that hot twinge of doubt, the same one I felt that Saturday after the barbecue. What if I am wrong? What if I’m raising a kid who can’t get along with others?
But then I see the small stuff. A month ago, Leo brought an extra pack of fruit snacks to school and gave it to the new kid who forgot his lunch. Last week, he offered his favorite truck to my neighbor’s toddler who was crying, just because he wanted to make her feel better. That’s real sharing, the kind that comes from wanting to be kind, not because someone made you do it. He doesn’t hesitate to say no when someone asks him to give up a turn on the slide or let someone else borrow his new crayons when he’s still using them, and that’s a boundary I never learned how to set as a kid. I spent most of my childhood and young adulthood saying yes to things I didn’t want to do just to avoid being called rude, and it left me exhausted more often than not.
I still don’t have all the answers. Some days I leave a playdate wondering if I messed up. I’ve had other parents disagree with me outright, and I get where they’re coming from—they want their kid to leave playdates happy too. But so far, this system works for our house. Leo’s happy, his regular playmates know he’s fair, and he’s learning that it’s okay to take care of your own wants before you give something away. I don’t know if that makes me right, or wrong, but it’s what feels right for my kid right now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Am I Wrong For Not Making My Kid Share Every Toy